What are your thoughts on Gutho as a hooker in 2 years time?
He will run from dummy half, he can kick a bit, he is super fit, he can tackle, he can pass.
I would hope by then we have done our homework and actually recruited a quality specialist DH than rely on moving our best and most consistent player and captain into the middle hoping that he can transition into a quality rake.
Maybe he can, but what if he doesn't? What then? We lose another season or two trying to find a suitable replacement? Matt Arthur may turn out to be a star, but what if he doesn't or he still needs a good 4 years or more to be a quality 9? What then?
All these speculations and assumptions are fine by us the fans, but if I were the coach, no way would I be punting on all these positional changes you guys are proposing and hope I am right.
We need a speedster and or powerful bulldozer in the backline. That's what we should be signing. We need a couple of big powerful boppers in the middle. That's what we should be signing. We need a specialist DH. That's what we should be signing.
Not moving and repurposing players that are gifted in the positions that they are currently in. If for some reason Gutho becomes pedestrian or ineffectual at fullback in 2 or 3 years time, we can reassess his position at the club then. If it coincides with his contract year all the better and it should reflect that to. Specialists and stability is the key, not makeshift and uncertainty.