nutley IS the most overated forward ( only by sharks supporters) in the competition, if you guys seriosly think we can challenge the top sides in this competition in the end of season games with nutley at prop forward you are delusional.
as i continually say his effort cannot be criticised but wake up boys he is simply not big enough, strong enough or fast enough to do any damage whatsoever.
sims/ryles/webcke/civoniceva/omeley/price/perry/rauhihi/clinton/ross/cayless
morley/villasanti and luke bailey all are his competition..and they all are clearly superior.
not to mention his penchant for dumb, no the dumbest of penalties and his propensity to argue with the referee, the bloke is dead set useless.
Marvellous piece of rhetoric - now can we have some hard facts to back this up? Perhaps some comparitive stats, maybe some figures on his penalty count compared to other props?
isemonger......copped continual bagging here in the early part of the year then played a few fair games, he defends well but may as well sit on the sideliine when we have the ball, sure he has a couple of knee operations and is a local junior so what.
he drops the ball cold each week and is average at best.
I appreciate your opinion but his error rate is .6 errors per game - this does not equate to "he drops the ball cold each week". Perhaps you have some facts that will make your assertion clearer?
(BTW I am pleased you give him credit for his great defence, despite his poor missed tack rate. Mind you it is better than a lot of other in NRL and when he is hitting them they stay hit!)
do you think it is just a coincidence that the top sides in the league have OUTSTANDING players, no boys its good man management and the ability to find the player and keep him and easts are specialists at this, hence their ongoing competitiveness.
live in a dream world and continue to believe these blokes will get you across the line or wake up to reality and look at the competition!
as peter peters often says you dont win wars with water pistols!!!!
And you do not lose games on the back of a single player. You want to attack a couple of individuals, you present no facts just opinions. I have no problem with you having your opinion but state is as just your opinion and admit you have no facts to back it up - or back it up!
If you want to argue the problem is the Club, its management and methods then put your case for that with facts. BTR has put his case forward on the ref and the coach and I might not entirely agree with him but at least he has mounted some some sort of case for his opinion.
Put a case or put a sock in it for gods sake!
(could not be bothered checking this so if my spelling sux or my english is poor feel free have a dig at me - at least there might be some fact in that :lol: )