Rumours and Stuff

[hineyrulz]

Yes
2025 is a rebuild.
BA era has left us with a bottom 2 finish
A bunch of over paid old players with POs
No money to spend
Our most highly rated juniors signing elsewhere.

But but but but Bea has been awesome for the club I’ve been told!!

 

[hindy111]

But but but but Bea has been awesome for the club I’ve been told!!

When he arrived we had Hayne, a young Jnr and Semi, Manu a stack of money to spend.
Unsure if we are in a better position now or then? We have a better halves I guess which is hard to get.

 

[Pazza]

When he arrived we had Hayne, a young Jnr and Semi, Manu a stack of money to spend.
Unsure if we are in a better position now or then? We have a better halves I guess which is hard to get.

I'll take what Moses has become over all those guys

 

[hindy111]

I'll take what Moses has become over all those guys

Over Hayne at his peak had he not gone off the rails?
He could of been the best of all time. 2014 looked like he just put it all together. He single handed won an origin series.
He was 26 and just getting to he peak years
NO WAY

 

[Soren Lorenson]

@hindy111 what's happened to Soni Luke? Is he injured or fallen out of favour? He was the next best thing for a while there.

 

[hindy111]

@hindy111 what's happened to Soni Luke? Is he injured or fallen out of favour? He was the next best thing for a while there.

He is garbage

 

[Soren Lorenson]

He is garbage

wanna elaborate Mr 85%?

 

[hindy111]

wanna elaborate Mr 85%?

Can't tackle well, errors, erratic
All he does well is his run game

 

[Pazza]

Over Hayne at his peak had he not gone off the rails?
He could of been the best of all time. 2014 looked like he just put it all together. He single handed won an origin series.
He was 26 and just getting to he peak years
NO WAY

He was an elite player but we never won anything with him. I'm excited over the next few years of having a genuine elite hafback.

 

[Soren Lorenson]

Can't tackle well, errors, erratic
All he does well is his run game

So are you saying the Penrith system couldn't teach him how to defend in the line?

 

[84 Baby]

So are you saying the Penrith system couldn't teach him how to defend in the line?

It was BAs fault for signing his brother

 

[Gronk]

I'll take what Moses has become over all those guys

100%. Merkins have short memories about our No.7 jersey curse.

 

[hindy111]

So are you saying the Penrith system couldn't teach him how to defend in the line?

When you're small I reckon you're always going to struggle. MA will be the same. Unless elite in every other area his little body will let him down.
Hands may not be skilfful or as crafty but he is a big body and can save tries on the line

 

[hindy111]

100%. Merkins have short memories about our No.7 jersey curse.

View attachment 92758

Moses is a very good halfback. Not the best. Maybe top 3. Never ever a chance to be talked about as an immortal.

Jarryd Hayne was a two time Dally M winner and potentially the greatest player the game has produced. Had he backed up his 2014 form for another 4-5 yrs then he takes that crown I'd say as the beat player the games seen.
Anyone who prefers Moses to that is a fool

 

[Gronk]

Moses is a very good halfback. Not the best. Maybe top 3. Never ever a chance to be talked about as an immortal.

Jarryd Hayne was a two time Dally M winner and potentially the greatest player the game has produced. Had he backed up his 2014 form for another 4-5 yrs then he takes that crown I'd say as the beat player the games seen.
Anyone who prefers Moses to that is a fool

That's great mate. He got us to a GF like Moses has. We also were regulars in the semis with Moses.

How did we go after 2009 with your immortal ?

 

[Eelementary]

Having lightweight forwards is great for mobility, and ruck defence - but we need to offset that somewhat with quick, powerful backs, like Penrith do.

We have powerful backs, like Sivo, and Penisini.

We have quick backs, like Simonsson.

But we don't have backs with both attributes, imo.

 

[Eelementary]

He was an elite player but we never won anything with him. I'm excited over the next few years of having a genuine elite hafback.

You mean until he goes to the Chooks, right?

 

[Eelementary]

Also - watch Penrith turn Talagi into a defensive beast next year.

 

[Gazzamatta]

6-7 years grace before we start whinging?

11.5 would be fair.

 

[Gazzamatta]

Can't tackle well, errors, erratic
All he does well is his run game

Was good enough to spell Boods for 12 to 15 mins each week.