Rd.5 v SeaEagles

[mxlegend99]

Anyone watching St Merge v Manly and still think Manly will get near us @hindy111 ?

If Turbo plays this badly against us they will be lucky not to concede 50.

This is the worst game I have ever seen him play. Looks like he's trying to outderp Scott Drinkwater from last night.

 

[Red&BlackBear]

Mate he brought in geyer to a bench job in at 2nd row, give him the go again, it save reshuffling 4 positions to one

Good point re: second row.

Still think there’s a chance Ivan changes what sides Tago and May play for this game.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Good point re: second row.

Still think there’s a chance Ivan changes what sides Tago and May play for this game.

Why? Explain the logic

 

[Girds89]

Peach is a hopeless 9 I can't see how Laurie would be worse in attack or defence

Mate laurie cant defend in the middle. He isnt a great defender at 6.

Your dislike of peach really blinds you haha.

Just like your love of burto blinds you.

You get tunnel vision with some players.

I trust ivan... but i think one thing that always has been a point he could improve is the bench rotations. Have said that for years.

I just dont see the value in laurie riding the pine unless theres an injury to dyl or the halfs.

I get it you need cover there. Just think we could cover that spot better.

 

[Girds89]

Good point re: second row.

Still think there’s a chance Ivan changes what sides Tago and May play for this game.

Ivan wont move tago from centre.

I think thats in the long term plan but definitely not in the next 3 years or so.

Maybe if/when casey is ready for fg amd soro is done he will move.

Be shocked if it happens before then.

Tago amd may have been probs the best centre pairing in the comp to start the year..wouldnt be chamging that.


Edit.....

Sorry i just re read and saw you said chamge sides.

Thought you meant move him to 2md row

 

[murraymob]

Anyone watching St Merge v Manly and still think Manly will get near us @hindy111 ?

It’s at brookvale the one place they play well.We need to aim our attack at Garrick woefull defender

 

[Chins get the wins]

Mate laurie cant defend in the middle. He isnt a great defender at 6.

Your dislike of peach really blinds you haha.

Just like your love of burto blinds you.

You get tunnel vision with some players.

I trust ivan... but i think one thing that always has been a point he could improve is the bench rotations. Have said that for years.

I just dont see the value in laurie riding the pine unless theres an injury to dyl or the halfs.

I get it you need cover there. Just think we could cover that spot better.

I know it was a trial but Peach's defence in England was diabolical. Peach covers no where but centre and backrow and that's just how it is

 

[Panther Pete]

Anyone watching St Merge v Manly and still think Manly will get near us @hindy111 ?

I am watching it and was just thinking if we play anything like we did against the Rorters on Thursday night and Manly continue like they are at the moment it could get very, very messy for them.

 

[Girds89]

I know it was a trial but Peach's defence in England was diabolical. Peach covers no where but centre and backrow and that's just how it is

There was a lot diabolical about that game.

Hed be fine in the middle.

In fact id trust him more in the middle in defence these days then on an edge against a world class centre or 2md rower.

Someone like manu or critta would burn him with power, speed.

In the middle he wouldn't be as solid as kemmy obviously but hes a fine defender front on against the slower middles.

 

[Alintheeast]

Same side as this week unless someone is in Nepean Hospital. Ivan doesn’t like change no one played badly. Peach would have been named in 17 by now if he was in Ivan’s plans. Soro would be the only one who would be rushed back as 2nd row only immediate problem.

 

[MugaB]

Same side as this week unless someone is in Nepean Hospital. Ivan doesn’t like change no one played badly. Peach would have been named in 17 by now if he was in Ivan’s plans. Soro would be the only one who would be rushed back as 2nd row only immediate problem.

If soro was moved he would just ho back to being a .middle

 

[Red&BlackBear]

Good point re: second row.

Still think there’s a chance Ivan changes what sides Tago and May play for this game.

Because Ivan changes the sides the centers play on multiple times every year. He even alluded to it in the press conference after the roosters match that a potentially change of sides is coming soon this year.

It builds the reps up between both wingers and both centers. Absolute awesome coaching that’s how I see it.

 

[martielang]

Peach could get a double hatty every week and Chins would call for him to be dropped due to a missed tackle that led to a try 34 minutes later.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Peach could get a double hatty every week and Chins would call for him to be dropped due to a missed tackle that led to a try 34 minutes later.

Some guys still think he has some sort of mythical XFACTOR. He's a NSW Cup level centre and that's that

 

[WestyLife]

Watched the Manly game when I finished work this morning. They won't worry us could rest cleary some more.

 

[Red&BlackBear]

Apparently Nathan said he is only missing the Roosters game? Guess we will know on Tuesday. But if true, awesome news.

Hopefully Schneid’s to 14 if Cleary starts!

 

[Chins get the wins]

Apparently Nathan said he is only missing the Roosters game? Guess we will know on Tuesday. But if true, awesome news.

Hopefully Schneid’s to 14 if Cleary starts!

Back after the bye. To make any other decision would be incompetent

 

[murraymob]

H

Apparently Nathan said he is only missing the Roosters game? Guess we will know on Tuesday. But if true, awesome news.

Hopefully Schneid’s to 14 if Cleary starts!

He was on the footy show said more likely after the bye

 

[Black Panther]

Back after the bye. To make any other decision would be incompetent

Says you. I will say if the games best player says he wants to play, we play him. He would know his injury better than anyone.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Says you. I will say if the games best player says he wants to play, we play him. He would know his injury better than anyone.

Yeah let's risk our season in round 5 against a team we'll cruise to victory over.