What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

R22 | Sharks 14-18 Knights @ Remondis | Sat 7.30pm

Round 22 result :: Sharks v Knights


  • Total voters
    11
  • Poll closed .

Joker's Wild

Coach
Messages
17,894
Who plays halfback next year? Gower is an unlikely prospect given his age. Even if he did sign for 2014, he'll not likely play every game due to an injury or 2

I think Roberts needs to remain at halfback and Clydesdale to backup Gids at hooker
 

perverse

Referee
Messages
26,753
Who plays halfback next year? Gower is an unlikely prospect given his age. Even if he did sign for 2014, he'll not likely play every game due to an injury or 2

I think Roberts needs to remain at halfback and Clydesdale to backup Gids at hooker
Dobson.
 

Rolla

Juniors
Messages
2,196
I like having Roberts out there. Our problem for a few years has been not enough players who can run on instinct and play what is in front of them, or pop up in the right spot with good anticipation. It gets Tyrone into trouble at times but I think that unpredictability provides something our team needs.

Back to the game, I honestly think we were watching the comps two best props in action last night. Fafita is a beast, not much to be said about him that hasn't been said already. But Kade has been enormous this year and more than justified the $$. I think having a good pack around him rather than being the lone wolf last year has helped a lot. His quantity has always been great, but this year it is all quality as well.

2nd best prop in the game for mine (while Tamou isn't killing it each week anyway).
 

knightsarmy

Juniors
Messages
203
Gower was bought over as cover for injuries at the time (Gidley & Danny) , now they are ok leave the team as we started
 

Burwood

First Grade
Messages
5,003
Mullen absolutely blew Carney away. I'll be extremely disappointed if he doesn't get a mention throughout the week for his performance, easily one of his best for the year.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/league/...dal/story-fn2mcuj6-1226694761101#.UgbvOxbkHbw

A MONTH ago, Todd Carney was ruing his omission from the NSW State of Origin team.

Now the Cronulla Sharks playmaker has surged into shock favouritism to snare his second Dally M player of the year award.

The combination of injuries to early favourites, Souths pair Greg Inglis and John Sutton, and a renewed enthusiasm following his Origin disappointment, has catapulted Carney to the top of the betting board for the prestigious medal.

Carney has been installed as the $2.75 favourite to win the award by Tabcorp's corporate betting arm, Luxbet, while surprisingly the odds on Inglis, the player many expected would break the Rabbitohs' 33-year Dally M drought this year, have blown out to $34.

Sutton is rated a $29 chance while North Queensland skipper Johnathan Thurston is second favourite at $4.

Carney was on 12 points, four points behind leader, Melbourne's Cooper Cronk, when voting went behind closed doors after Round 16.

Inglis was equal-second on 15, with Newcastle's Jarrod Mullen and Sutton.




But three, possibly four, man of the match performances from Carney in his past six matches has many believing the Sharks five-eighth has recaptured the form that saw him claim the gong in 2010 when he inspired the Roosters to the grand final.

They include former premiership winning halfback Brett Kimmorley.

"Given his form, you'd have to think Carney would be leading comfortably," Kimmorley said."He's been outstanding. The biggest strength of his game when he won the Dally M previously was his running game.

"He's running a lot straighter and on the back of the momentum that the Sharkies create, you find him posing a lot of questions.

"He looks fresh and happy, too, which at this time last year, he was probably the worst he ever felt in his career. He's not coming out of Origin deflated.

"He would've sat back and watched the series without any pressure and then he goes out and picks up points while the guys that did play Origin have come back a little flat.

"Cooper Cronk and Cam Smith weren't great in the month after Origin and now Inglis is injured."

Repaying the faith shown by Sharks coach Shane Flanagan, Carney has also stepped up in the absence of club captain Paul Gallen, who missed six weeks through injury.

"He's taken a leadership role with Gal missing and he's realised that he's a senior member there," State of Origin coach Laurie Daley said. "Like all the good players in the competition, he knows that if he can play well he can have a say in the result of the match. He's certainly done that, which has left the race wide open."

Manly's Daly Cherry-Evans and Canterbury pivot Josh Reynolds also have the potential to make a late charge for the Dally M Medal, which will be awarded in grand final week for the first time this year.

It appears Mullen doesn't even appear to be on the radar for the Dally M this year??

Since Round 16 we've only had a hard fought loss against the Roosters and a draw against the Broncos- I can't see him not having polled quite a few Dally M points since voting went behind closed doors.
 

Noname36

First Grade
Messages
7,067
That whole article is just speculation. I don't doubt that Carney would be right up there, but I don't think that means that blokes they're writing off or not mentioning don't have a shot either.
 

Swarzey

Bench
Messages
4,165
Carney will be up there. No doubt he would have nabbed 3 points in a lot of his recent games. However, I'd be surprised if he got more than one last night. Then again, we're talking about a system at gave Cronk 3 points against the Tigers. Perhaps Mullo has easily nabbed points in games since it went behind closed doors; always one of our stand out players regardless of the result.

I absolutely hate the timing of this article. Clearly it was written with the assumption that Carney was going to get another three points last night.
 

Yosh

Coach
Messages
12,001
Great game. It's really good to see the team go the whole 80 minutes week in week out now. If this game happened 2 or 3 years ago, we would have been shot off the park in the last 10. We have self belief but do we have the skill to beat the top teams? I don't see the team having enough points in them... Our enthusiasm in defense is great to see but in attack we are missing spark, enthusiasm and intensity. I've personally had enough of Darius. What's the point of paying him half a million for 8 carries a game and non-contests on bombs? I can't see how Kev or Kidley would be any worse than Darius for the rest of the year.
 

voltron

Juniors
Messages
1,454
being at the game was great
the refs were so biased towards the sharkies
but we never gave it, it was amazing
and mullen's kicking was on the ball, only a couple of balls went down the throat
otherwise it was all ground, and good ground, not like in front of a back and he picks it up on the fly

as mentioned before, roberts cleans up so many chip kicks and grubbers, line breaks
i like what he does.
i think people are being a bit too hard on him

boyd keeps to have a carton of cement
such a princess
 

Big Tim

First Grade
Messages
6,500
My thoughts, Kurt to fullback (will give his all) Boyd can f**k off. Dane is being used for to many hitups he isn't big enough to be a battering ram, I think it is detracting from his game.

Cant agree on point 1.

I was saying to my brothers in law that teams now kick to Uate. If you kick to McManus you get a solid carry with a quick PTB followed up with a solid carry from Joey.

Kick to Uate, make sure you get numbers down there as he will try to run over someone, dominate Dane tackle 2.

Seems to happen too often not to be a gameplan.
 

Rod

Bench
Messages
3,764
Just watched the game. From the comments I'd heard about the game I went in expecting a bit of a dire performance from us but I don't think we were poor at all. We just grinded the crap out of that game, which considering the conditions, the amount of ball and penalties they had and the quality of their forward pack, is a mighty effort. We can be very happy with that game and I think the response of the players after the final whistle blew really said a lot, they were rapt they put in that type of effort and got the reward.
 

Latest posts

Top