It doesn't need to always be true, it just needs to be generally true for my assessment to make more sense than yours. Better players cost more than worse ones. So replacing players with better ones should cost more. You don't need to know anyone's contract details to know that's true. But if you believe there's an exception to that rule at work here then you need to pony up with the details. Otherwise you're not making sense.
And then there is reality. $600k Beau Scott.
Yes you do need to know the contract details, again exhibit A. Beau Scott.
And again Beau Scott.
Oh I'm sure you would be foolish enough if it suited you. Why do you think we can replace our players with better players without it costing more? How much do you think the current players are on? How much do you think their replacements would cost? If you can't even have a guess why are you making such wild claims?
Again Freakin Beau Scott. Who the F knows for real...Beau F**king Scott. Bad timing for you aye Pou with the Beau Scott revelation coming out now. Not so good for your foolish pontificating and bull-crap figures.
So how much do you think we're under, and if it's a lot why didn't we spend it before the comp started when desirable players were off contract?
Again who the F knows, certainly not you. That's for sure.
How much Lodge/TPJ are on now is irrelevant. Their next contract will be driven by demand, and demand is probably very high at the moment.
So we should have a go, right? Or are we just not in the game by your pathetic negative logic?
And while I agree Lodge and TPJ would both improve our top 17, that isn't enough reason to sign them at any cost. We already have enough forwards contracted for next year (even though you don't rate them) and with our remaining cap space we need to address the bigger holes in the roster, being hooker and the outside backs.
Again just crapping on to suggest that I would sign anyone at any price. But yes I would rather sure up our forwards and halves before any other position in the team. Outside backs are much easier to come by then Lodge and TPJ quality forwards that are right now available. If you can't see that, then there's not much else left to say.
You know Pou, you're the type of person that would say in a couple of years time, something like, "we didn't really need to improve our forwards by much back in 2018. Our backs were the issue and trying to buy players like TPJ or Lodge is way to expensive now anyway. They just don't grow on trees you know."
But halves and forwards win you games, even if your backs are a little average, at least you won't be 2-9 and soon to be 2-12 and so on it will go. Also I think that we can probably produce more outside backs then top notch forwards for some reason. We seem to have failed at that dismally in the last decade.