What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,848
I remember when Smithy was coaching us the chorus of deathriders couldn't wait to see the back of him.

Now we seem to have gone full circle with some of the same people wanting him back.

I wonder how many will want BA back as HOF in 10 years time.
I reckon it’s a role he’s more suited to.
 

Joshuatheeel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,160
it does to me if you read below

But wait here is more:

“After the warm ups, stretching and core strength work with Lachlan Wimot, the squad launched into a couple of kilometres of shuttle runs. ”

https://thecumberlandthrow.com/2018...-training-january-8-2018-big-blokes-bring-it/

“In addition to the regular core strength stretches and runs, there were fun games and highly coordinated sprint sequences. Watching the range of drills employed by Lachlan Wilmot, and how synchronised the squad were in their execution, really emphasised the buy-in of the playersWell out of the few thousand words they wrote the last been above us is really the only time they give the AFL credit and it was an opinion piece. The rest was just reporting I reckon.

Selective reading again:

Well out of the few thousand words they wrote the last been above us is really the only time they give the AFL credit and it was an opinion piece. The rest was just reporting I reckon.
 

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,746
Well he never got himself involved enough for any chance to burn anybody. Against Mounties in ISP both wingers showed him the sideline and he left them for dead. Also the time trial was in December and he would have been fresh
Bev showed his real speed in Roosters game, his best game of the year imo. Gave Tedesco a 2 metre start and run him down and prevented a try! So who is the quickest player in NRL, probably Bev. With right tactics and dominant pack I still believe he'll make a good fist of fullback in the Dufty mould. But BAs tactics, or lack thereof, have severely hindered him.
 

TheRam

Coach
Messages
13,884
I don’t disagree with anything you posted there. The club is terrible at the moment. F**ken terrible.

Personally I think some people such as yourself and Ram try and project yourselves as geniuses when clearly you aren’t.

Also, there is a very strong tendency to talk things up with the benefit of hindsight (which those that are managing the issues don’t get to do). Everyone can look like a genius with hindsight and occasionally I like to remind you of that.

It would be pretty boring if we all just agreed with you and told you that you were brilliant. We’d also be lying to you, but more importantly, lying to ourselves.

No hard feelings and just a bit of banter at the end of the day.

On your first point. Then STOP needling everyone that decides to vent or express their opinions on that very topic ffs or you just sound like a schizophrenic baiter who is just being a dick.

As for trying to project ourselves as geniuses, sure at times Hindy and I will clown around and pretend to be know it alls, but that is clearly tongue in cheek stuff. The other times we are just putting forward our own belief as to what could benefit our roster/club or what they should not have done in the first place and now look at the mess that has transpired.

Is some of it in hindsight? Yeah of causes it is and for sure, but many of the things that our club has done that has turned out to be disastrous many here not just Hindy and I had misgivings from the very beginning. But you and Gronk and others, have your own revisionist history model you work from and will keep hammering that agenda till the handle breaks off. HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER...
Perfect simple example of agenda besmirching is to constantly criticise anyone who suggested we need big forwards. You and others seized on that and made out that we were referring to anyone that was fat and heavy and that that wasn't the issue and that we should be seeking quality. Well der. It didn't matter how many times we said it was a given that the big forwards needed to be quality, the derision and jokes kept coming.
HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER...

As for the those who manage the issues not having hindsight, sure, but they do/should have inside information that should make their decisions less likely to backfire if they are up to it. Well results over the years have taught us that they have been wanting on that and thus we are here again...14th wooden spoon. Now how can Hindy and I and others ever be unhappy about that? And how could we ever be critical in hindsight or otherwise?

I'll tell you what, you, Gronk and the other apologist are lucky you don't follow European Soccer. Teams over there have 1 or 2 losing seasons and the fans want to lynch everyone associated with the team. The apologists are outnumbered 100:1 And my hostility towards losers is amateurish when compared to those fanatics.

And yes it would be very boring if we all simply agreed on everything. Oh and believe me that I am absolutely lying to you when I say that I think you are freakin brilliant.

Tongue in cheek dude, don't get your knickers in a knot. Cheers
 
Messages
19,383
On your first point. Then STOP needling everyone that decides to vent or express their opinions on that very topic ffs or you just sound like a schizophrenic baiter who is just being a dick.

As for trying to project ourselves as geniuses, sure at times Hindy and I will clown around and pretend to be know it alls, but that is clearly tongue in cheek stuff. The other times we are just putting forward our own belief as to what could benefit our roster/club or what they should not have done in the first place and now look at the mess that has transpired.

Is some of it in hindsight? Yeah of causes it is and for sure, but many of the things that our club has done that has turned out to be disastrous many here not just Hindy and I had misgivings from the very beginning. But you and Gronk and others, have your own revisionist history model you work from and will keep hammering that agenda till the handle breaks off. HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER...
Perfect simple example of agenda besmirching is to constantly criticise anyone who suggested we need big forwards. You and others seized on that and made out that we were referring to anyone that was fat and heavy and that that wasn't the issue and that we should be seeking quality. Well der. It didn't matter how many times we said it was a given that the big forwards needed to be quality, the derision and jokes kept coming.
HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER...

As for the those who manage the issues not having hindsight, sure, but they do/should have inside information that should make their decisions less likely to backfire if they are up to it. Well results over the years have taught us that they have been wanting on that and thus we are here again...14th wooden spoon. Now how can Hindy and I and others ever be unhappy about that? And how could we ever be critical in hindsight or otherwise?

I'll tell you what, you, Gronk and the other apologist are lucky you don't follow European Soccer. Teams over there have 1 or 2 losing seasons and the fans want to lynch everyone associated with the team. The apologists are outnumbered 100:1 And my hostility towards losers is amateurish when compared to those fanatics.

And yes it would be very boring if we all simply agreed on everything. Oh and believe me that I am absolutely lying to you when I say that I think you are freakin brilliant.

Tongue in cheek dude, don't get your knickers in a knot. Cheers


How are things, Casper?
 
Last edited:

TheRam

Coach
Messages
13,884
I remember when Smithy was coaching us the chorus of deathriders couldn't wait to see the back of him.

Now we seem to have gone full circle with some of the same people wanting him back.

I wonder how many will want BA back as HOF in 10 years time.

I was one of those, but who said anything about him coaching the team or don't you understand the difference between the 2 rolls being discussed here? Or don't you think he is qualified for the roll of HOF?
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,025
I was one of those, but who said anything about him coaching the team or don't you understand the difference between the 2 rolls being discussed here? Or don't you think he is qualified for the roll of HOF?

I didn't give any opinions so not sure how you can make such a conclusion from my post. I was making an observation based on how peoples behaviours/opinions has changed over the years.

Personally I think he would do a good job as HOF because he has shown that he can do the job by what he has achieved at the Warriors but as he is still under contract to them I dont think he is on our list of candidates.
 

TheRam

Coach
Messages
13,884
I didn't give any opinions so not sure how you can make such a conclusion from my post. I was making an observation based on how peoples behaviours/opinions has changed over the years.

Personally I think he would do a good job as HOF because he has shown that he can do the job by what he has achieved at the Warriors but as he is still under contract to them I dont think he is on our list of candidates.

Cool. I think he would do a good job too. As for contract? They mean nothing if there is a will to break it. It's made even easier if he chose to do so, by citing that he wants to come home(family) etc...
 

Joshuatheeel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,160
they said AFL guy was our best signing after you claimed they weren't jerking off over him

If You actually read what I said, all their reports which there were 20 or so they pretty much just reported what they saw, without blowing their load on the AFL dude (which many claimed they did).

It was only in one opinion piece did they give their opinion on him !! 2 paragraphs out of a couple thousand words!! Not the wank feast some have claimed!!!
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,025
Cool. I think he would do a good job too. As for contract? They mean nothing if there is a will to break it. It's made even easier if he chose to do so, by citing that he wants to come home(family) etc...

I suspect we may aim for some one younger but I guess we'll see. Smithy seems to have a soft spot of the Eels so he may consider breaking his deal to "come home".
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
52,913
On your first point. Then STOP needling everyone that decides to vent or express their opinions on that very topic ffs or you just sound like a schizophrenic baiter who is just being a dick.

As for trying to project ourselves as geniuses, sure at times Hindy and I will clown around and pretend to be know it alls, but that is clearly tongue in cheek stuff. The other times we are just putting forward our own belief as to what could benefit our roster/club or what they should not have done in the first place and now look at the mess that has transpired.

Is some of it in hindsight? Yeah of causes it is and for sure, but many of the things that our club has done that has turned out to be disastrous many here not just Hindy and I had misgivings from the very beginning. But you and Gronk and others, have your own revisionist history model you work from and will keep hammering that agenda till the handle breaks off. HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER...
Perfect simple example of agenda besmirching is to constantly criticise anyone who suggested we need big forwards. You and others seized on that and made out that we were referring to anyone that was fat and heavy and that that wasn't the issue and that we should be seeking quality. Well der. It didn't matter how many times we said it was a given that the big forwards needed to be quality, the derision and jokes kept coming.
HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER, HAMMER...

As for the those who manage the issues not having hindsight, sure, but they do/should have inside information that should make their decisions less likely to backfire if they are up to it. Well results over the years have taught us that they have been wanting on that and thus we are here again...14th wooden spoon. Now how can Hindy and I and others ever be unhappy about that? And how could we ever be critical in hindsight or otherwise?

I'll tell you what, you, Gronk and the other apologist are lucky you don't follow European Soccer. Teams over there have 1 or 2 losing seasons and the fans want to lynch everyone associated with the team. The apologists are outnumbered 100:1 And my hostility towards losers is amateurish when compared to those fanatics.

And yes it would be very boring if we all simply agreed on everything. Oh and believe me that I am absolutely lying to you when I say that I think you are freakin brilliant.

Tongue in cheek dude, don't get your knickers in a knot. Cheers
All good mate. Nothing like a bit of healthy debate.

Believe me I don’t deliberately try and disagree with you to stir you. Some of what you comment on makes sense but if I think you are talking shit (which you occasionally do) then I am going to call you on it. Just as others do.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,261
So it's gone from bash the coach to.. Bash who ever shows support to the coach before the season started..
 

Gazzamatta

Coach
Messages
15,605
So it's gone from bash the coach to.. Bash who ever shows support to the coach before the season started..
Lol. Can go in reverse as well mate but that just about sums it up. Looks like BA has done a Houdini so best to move on and wish him well. A huge task to turn The Titanic around though.
 

Latest posts

Top