Reagan Campbell-Gillard and Jack Hetherington

[muzby]

No we shouldn't. Tell me why you think we should get Martin?

We should get RCG and or Hethrington. That will really weaken Penrith.

I couldn’t give a f**k which club we weaken, so long as we get stronger..

You don’t really ‘win’ by making someone else weaker..

 

[Dragsters]

We just should get Rhyse Martin

Defense around the ruck is what we are lacking most without Jack.

I'm not sure picking up a bloke like Martin, who has openly stated he needs to work on his defense and highlighted this for the reason he has been in and out of first grade all season, is what we need right now...

 

[Dragonslayer]

1st question, is Hetherington out injured or suspended? He was not listed in either 1st grade or in CC yesterday. Not the player we need right now.

RCG played 40 mins fron the bench yesterday, made 6 runs for 54m, took ave 4 seconds to play the ball and had 84% tackle efficiency (missed 4 tackles). Out of form? Out of favour?
We would be taking a risk in signing him based on his current form. Change of scenery? Maybe, but we cannot wait for a "maybe" to gain form.

Some other names mentioned include:

Ma'u, yesterday played 80 minutes had 17 runs for 170m, 2.88 seconds play the ball and 94% tackle efficiency (made 30 missed 2).
Ese'ese, yesterday played 43 minutes had 12 runs 106m, 3.55 seconds play the ball and 89% tackle efficiency (made 24 missed 1 and 2 ineffective).

Only Ma'u really stands out based on those numbers.

 

[Frank Facer]

1st question, is Hetherington out injured or suspended? He was not listed in either 1st grade or in CC yesterday. Not the player we need right now.

RCG played 40 mins fron the bench yesterday, made 6 runs for 54m, took ave 4 seconds to play the ball and had 84% tackle efficiency (missed 4 tackles). Out of form? Out of favour?
We would be taking a risk in signing him based on his current form. Change of scenery? Maybe, but we cannot wait for a "maybe" to gain form.

Some other names mentioned include:

Ma'u, yesterday played 80 minutes had 17 runs for 170m, 2.88 seconds play the ball and 94% tackle efficiency (made 30 missed 2).
Ese'ese, yesterday played 43 minutes had 12 runs 106m, 3.55 seconds play the ball and 89% tackle efficiency (made 24 missed 1 and 2 ineffective).

Only Ma'u really stands out based on those numbers.

Interesting stats. I don't mind M'au, it is just that he is already 31 years old.

 

[Wittenberg]

We will not buy anyone.

 

[blacksafake]

Interesting stats. I don't mind M'au, it is just that he is already 31 years old.

We’d still get 2 good years out of him.

 

[betcats]

No we shouldn't. Tell me why you think we should get Martin?

We should get RCG and or Hethrington. That will really weaken Penrith.

No one will be disappointed if you take Rcg.

 

[possm]

Sign RCG as JDB's replacement while we can. It is no good waiting for him to play himself into form and then try to sign him. He will eventually come good and my tip he will be back to his best in 2020.

 

[SBD82]

No one will be disappointed if you take Rcg.

We might be.

 

[betcats]

We might be.

Possibly. He has the ability to make it a good signing, he just isn't turning up often enough atm.

 

[Warabrook saint]

We will not buy anyone.

This is what it's looking like

 

[Wittenberg]

Our problem is that our club is on the nose and can we commit to more than one season given the limitations imposed on us by the NRL ? I think I remember that anyone signed as a replacement for JDB can only be offered a one year contract from the club. Hope I’m wrong.

 

[The calm one]

We will not buy anyone.

You are correct. No one is coming here. Especially to play in the back three. Anyone over 120cm does not get to the negotiation stage

 

[Warabrook saint]

Our problem is that our club is on the nose and can we commit to more than one season given the limitations imposed on us by the NRL ? I think I remember that anyone signed as a replacement for JDB can only be offered a one year contract from the club. Hope I’m wrong.

Everyone else can get around these sort of things except good old us