Rumoured Signings and Even More Crap X

[Poupou Escobar]

Surprise surprise you disagree. Sandows record of playing in zero final games speaks for itself.

Like Hindy's record as a captain speaks for itself?

Be real careful talking about a player's individual records in a team game.

 

[pedge]

Like Hindy's record as a captain speaks for itself?

Be real careful talking about a player's individual records in a team game.

It does speak for itself...he was a shit captain, I would argue with anyone who said otherwise

 

[Poupou Escobar]

I think he was too, but not because of his record.

 

[Someone]

i will not lose any sleep if sandow leaves.

1. Hayne
6. Norman
7. Robson
9. Luke


I might have a tug tonight afterall.

 

[Chipmunk]

Like Hindy's record as a captain speaks for itself?

Be real careful talking about a player's individual records in a team game.

Just as Brian Smith's zero Premierships as a coach is not an issue either

 

[Chipmunk]

i will not lose any sleep if sandow leaves.

1. Hayne
6. Norman
7. Robson
9. Luke


I might have a tug tonight afterall.

Re-signed with the Sharks. When they are struggling looking for a few players for 2014/15 I doubt Robson will be one they will be releasing.

 

[EelsFan05]

Like Hindy's record as a captain speaks for itself?

Be real careful talking about a player's individual records in a team game.

Sandow has achieved nothing in the game of rugby league as an individual or as a team member. He doesn't even belong in the same sentence as Hindmarsh. But keep bagging a club legend and suggesting he was a bad leader without taking into account the cattle he was leading. But keep making excuses for an over priced poor excuse for a halfback because he plays in a bad team. Be careful that argument works both ways as well Poo.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Just as Brian Smith's zero Premierships as a coach is not an issue either

After 20 years in coaching the sample size starts to become more reliable (more reliable than his 0 from 4 grand final record). Especially when you observe a pattern of his team's choking in big games.

On the other hand Hindy was only the sole captain of Parra while he was saddled with shit teammates, so his captaincy record is difficult to judge. It could have been a combination of his shit leadership, a shit coach or shit teammates, but the sample size is too small to put it all on Hindy. The fact that it's a team game means the useless teammates is more likely.

Ricky Stuart won over 60% of his first 42 games as coach, including a premiership. He did this at a strong club with quality players and a great captain.

Consequently he has only won 10 of his past 42 games (same as Kearney) as coach of the Sharks and Eels - two clubs with weak rosters and poor leadership.

It's a team game.

 

[Someone]

i agree with everything you say pou but f**k me you dribble on and on

 

[EelsFan05]

i agree with everything you say pou but f**k me you dribble on and on

Have you read a large enough sample size of his posts to make that sort of comment?

 

[Bigfella]

I agree with everything that Someone says there

 

[I bleed blue & gold]

:lol:

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Sandow has achieved nothing in the game of rugby league as an individual or as a team member.

Dally M Rookie of the Year as a teenager, and has received praise from plenty of people in the game, including Wayne Bennett. He has achived little from a team point of view because he had been stuck in shit teams.

He doesn't even belong in the same sentence as Hindmarsh.

He does if you want to talk about a player's individual winning record while ignoring the teams he was in. See my previous post.

But keep bagging a club legend and suggesting he was a bad leader without taking into account the cattle he was leading.

Just my point. You ignore the effect of Sandow's teammates while making a song and dance about the deadshits your hero Hindy was saddled with. And like I said to you, it goes both ways.

But keep making excuses for an over priced poor excuse for a halfback because he plays in a bad team. Be careful that argument works both ways as well Poo.

Mate, you don't tell me to be careful; I tell you to be careful. It does indeed go both ways which is why I brought Hindy's captaincy record up.

It's a team game. That goes for Sandow as much as for Nathan Hindmarsh.

 

[EelsFan05]

Dally M Rookie of the Year as a teenager, and has received praise from plenty of people in the game, including Wayne Bennett. He has achived little from a team point of view because he had been stuck in shit teams.



He does if you want to talk about a player's individual winning record while ignoring the teams he was in. See my previous post.



Just my point. You ignore the effect of Sandow's teammates while making a song and dance about the deadshits your hero Hindy was saddled with. And like I said to you, it goes both ways.



Mate, you don't tell me to be careful; I tell you to be careful. It does indeed go both ways which is why I brought Hindy's captaincy record up.

It's a team game. That goes for Sandow as much as for Nathan Hindmarsh.

Be careful not to get so agitated when you're on the back foot in an argument Poo. But keep punching out of that corner like a good old fighter always does.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

i agree with everything you say pou but f**k me you dribble on and on

When I'm talking to smart people I can keep it short. With idiots I have to anticipate every way they might misunderstand the point, refuse to comprehend the inference, or just plain fail to read the words. So I have to refute every possible stupid response as I go.

And they still find new ways to f**k it up. These dopey merkins make me sad.

 

[I bleed blue & gold]

When I'm talking to smart people I can keep it short. With idiots I have to anticipate every way they might misunderstand the point, refuse to comprehend the inference, or just plain fail to read the words. So I have to refute every possible stupid response as I go.

And they still find new ways to f**k it up. These dopey merkins make me sad.

I guess that's why you are always short with me

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Be careful not to get so agitated when you're on the back foot in an argument Poo. But keep punching out of that corner like a good old fighter always does.

Well mate, I refuted your stupid arguments and you had no comeback. That's good enough for me.

 

[Gary Gutful]

Be real careful talking about a player's individual records in a team game.

Be careful that argument works both ways as well Poo.

Mate, you don't tell me to be careful; I tell you to be careful.

Be careful not to get so agitated when you're on the back foot in an argument Poo.

F**k you guys are extremely cautious...

 

[EelsFan05]

Well mate, I refuted your stupid arguments and you had no comeback. That's good enough for me.

I don't need one. I only have so much time for imbeciles each day and you have exceeded you quota.

 

[IFR33K]

We did start off with rumours, and poo poo supplied the crap, again.

Surprise, surprise.