What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

RATM Reform for Coachella

CC_Eagle

First Grade
Messages
7,295
I thought AI was more of a concept album, focused around one or a few central characters?

Ignoring the title song..
 

salivor

First Grade
Messages
9,804
Sure it's a punk opera (though calling Greenday punk is a bit of a stretch these days) but there are a lot of political messages throughout. Here's what amazon.com said:
Amazon.co.uk Review
There's a clenched fist grasping a heart-shaped hand grenade on the cover of American Idiot, a militant mural presumably designed to inform us that Californian punk-pop vets Green Day love America but hate what's becoming of it. Inferences aside, you could argue that American Idiot is a suspect device--a punk concept album/rock opera primed to blow up in the faces of the ruling right-wing American classes but which could just as easily leave splattered egg on the faces of the insurrectionists. The concept is fuzzy (telly-brainwashed teenage runaway falls in with the wrong crowd, something or other happens with drugs, rock and a character called "Whatsername") and the political protestations against the metaphorical Arrnies and Dubyas are mere slapstick custard pies compared with the Dead Kennedys' CIA-bothering debunking of Reaganomics. However, something about American Idiot both excites and rings true whilst simultaneously beggaring belief. Spanning influences from The Who's Tommy to Husker Du's Zen Arcade, American Idiot has the listener living in cliff-hanging fear of an unexpected Richie Blackmore guitar solo or Tarkus-style ELP exposition but actually never strays from Buzzcockian melodiousness or phlegm-drenched rifferama even when things get ridiculous. "Homecoming", for example, is probably the best amalgamation of The Clash, Pink Floyd's The Wall, Millwall football supporters terrace chants, Deep Purple, The Levellers, Bob Mould, UK Subs, Rush, Pete Townsend and The Tubes you'll ever hear. American Idiot could be brave or it could be stupid, but it really can't be ignored. --Kevin Maidment

From the Label
Produced by Rob Cavallo, American Idiot is not only Green Day's most ambitious album to date, but also perhaps one of the most audacious efforts in the history of punk. Centred around two five-part, nine minute epics ("Jesus Of Suburbia" and "Homecoming"), 'American Idiot' is an expansive and intimately crafted concept album, detailing the alienation and disillusionment of the American citizen under Bush's post-War On Terror administration. "Jesus Of Suburbia" sees Green Day crossing genres at will to convey their story, mixing stomping melodic punk with elements of classic American rock, sun-kissed harmonies, a hint of psychedelia and Billie Joe singing plaintively over a lone acoustic. Elsewhere, Green Day's talent for reflective, melancholy sounds is pushed to the forefront with "Boulevard Of Broken Dreams" which finds them at their evocative best, and with "Are We The Waiting", possibly the most beautiful song ever to feature an old-school terrace chant. But it's with "When September Ends" that Green Day fully realise their strength at combining the tender with the powerful. The title-track rages with the aggression and infectiousness that typifies the best of the band's prior work, whilst a host of other tracks – including the breakneck punk of "St Jimmy" and the power-pop of "Extraordinary Girl" – remind us exactly why Green Day were so good in the first place.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/American-Idiot-Parental-Green-Day/dp/B0002OERI0
 

CC_Eagle

First Grade
Messages
7,295
Wow.

He made a totally average album seem really great. Hats off to him.

Back to the point, RATM > Green Day.
 

salivor

First Grade
Messages
9,804
What review were you reading? Both took pot shots at the album.

You can't even do a comparison between Rage and Green Day. One is a genuine political band with a powerful message, the other are amateur sell outs, not even in the same league.
 

Ron Jeremy

Coach
Messages
25,689
Just because a band is political doesn't make it a great band. It really isn't that hard to express your political views through a song, hell even Pink did it lol
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
154,203
I love Green day, off all the bands that sing their 3 minute punk songs these guys are a class above the rest, but RATM are in a class of their own for me

I've just been fortunate enough to see Tool live and that was a great honour, but I'd give anything to Zach and the boys play live
 

CC_Eagle

First Grade
Messages
7,295
Got a mate who somehow had a credit card application approved, bought a one way to LA and is over there now.

Lucky f*cking b*stard.
 

Red Bear

Referee
Messages
20,882
RATM - ok, nothing great. Strike me as a tad hypocritical. lyrically very anti-capatalist yet signed to one of the major labels? If you want political music listen to propaghandi, Bad Religion etc
 

Dragon

Coach
Messages
14,984
triple j is gonna be doing a cross or something to coachella this afternoon, should be good.
 

Latest posts

Top