What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

RLIF 2017 Sydney Meeting

LordLeague

Juniors
Messages
158
A few alternative views to the GB resurrection.

Players have spilt blood for nearly 100 years fighting for the RL Ashes. What English player wouldn't want the chance to pull on the GB jersey and try to get his hands on the Ashes Cup and bring it home after all these years?

I suggest that wearing a GB jersey and playing for the Ashes would lift the team of predominantly (or wholly) English players to a new level.

I guess the argument here is that England could have played in an Ashes series. I don't think this would be a good idea given that for the later half of the 20th century the GB team competed for the Ashes and for anyone still alive today, the RL Ashes is GB v Aus. If the Ashes are to be resurrected then GB should be the team fighting the Aussies, there really is no other option.

So I read the posts saying the GB team is just England in GB jerseys and that GB should be brought back once Wales and Scots can produce some talent. I believe this argument to be fundamentally flawed. You can't chop and change between GB and England branding depending on who is available for selection. I believe the GB brand should be retained only for Ashes tours/series, which still allows for a well-planned international for the home nations.

If there are no non-English players worthy of selection then so be it. It is still a GB team! as all Welsh, Scottish and Irish players are eligible for selection. You never know when the next Brian Carney is going to Burst onto the scene and the GB concept must leave the door open for non-English players even though in some years the GB team will be all-England. For the record I don't support Aussie ring-ins. You could always include a minimum of 2 players from the home nations in the touring party if you want to try and legitimise the concept. It doesn't mean they'll get anywhere near the GB team for the tests.

And finally, the Rugby League Ashes is an all too rare concept in RL. An event which has the necessary history to provide for a real meaningful international RL contest that the players actually care about. Personally, I am sick of one-off Bundaberg, Holden, VB tests (whatever you want to call them). against the Kiwis. Sometimes there's a mention of something called a Bill Kelly Cup, but who F#ckin knows when that is being played for or not?

I'll leave you with this. Would I travel from regional Australia to Sydney or Brisbane to see a meaningless England v Australia tri nations round robin game. Probably not. Would I travel to see a GB v Aus Ashes test. HELL YEAH!!! (They better play for the F#ckin Ashes when they tour in 2019).

Lord League
 

roughyedspud

Coach
Messages
12,181
There's so much to destroy there I just don't have the energy anymore...I'll just make this one point..

England players wearing a GB Shirt WILL NOT MAKE THEM ANY BETTER!! and it's effing ridiculous to suggest such bullshit...


and....relax....
 

roughyedspud

Coach
Messages
12,181
I'm calm...lol

On whether which series will be for the ashes...when the news broke the other week,on sky sports news,the ticker that scrolls alone the bottom said..

" GB tour down under in 2019,Australia tour in 2020 for the ashes" or ashes series it said..either way it definitely had 2020 & ashes in the same sentence.

I've asked various bodies & people on Twitter to clarify...but never get a answer back
 

roughyedspud

Coach
Messages
12,181
Me neither....

Where as the Welsh & Scottish CEOs seem to be blindly following the RFL like sheep the Irish took to their Facebook page to actually ask fans what they think...and GB certainly didn't get 99.9% support like the Welsh CEO thinks support the return of GB.
 

Irish-bulldog

Juniors
Messages
785
The Irish want nothing to do with GB it's an insult actually. I've said it once and I'll say it again, who the hell does international league think they are kidding with this GB garbage ?, England in a different shirt :rolling_eyes:, give it a rest, stick with building the international game, not some stupid gemick, don't treat people like idiots.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
70,855
GB is a great idea but only for ashes series. Gives chance to marketnitmdiffernetly to four nations and RLWC tournaments. Who cares if it's all England players? Running out in the historic red white and blue to land of hope,and glory with the naive belief we may win the ashes is a marketers dream.
 
Messages
3,884
Don't underestimate the difference that having Scottish and Welsh players is going to make to an English core squad. Ben Flower will stiffen the GB pack, while Danny Brough will weave some magic in the halves if needed.
 

Latest posts

Top