What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumoured Targets 3

PhilGould

Bench
Messages
3,469
I'm not fussed on Barnett either way. That said - if another club values an under-contract player enough to throw big money at them, maybe demand something in return rather than just letting them walk for free? Pathetic, spineless management if that's how it plays out.
 

PhilGould

Bench
Messages
3,469
Don't think they'd budge on Curran but Chanel Harris-Tavita or Eliesa Katoa are 2 on the fringe at the Warriors that could probably be available. Both for less than what Barnett is already being paid.

Replace Crossland with CHT or Jones/Momoisea with Katoa and we're a better team IMO.
 

Sir Galahad

Juniors
Messages
719
in a very likely scenario Barny will just get there as Browny is out the door.

Must be some serious coin to leave home and support network after just having a kid
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
Ugh that's a bit frustrating.

On a positive note at least it gives him a chance to get here and get in shape and get plenty of practice in.. Hope it means he hits the ground running and super motivated.

He could genuinely be our X-factor and you might even be saying Ponga who? Or they are a dynamite duo..
 
Messages
2,091
I'm not fussed on Barnett either way. That said - if another club values an under-contract player enough to throw big money at them, maybe demand something in return rather than just letting them walk for free? Pathetic, spineless management if that's how it plays out.
100% this. We need to push for some player traffic back our way

Their backrow stocks are pretty full, one of those would be nice
 

Knight Tales

Bench
Messages
3,024
Hard not to be critical of our recruitment plan when we let quality players go early and not replace them. Clune is playing halfback cos we failed to get Brooks. He is doing well but it is really not the point is it. He was never our first choice.
 
Last edited:
Messages
3,167
I'll be honest, I'm not sad to see him go. His bone headed act in Round 3 when we were on top of the best side was unforgivable. I do acknowledge that if we let him go we need someone of equal value or better which doesn't seem to happening and that's the big issue here.
 

PhilGould

Bench
Messages
3,469
Big Tino & Addo-Carr 2 recent examples of players who Melbourne knew were leaving a year in advance. Both were told they would be let go early if the club got something satisfactory in return. Didn't happen, so they played out their deals in Melbourne. Burton last year another example.

Good clubs don't just roll over and let valuable players leave early for no return.

Maybe having a GM of Football with no actual qualifications other than being a good bloke is not a smart way to build a winning football club?
 

PhilGould

Bench
Messages
3,469

Knights shock: Club pulls Ponga offer


Newcastle has sensationally withdrawn its three-year contract extension for Kalyn Ponga, freeing the Knights superstar to become the Dolphins’ first marquee signing.

And the shock decision would allow Newcastle to launch a massive long-term deal for Storm champion Cameron Munster.

The Daily Telegraph understands the club and Ponga had agreed to a new five-year contract before the deal was pulled last Friday.

Sources close to Ponga and the club claim his father, Andre, wanted authority over when the new deal would be announced publicly, not the club.

Certain factions inside Newcastle are unsettled at the influence Andre seems to now have at the club.

While some elements at the club still want to keep Ponga, senior Knights management was becoming increasingly fed-up with Andre’s announcement delay and the money being outlayed for a player struggling to find form.

Last week, the club met with Ponga and the deal – and third party deals - were essentially accepted by both parties before its spectacular collapse.

Newcastle wanted to publicly reveal their Ponga coup last week – the club needed to release a feel-good story - but Andre wanted the announcement delayed.


Ponga, 24, has until round ten to trigger an option for the remaining two years of his existing Knights contract.

Newcastle offered Ponga a three-year extension, a deal which would have secured the champion fullback for another five years. The new deal would have seen Ponga earn $1.1m to $1.2m a year.

The question remains whether Newcastle’s stance is part of contract argy-bargy and the deal can be rekindled or whether the contract is now dead in the water.

Ponga can now ignore the contract clauses his way for 2023 and 2024 and leave Newcastle after this season.

The Dolphins have been circling Ponga for some time and have been desperate to secure a marquee player who is a Queenslander.

Munster comes off contract at Melbourne after next season.

The Storm have offered Munster a new deal worth about $750,000 a year but his manager, Braith Anasta, believes his client is worth $1m a season player.

And few would argue at Munster’s value after his remarkable individual performance for Melbourne against Cronulla on Saturday night.

Aside from Redcliffe, it would appear no other club has the money – nor desire – to shell out more than $1m a year for Ponga. Maybe Wests Tigers could show an interest.

It is known that Newcastle has a special back-up plan to replace Ponga, which is believed to be Munster.

Ponga could still trigger his 2023 and 2024 contract clauses and remain at Newcastle but that scenario would not appear unlikely.

The Maroons star has claimed he wanted to remain at Newcastle to win a premiership. That though would appear unlikely to happen by joining Redcliffe.


Plenty going on in that article
 

Knight Tales

Bench
Messages
3,024
Ritchie said it was a done deal a week ago! KP needs to cut the umbilical clean. His father is an embarrassment frankly speaking. He’s 24!
 
Last edited:

perverse

Referee
Messages
26,700
Ritchie said it was a done deal a week ago! KP needs to cut the umbilical clean. His father is an embarrassment frankly speaking. He’s 24!
According to the article - it was... and Andre was delaying the announcement. It's a weird one... but Andre certainly marches to the beat of his own drum. Might come back to cost them some money here, or result in them moving up north. Either way, as I said weeks ago, I'm unconcerned if he stays or goes at this point, just want the circus over one way or another.

The club is right to stand up to Andre at this stage though. We've treated them very well - and it appears as though the goodwill isn't a 2 way street.
 
Top