Ricky Ponting is a Shocking Captain Thread

[Bazal]

Your allowed opinions but nobody acknowledges the good things Ponting does instead they bag him out for the teams performances which isn't alot of the time his fault

Some do. But you applied a broad brush when some of us legitimately criticise his captaincy while still acknowledging his other qualities. Surely there can't be many left who are still blind to his inadequacies as a skipper?

 

[lockyno1]

Your allowed opinions but nobody acknowledges the good things Ponting does instead they bag him out for the teams performances which isn't alot of the time his fault

Ponting not thinking outside the square is his main critcism and rightly so. We are a better chance of winning with Clarke captain

 

[mozza91]

Ponting not thinking outside the square is his main critcism and rightly so. We are a better chance of winning with Clarke captain

Why?
Being overly aggressive has cost us games in the past being defensive works often Adelaide 06 was a perfect example

 

[lockyno1]

Being overly defensive has costed us two series in a row..and don't bring up Adelaide that was Warne winning the game NOT Ponting! Katich or Clarke are better tactical captains yet we keep this clueless moron in charge..