What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rugby Australia to target top NRL talent - Lomax case settled

Coparugby

Juniors
Messages
708
Interestingly I’ve not read anything about r360’s potential impact on the NRLW. I’m sure quite a few of the women would be easily tempted by a massive pay increase on their NRLW salary.
 

Billythekid

First Grade
Messages
7,211
I'm starting to agree with WB about this.

If the NRL loses Paps, NAS and Haas but the pay off is the collapse of Super Ruger, English Premiership, Top 14 and Union internationals .... I'm on team R360
I can’t agree with this. The NRL is booming right now, we’re in a far stronger position than we’ve ever been and we’re on the precipice of expanding the game in a massive way. We’ve actually reached a point where you can genuinely argue we’re the most popular sport in the country.

It’s impossible to say how this will play out for league and union but it comes at a bad time for us IMO. Also whilst both sports will be losing players at least for union they’re ending up playing union.

Im not going to doom and gloom but I won’t be celebrating R360 that’s for sure.
If it’s tax free he would be crazy to say no
I know this is the reality of human behaviour but this always blows my mind. Whether Haas stays or goes he’s going to earn 10s of millions in his career. Dude is on track to be mega rich. I’ve never really understood giving up the things you love to chase money when you’re already so rich.
 

Chimp

Bench
Messages
3,405
Lol after arguing that PNG players would be paid tax free for the last year, now you come up with this garbage. Have you finally learnt what tax residency is?
The difference here is, R360 players will be reliant on existing tax loopholes and laws, the Aus government aren’t involved in R360. Whereas the PNG NRL team is an Aus government initiative, therefore any tax exceptions are presumably agreed as part of this initiative - they won’t be using existing tax law/loopholes, it’ll be a specifically designed agreement.
 

Gobsmacked

First Grade
Messages
5,920
I can’t agree with this. The NRL is booming right now, we’re in a far stronger position than we’ve ever been and we’re on the precipice of expanding the game in a massive way. We’ve actually reached a point where you can genuinely argue we’re the most popular sport in the country.

It’s impossible to say how this will play out for league and union but it comes at a bad time for us IMO. Also whilst both sports will be losing players at least for union they’re ending up playing union.

Im not going to doom and gloom but I won’t be celebrating R360 that’s for sure.

I know this is the reality of human behaviour but this always blows my mind. Whether Haas stays or goes he’s going to earn 10s of millions in his career. Dude is on track to be mega rich. I’ve never really understood giving up the things you love to chase money when you’re already so rich.
NRL clubs all have multiple stars and not only is this a very small group but they aren't even the best stars at their own clubs.
This won't impact the NRL at any meaningful way. The early release point more to the clubs welcoming the extra cap space. Paps is past his best and gives the storm a million bucks to keep players through upgrades.
We have far more talent coming through.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
48,849
The difference here is, R360 players will be reliant on existing tax loopholes and laws, the Aus government aren’t involved in R360. Whereas the PNG NRL team is an Aus government initiative, therefore any tax exceptions are presumably agreed as part of this initiative - they won’t be using existing tax law/loopholes, it’ll be a specifically designed agreement.
The Australian govt is passing specific tax laws to ensure png players are also exempt from Aussie taxes
 

bazza

Immortal
Messages
33,268
At the end of the day Lomax isn't really a great loss but I still think the NRL needs to be more proactive here and introduce a system where the top players salaries aren't capped.

1 or 2 players from each team should not be included in the salary cap. With 20 teams, that's potentially 40 of the best NRL players protected. Broncos could easily afford to keep Haas if they were allowed.
I think Lomax went from Saints to Parra for less money - not sure how this idea would have changed anything
 

Maximus

Coach
Messages
16,978
The difference here is, R360 players will be reliant on existing tax loopholes and laws, the Aus government aren’t involved in R360. Whereas the PNG NRL team is an Aus government initiative, therefore any tax exceptions are presumably agreed as part of this initiative - they won’t be using existing tax law/loopholes, it’ll be a specifically designed agreement.

Good luck getting those new tax laws (which haven't been through parliament) through a high court challenge.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
75,590
I can’t agree with this. The NRL is booming right now, we’re in a far stronger position than we’ve ever been and we’re on the precipice of expanding the game in a massive way. We’ve actually reached a point where you can genuinely argue we’re the most popular sport in the country.

It’s impossible to say how this will play out for league and union but it comes at a bad time for us IMO. Also whilst both sports will be losing players at least for union they’re ending up playing union.

Im not going to doom and gloom but I won’t be celebrating R360 that’s for sure.

I know this is the reality of human behaviour but this always blows my mind. Whether Haas stays or goes he’s going to earn 10s of millions in his career. Dude is on track to be mega rich. I’ve never really understood giving up the things you love to chase money when you’re already so rich.
youre one neck injury away from retirement in a high collision sport. Take the money when you can get it, never know what tomorrow brings.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
75,590
The difference here is, R360 players will be reliant on existing tax loopholes and laws, the Aus government aren’t involved in R360. Whereas the PNG NRL team is an Aus government initiative, therefore any tax exceptions are presumably agreed as part of this initiative - they won’t be using existing tax law/loopholes, it’ll be a specifically designed agreement.
you think the Aus govt can just waiver the countries tax rules for certain sports individuals? This isn’t corrupt png lol
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
75,590
NRL clubs all have multiple stars and not only is this a very small group but they aren't even the best stars at their own clubs.
This won't impact the NRL at any meaningful way. The early release point more to the clubs welcoming the extra cap space. Paps is past his best and gives the storm a million bucks to keep players through upgrades.
We have far more talent coming through.
Depends, if it’s two for sure, if it’s 20 then it will have an impact. Especially at a time the nrl needs an extra 64 players for two new teams
 
Top