Robbie Farah > Smith

[Fire]

Rein/King > Every other nuffy hooker in the NRL.

 

[Bretto]

John Plath.

That is all.

 

[Ronnie Dobbs]

Smiffy just looks average around a bunch of good players.

When the Storm needed him to produce, he can't come up with the goods. He's slowly been shown up for the scam that he is.

Yo Crazy

 

[aussie7798]

1 Chuck Norris
2 Smith
3 Farah
4 Luke

 

[Frailty]

 

[dogslife]

Got nothing on Adam Perry

 

[Big Pete]

Ian Lacey.

Just Ian Lacey.

 

[gronkathon]

Ahh yes, the cube

 

[dogslife]

Bill Peden: 2 premierships

Ergo Bill Peden>Farah

 

[macavity]

Bill Peden: 2 premierships

Ergo Bill Peden>Farah

Fact.

 

[Billythekid]

Definitely not true. Having said that Farah is one of the most underated players on this forum.

 

[Silent Knight]

Great thread DINNNNNKKKKKKOOOOOO!

 

[RABK]

I'd take Farah over Smith at this stage of their careers. Farah continues to carry the Tigers week in, week out with help from Benji once a month. Smith's clearly on the decline and likely to finish a premiershipless grub with his trophies been brown paper bags and speedboats.

 

[Mr Saab]

Syd Eru - best hooker ever

 

[some11]

Move along, nothing to see here

My jimmies have been thoroughly rustled :lol:

 

[de$$ie]

I'll take Matt Ballin over all these nuffies. 2 premierships can't be that bad?

 

[dinko]

I'd take Farah over Smith at this stage of their careers. Farah continues to carry the Tigers week in, week out with help from Benji once a month. Smith's clearly on the decline and likely to finish a premiershipless grub with his trophies been brown paper bags and speedboats.

well said

 

[dinko]

Great thread DINNNNNKKKKKKOOOOOO!

Anytime

 

[Charlie124]

Smiffy just looks average around a bunch of good players.

When the Storm needed him to produce, he can't come up with the goods. He's slowly been shown up for the scam that he is.

Go to bed, Robbie. Youve got a game tomorrow.

 

[madunit]

Daniel Fitzhenry 1 premiership
Steve Rogers, Wayne Pearce, Ben Elias, Paul Sironen, Andrew Ettingshausen, Keith Holman, Keith Barnes, Frank Burge et al 0 premierships

ergo Fitzhenry to be considered next immortal.