What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Glenneel

Bench
Messages
3,756
If you actually read what I post, you will note that I have stated this week that a) our regular halfback is being held together with sticky tape, so I get why a back up needed to be considered vs Raiders b) that unless Jake puts on the kegs significantly to his already big frame, I think his future lies in Super League.
I've not criticized JA but have his selection, and the 15 player option BA picks, because I believe our forwards need to be rested to maintain high intensity. Now this might work against the weaker teams but I don't think it is the right option for the next 2 (or 1) game/s. Cows to be played in high heat and humidity and if we win we just need the full 17 players to beat Panthers.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,628
I've not criticized JA but have his selection, and the 15 player option BA picks, because I believe our forwards need to be rested to maintain high intensity. Now this might work against the weaker teams but I don't think it is the right option for the next 2 (or 1) game/s. Cows to be played in high heat and humidity and if we win we just need the full 17 players to beat Panthers.
You might be right. Or wrong.

Both the Cows and the Eels seem to use 15 players of late and only use 16 and 17 when required.

For what it’s worth BA played Carty in NT and both Makka and Carty played 19mins each. We got wooped in that match too.

If it aint broke, then don’t fix it comes to mind. Wins vs Storm and Raiders seems to suggest this. But what would I know.
f**k all really.
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,192
I also want to say how disgusted I am that some lowlife would leak Nathan Brown's report.

Can you imagine how Jakob Arthur would be feeling, with these accusations of nepotism being thrown around?

Whether you like Jake as a player or not, he's done nothing wrong; he has given 100% every time he has put on our jersey, and this report comes out, and declares that senior players are pissed that he's getting selected...

I can't imagine how he must be feeling.

I'm actually very impressed that he was able to put that aside, and perform quite solidly last night.
 

Soto

Bench
Messages
4,214
I know cows did it last match but has anyone been further back to see if Payten did that In other matches?
I don’t know but i think it would've been noted earlier if that was the case...
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,282
I know cows did it last match but has anyone been further back to see if Payten did that In other matches?
I don’t know but i think it would've been noted earlier if that was the case...
Due to their great defence they’ve had a lot of big wins this year, so it would only be worth looking at their close wins (and losses). It’s easy to throw garbage minutes at a reserve grader when the result isn’t in doubt. Arthur’s does it too.
 

Bandwagon

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
44,880
I also want to say how disgusted I am that some lowlife would leak Nathan Brown's report.

Can you imagine how Jakob Arthur would be feeling, with these accusations of nepotism being thrown around?

Whether you like Jake as a player or not, he's done nothing wrong; he has given 100% every time he has put on our jersey, and this report comes out, and declares that senior players are pissed that he's getting selected...

I can't imagine how he must be feeling.

I'm actually very impressed that he was able to put that aside, and perform quite solidly last night.

It's not being claimed the report states senior players are pissed at JA's selection, the report isn't even about the NRL team as such, it's about pathways.

The claim of senior players being pissed is entirely separate, and seems based on little more than rumour.
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,192
It's not being claimed the report states senior players are pissed at JA's selection, the report isn't even about the NRL team as such, it's about pathways.

The claim of senior players being pissed is entirely separate, and seems based on little more than rumour.

My mistake. It was quoted in the same article
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
It's dissapointing that Under 20s and NSW CUP aren't on the same week as NRL GRAND FINAL.

Penrith are in the grand final for both. They also won the SG BALL. It would be an enormous effort if they took out all 4 grades. Almost unheard of.
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,021
It's dissapointing that Under 20s and NSW CUP aren't on the same week as NRL GRAND FINAL.

Penrith are in the grand final for both. They also won the SG BALL. It would be an enormous effort if they took out all 4 grades. Almost unheard of.
Which is why our club should camp out at all those grand finals and the raid the f**k out of their juniors.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
Which is why our club should camp out at all those grand finals and the raid the f**k out of their juniors.

Agree. People say they'll drop off next year. I mean they may but they obviously are stacked.
Like I said I have been told we have nothing in lower grades coming through of any great quality for about 2-3yrs
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,282
Agree. People say they'll drop off next year. I mean they may but they obviously are stacked.
Like I said I have been told we have nothing in lower grades coming through of any great quality for about 2-3yrs
You can buy a team in less time than that. We’ve had more luck improving cheap nuffies from other clubs than poaching juniors and trying to keep them. You can build a team with mercenaries but you don’t build a culture with them, however building with juniors is very expensive.

It’s like Sharp said when talking about salary cap laundering through TPAs, you might need to spend $300k outside the cap to realise a thirty grand benefit under it. It’s the same with trying to beat the cap with loyal juniors. Building the program that gets you the most genuine candidates early enough costs a lot of money outside the cap. Far more than the realised salary cap benefit. It is a type of money laundering.
 
Last edited:

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,628
It's dissapointing that Under 20s and NSW CUP aren't on the same week as NRL GRAND FINAL.

Penrith are in the grand final for both. They also won the SG BALL. It would be an enormous effort if they took out all 4 grades. Almost unheard of.
We used to have a club championship once. You’d get points awarded for your club performance across U23s, Reggies and Firsts. A was shield awarded and it was quite prestigious. Dunno what happened to it, does anyone know ?
 

Latest posts

Top