The only comment I'll make as far as Hook goes is, if his major role is culture and motivational, even his staunchest supporters would have to admit that, at the moment, he certainly seems to be failing in those aspects, considering he himself, specifically warned the players not to get together and get on the drink after the warriors game and they went ahead anyway, resulting in the debacle at Vaughan's place.
My biggest concern with Hook at the moment is that even though he is talking. the team don't seem to be listening.
Good points. Back in the bad old McGregor days I wondered how a team could have so much talent but do so poorly. I was one of McGregor's biggest critics. My thinking was get rid of him and we could only go up.
My first shock was DeBelin getting caught up in his scandal. Even though charges were dropped he did put himself in a bad situation, bad judgement, etc. I was and still am a DeBelin fan and Greenberg and the NRL can cold smoke a #ick the way they handled the situation but Jack's actions provided a clue.
McGregor left and things were looking up.
I was and maybe still a Paul Vaughn fan but the BBQ debacle was a clue bat hitting me upside the head.
"The team don't seem to be listening" and I'm thinking a lot of the blame for the past few years can also be laid upon many of the players. Loads of talent but maybe only utilized when the players felt like it or fit their own agenda.
I wouldn't write Hook off yet but hope he jettisons those that can't seem to listen and build from the ground up.