What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

R15 vs Sydney Roosters

Messages
730
Why the f**k are Kenny, Luke and Salmon all on the field at the time?

All momentum was lost.
I guess it’s par for the course on here for posters to dunk on Kenny after every game but I thought, besides that one horrible pass along the ground, that he had a great game. He put on some enormous hits and was rock solid in defence. He’s also being asked to play big minutes every week because IC, perhaps justifiably, doesn’t trust Luke.
 

Munky

Coach
Messages
12,216
I guess it’s par for the course on here for posters to dunk on Kenny after every game but I thought, besides that one horrible pass along the ground, that he had a great game. He put on some enormous hits and was rock solid in defence. He’s also being asked to play big minutes every week because IC, perhaps justifiably, doesn’t trust Luke.

I did post that during the game not after. 😉

Kenny was decent and had a good pass for Yeo's try (IIRC).

The problem is Luke and Kenny next to each other in the defensive line.

The middle is immediately lost since so much size is given up.
 

WestyLife

First Grade
Messages
7,391
I guess it’s par for the course on here for posters to dunk on Kenny after every game but I thought, besides that one horrible pass along the ground, that he had a great game. He put on some enormous hits and was rock solid in defence. He’s also being asked to play big minutes every week because IC, perhaps justifiably, doesn’t trust Luke.

It's not "Kenny bad" rather "Ivan has a weird bench rotation".
 

Crashtest

Juniors
Messages
1,193
Depends what you want the balance of the side to be.

It is either him or Hosking in the 17

Smith is now our 4th best prop, now that Sorensen has moved to an edge. Hosking is our 3rd best edge forward. They should both be in our 17.
 

Girds89

Bench
Messages
3,242
I reckon one of the best things out of last night was how cogger straightened up luais attack.

His short balls to him running straight onto it really made a big difference.

There was less sweeping out the back plays like cleary does..

Cogger just was giving short early balls and luai really played direct.

Nice change up by Ivan to the normal style... good to see him finally making some changes to the predictable structures
 

Iamback

Referee
Messages
20,439
If Yeo promotes the ball 30cm on halfway with a guy holding his foot he's taking a month long holiday to Canada to get his head scanned.

Maybe medically retired.

Haha.

I mean if that happens near the sideline. Yeo gets up because he broke the tackle

Steps into touch.

He isn't asked to go back and play the ball. It is Roosters ball
 
Messages
730
I think Kenny is doing well for the most part but he seems to be getting overplayed and that’s when he gets understandably sloppy. Playing huge minutes and is involved in every one of them.
Yeah in the modern game I don’t think playing hookers for 80 minutes is ideal. It’s too much to ask them to maintain the necessary level of intensity over that period every week. Koroisau last season for ~60 minutes was perfect.
 

Bob

Juniors
Messages
1,454

Speaking of wankers what about this drivel, Mr Crawley you have excelled your self

NRL Tackle: Ivan Cleary’s hypocrisy on show in explosive fallout to JWH-Spencer Leniu fight​

Ivan Cleary thinks Jared Waerea-Hargreaves was ‘looking for trouble’ in the explosive Roosters-Panthers showdown, but he might need to look a little closer to home, writes Paul Crawley.



NRL: Jared Waerea-Hargreaves and Spencer Leniu have almost come to blows in a huge fiery exchange which resulted in both props heading to the sin bin.
It was a bit rich of Ivan Cleary throwing Jared Waerea-Hargreaves under the bus when accusing the Roosters enforcer of “looking for trouble” in the explosive aftermath to the Panthers’ thumping 30-6 win over the Roosters.

While it is understandable an NRL coach will want to look after his own players, Cleary might want to remember he doesn’t coach a team of choir boys.
And he has one player in particular in Jarome Luai who goes out every single week with what appears a clear intention of looking for trouble, albeit in a very different way to what Cleary was accusing Waerea-Hargreaves of here.
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves and Spencer Leniu come together in a flashpoint at the end of the match. NRL Imagery

Jared Waerea-Hargreaves and Spencer Leniu come together in a flashpoint at the end of the match. NRL Imagery
But in the big prop’s defence, it was outrageous of Cleary to suggest intentional foul play had anything to do with the two ugly incidents involving Liam Martin and Moses Leota.
While Cleary’s comments about Waerea-Hargreaves’ apparent intention to start the trouble were just as ludicrous, with the claim “the balance of probability was that Jared was probably the one initiating it” complete and utter nonsense.
In the incident involving Martin it was the Panthers backrower who came in from the side and hit his head on Waerea-Hargreaves’ hip.
A total accident, which was proven by the fact the NRL did not charge JWH for what happened.
While in respect to Leota, as Trent Robinson said, Waerea-Hargreaves was simply running with his bumpers up like every prop does, and the replays certainly did not indicate to me that he raised his elbow in an act of illegal play. Again, the NRL match review committee agreed.
Penrith coach Ivan Cleary had some choice words to say about Roosters enforcer Jared Waerea-Hargreaves. Picture: Getty

Penrith coach Ivan Cleary had some choice words to say about Roosters enforcer Jared Waerea-Hargreaves. Picture: Getty
You see multiple incidents very similar in most games, just go back to Thursday night when Tino Fa’asuamaleaui broke Api Koroisau’s jaw.
Yet when asked if he had an issue with this one, Cleary didn’t hold back.
“If I’m truthful, I did,” Cleary added. “I think it was very questionable. The way he looked. Where he saw him. The way it (the elbow) was cocked.”
There was a time when rival coaches would steer clear of commenting on incidents likely to go before the NRL match review committee out of respect, especially when the evidence was as unclear as this was.
No doubt, Waerea-Hargreaves over reacted when squirting Spencer Leniu with water before hurling the bottle at him.
Waerea-Hargreaves has a reputation as one of the game’s most fiery forwards. Picture: Getty

Waerea-Hargreaves has a reputation as one of the game’s most fiery forwards. Picture: Getty
But again, Cleary’s inability to see fault in his own players was highlighted by the fact he was confused why Leniu was even sent to the sin bin.
How about the fact Leniu was carrying on like a lunatic and couldn’t be calmed down, not even by his own captain Isaah Yeo.
Even when Lenui was walking from the field he still couldn’t control his anger as he started doing lewd gestures to the crowd and appearing to offer to fight anyone out in the car park.
You want talk about out of control, that was the rugby league definition of it.
 

Latest posts

Top