What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Return of game of the round at the SCG

Moffo

Referee
Messages
23,986
totally agree mate, im in bondi and its the same issue. sfs is pretty accessible...i mean you can get to central from anywhere and then its either a 20min walk up the hill or a bus for the lazy sh*tes
 

Red Bear

Referee
Messages
20,882
SCG is great for 1 or 2 games a year for the memories, and if they open up the top decks of the brewongle/chruchill/trumper stands its actually a pretty decent view because you are right above the game and can read the play really well. Not a good enough view at ground level for full time viewing.

SFS is a supurb ground that is under utilised, so having bigger games there would be good.


One feels this could be the first step to an eventual AFL situation that sees almost evey game being at the big grounds.
 

adamkungl

Immortal
Messages
42,971
imo they should make the special event buses to Moore Park free....shut all the whinging pricks up.
 

adamkungl

Immortal
Messages
42,971
One feels this could be the first step to an eventual AFL situation that sees almost evey game being at the big grounds.

Hope not. As long as the suburban grounds keep gradually improving over the years, I see no reason to ever lose home and away games. Hate the AFL system.
 

Angry_eel

First Grade
Messages
8,644
Great Idea. This is what I said after Tigers V Parra. The biggest game of the round needs to be at SCG. However, it depends on the teams too. Parramatta V Penrith at SFS will be lucky to crack 20,000.
 

hilltop hood

Juniors
Messages
117
Not sure who was whinging about the cost Adam? Perhaps you were a little blinded by the prospect of having some decent teams playing some decent footy in that neck of the woods. :D
 

adamkungl

Immortal
Messages
42,971
Not sure who was whinging about the cost Adam? Perhaps you were a little blinded by the prospect of having some decent teams playing some decent footy in that neck of the woods. :D

If someone is whinging about the distance of the short walk, they can catch a bus. I don't see the problem with getting to the SFS.
 

Loudstrat

Coach
Messages
15,224
Couldn't agree more.

The SCG is the perfect example of people remembering only the good things about the past and forgetting about all the crap things that came with it. It's horrible for watching footy. There is a very good reason why games aren't played there anymore.

Totally 100% true. We've had nostalgia club games ther involving Wests and Souths and the crowds were no better than you'd get at Leichhardt
The SFS on the other hand is in the same great location and is a brilliant stadium. Use it for freaks sake!
You mean same sh*t location.

Steady or they'll be labelling you a negative Sydney hater!

If it gives clubs more money and the fans like it, great. My point is what do 12-20 year olds want and expect form paying $20-40 to see a game? If its to sit in sub standard stadia miles from the pitch SCG is a great idea! The kids are tomorrows fan base.

SFS is by far the best RL stadium in Sydney I have been to for mid size games and is very under utilised so if this plan uses it more and gets 30,000 to games then wonderful!
And what would suddenly make 30k crowds happen at the SFS? Because you said so?The Roosters aside (and arguably Wests after 3 games last year) the SFS is a disaster for club games - Saints and Souths left for a reason.

Indeed. Plus the SCG is more central to Sydney than ANZ.

Not to the people. ANZ is far more central to 75% of the population. Moore Park is better for the Eastern Suburbs, the Bay and arguably the Shire and Lower North Shore. Just the same for Manly fans, and far worse for everyone else.
 

adamkungl

Immortal
Messages
42,971
Not to the people. ANZ is far more central to 75% of the population. Moore Park is better for the Eastern Suburbs, the Bay and arguably the Shire and Lower North Shore. Just the same for Manly fans, and far worse for everyone else.

so for Easts, Souths, Cronulla, Saints, and Manly fans, the SFS is fine.
The NRL would be moronic to play Parra/Penrith/Bulldogs local derbies there anyway.
 

Loudstrat

Coach
Messages
15,224
The ones that live close to town. Manly would draw less to Moore park than Brookie. And Souths and Saints dumped it as their HG. Good for the chooks - served well in big games before ANZ. But we built the SFS because the SCG was too old back in 1986!
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,489
And what would suddenly make 30k crowds happen at the SFS? Because you said so?The Roosters aside (and arguably Wests after 3 games last year) the SFS is a disaster for club games - Saints and Souths left for a reason.



.

marketing, playing it on a Sunday afternoon, hyping it up as the game of the week, making it affordable, extra capacity meaning blockbusters could fit in more than the 16,000 at suburban grounds?
 

Loudstrat

Coach
Messages
15,224
marketing, playing it on a Sunday afternoon, hyping it up as the game of the week, making it affordable, extra capacity meaning blockbusters could fit in more than the 16,000 at suburban grounds?

What on earth would make people travel all the way to the SFS?

The problem with it is that it is on the east of the CBD. Most CBD workers have over an hour commute 10 times a week from home, they are not going to make it 12 without a damn gpood reason for it. More likely they would go to their local ground, or ANZ which is only really a problem for those in the eastern suburbs and rail communters from Cronulla.

2 clubs - both right on the doorstep of the SFS, have left there after poor crowd results. Saints found it far better to go back to their suburban ground - due to market demand. Souths wouldn't know their arse from their tit, and Canterbury - who have used 4 and considered a 5th home ground in the last 15 years haven't even bothered looking at the SFS.

The SFS/SCG is simply using the ANZ strategy. Offer money - talk it up. The Roosters are the only side comfortable there - it's been their home for 102 years.

And the Moore Park complex represents sporting xenophobia for the masses of Urban Sydney. AR, Union and Soccer plonk sides there and claim ownership of the entire metropolis - Clover Moore hosting a ticket tape parade for the Swans and not Wests in 95 smacked of it's arrogance "The Swans represent all of Sydney". No they don't. They play in a far flung Eastern suburb that is nothing to the majority of the city's population.

And your solution is to play more games there, and alienate the population. Great idea, Einstein.
 
Last edited:

Moffo

Referee
Messages
23,986
tigers v parra got 34k at the SFS earlier this year. explain that if everyone 'hates' the SFS

telstra stadium is f**king sh*te unless there are 40k+
 

hilltop hood

Juniors
Messages
117
tigers v parra got 34k at the SFS earlier this year. explain that if everyone 'hates' the SFS

Tiges v Parra drew 34000 because it was do or die. Both teams needed as much support as possible and their fans responded.

They could have played in Timbuktu and drawn a great crowd.

The same game at Homebush would have been even bigger.

The same 2 teams at SFS earlier in the year, without the desperation, would get low 20's maybe.
 

Bulldog Force

Referee
Messages
20,619
I can't see 1 team giving up their home advantage every week. Perhaps once a fortnight or month will be feasible, but every week is just too much!
 

adamkungl

Immortal
Messages
42,971
Tiges v Parra drew 34000 because it was do or die. Both teams needed as much support as possible and their fans responded.

They could have played in Timbuktu and drawn a great crowd.

The same game at Homebush would have been even bigger.

The same 2 teams at SFS earlier in the year, without the desperation, would get low 20's maybe.

Isn't the point of this to play blockbusters at the SCG/SFS? I think that qualifies as one...
 

Latest posts

Top