What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Round 2 vs Souths

carltonsouth79

First Grade
Messages
5,988
The lowest of lows
The coach leaves a player on for 30 mins with a cracked rib or cartilage
couldnt run or lift his arm
Oue defence is thread bare
The heads go down whenever we have to defend for long periods and things dont go our way
So much for a culture change
The 7 couldnt seal the win with a field goal 5 to go in front of the posts...puts up a limp dick bomb ffs
Lawrie lasted 18 mins ffs
Liddle again wasted on the bench..Wont cook come off ???
The only time we showed any back line flair was when Gutho went to 1st or 2nd receiver
What was wrong with a chip kick over the top of a tiring defence for Sloan or CT to regather
Why were our tactics to go set for set with the Bunnies FFS
The Coach didnt have his best day either
Changes ????
Klemmer will come straight in , Bye Blake
Should be plenty , but only changes will be for injuries and Klem
Suli will miss a few weeks.. Need a centre ..Pls no Cook
Ilias ...would be giving him a spell in NSW Cup..But it wont happen
Glover has been ok in Cup or even Gutho to 6 Kyle to 7 Slaon to 1, Finau to wing , but wont happen
Thought Coachman and Stewart tried really hard
Sloan threatened but was let down by his inside men
We are in big trouble
With respect .....today was only Souths
Storm in 2 weeks..
God help us
I’d definitely think about Gutherson at 6, Flanno Jr to 7. Sloan to 1. Klemmer, Seles should come in against the Storm. Love to see one of the young middles from Reggie’s get a go as well. Think we are light on for centres.
 

Parko1310

Juniors
Messages
1,482
Cook and Ilias were worst on ground.. thank god Lawrie stayed off or it it would've been him by the length of the straight.

Seriously, anyone still going to defend Lawrie in here? Anyone? That was the worst stint I've ever seen from him and that is saying something very profound. Absolute plodder.

Poor Toby who's wearing some flack was absolutely out on his feet because he had to play 65 mins in the middle in the scorching heat because we couldn't afford to put that useless excuse for a prop back on. And I'm sorry, I've supported Flano heaps, but his decision to play Lawrie, and then start him, has to be seriously called into question. HUGE oversight and a selection he obviously regretted given the rotation (or lack thereof) that unfolded. But it should have been obvious to him, as it was to most of us here, that this was not going to end well. Thought we'd lose today as soon as I saw that team sheet an hour before kick off. Klemmer can't come in quick enough, and you'd say Lawrie not coming back on is pretty telling for round 4's team.

Gutho was our best, and probably BOG, but also a couple defensive howlers.

Su'A needs to pull his finger out, been awful to start the year. Needs to stop having one good year followed by absolute shit the next.

Cook may be the worst buy of the year. Does not know how to attack on the goal line at all, hospital passes everywhere, some really selfish plays today where it looked like it was more about him getting one up on his old club than playing for his team now. He embarrassed himself and Dragons fans today.

Ilias is the exact player I thought he would be.. he is going to prove absolutely no body wrong. He sucks.. simple as that. Got absolutely nothing. Throws passes that aren't on, setting his teammates up to get smashed, throws passes that hit the deck, defensively inept, and terrible at controlling a game. 6 points up, 13 to go. There was space in behind the line for a kick that would've pinned souths in the corner. Ilias tries a trick play with Sloan and sends him into a brick wall of defenders right where the ruck was. Instead of pinning souths on their own line, we turn it over more than 20m out from their line.

Thought Sloan did his job, wasn't too erratic, and got to ground most times quick enough not to get pushed back. Picked a couple moments correctly and was pretty good under the high ball. 215 run metres is a good effort from him. Stewart and Couchman tackled their asses off and tried hard, some of our better players today and they're 20 and 21. Senior players need to step up better than they did today.

Going to be a long year, especially with that spine and middle. Bottom 4 team, absolutely rotten.
 
Messages
1,937
Cook, Holmes, Lawrie, Guler, RFM absolutely useless today. Ilias not much better.
Lawrie's inclusion was baffling from the start but to then only use him in one spell at the start of the first half was just wasteful.
I'd be fuming if I was Liddle, sitting on the bench while Cook does... whatever little he did.
JdB and Gutho are the only ones with any ticker and JdB undoes that by being stupid.
Bring on the bye. At least we get a two week furlough before Melbourne tear us a new one.
 
Messages
83
Our defence is absolutely atrocious. We don't move up still back peddle, piss Dean young off and get someone new in because his systems are shit. Terrible play from Cook one of our captains, terrible game awareness. 0-2 have to love it what a joke
You’re wrong KingFlanno, our defence is worse than atrocious. Apparently it was worked on during the week. Have you ever seen more softer tries than the ones that Mamouzelos and Keppie scored? You would have thought Deano would remember the defensive system that worked 2009-2011 under Bennett. Apparently not. Strap yourselves in for another long season. Storm will put 60 on us.
 

RedVDave

First Grade
Messages
5,794
I really don't know why people were so excited for this year.

Young & Carr are still part of the coaching staff.

Cook is well cooked and well past his best, out best player last year Liddle getting less minutes is simply idiotic.

Molo sadly is/was our best prop and he's no longer with us.

Ilias sucks he was slightly better today but he absolutely sucks last time he played in Wollongong was again us and he got hooked he's only the halfback until Atkinson arrives which can't come soon enough.

Anyway I'm pissed and as hell and over this shit we've lost to 2 arch arrivals at home 2 weeks in a row and we are still the dumbest and possibly laziest football I've ever seen.
 

coastiedragon

Juniors
Messages
166
*Liddle starts cook only to give him a spell
*Luc dropped 76m lazy and over weight if you want to be a side of a house move to prop
*Lawrie never to play 1st grade again 32m
*ilias not up to standards should have closed that out
*emre 49m not good enough
*Bring cup players up loko ran for 131m pcm 64m off 10 carries
*halangahu ran for 114m pcm 56m of 8 carries
Make changes so they know its not good enough thought flanno was a hard nose coach
 

Illusion

Bench
Messages
3,300
I really don't know why people were so excited for this year.

Young & Carr are still part of the coaching staff.

Cook is well cooked and well past his best, out best player last year Liddle getting less minutes is simply idiotic.

Molo sadly is/was our best prop and he's no longer with us.

Ilias sucks he was slightly better today but he absolutely sucks last time he played in Wollongong was again us and he got hooked he's only the halfback until Atkinson arrives which can't come soon enough.

Anyway I'm pissed and as hell and over this shit we've lost to 2 arch arrivals at home 2 weeks in a row and we are still the dumbest and possibly laziest football I've ever seen
Hay Dave I hear you , our 6 and 7 are non existent in attack , and when your 9 is so so , and Lawrie starts we are in trouble .......
 
Top