What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Gazzamatta

Coach
Messages
15,646
The Papalii thing was always going to blow up eventually once Maguire was sacked. I was told at the time the sweetner for the deal with playing under the NZ coach as Ice is clearly going to be a representative level player for long into the future. Maguire is gone now, so what exactly is the upside to going to the tigers? If we can offer the same money - then nothing.

From a contract standpoint - i dont think he should be allowed to renege on the contract unless we offer the same financial terms.
Only The Chooks are allowed to do that. Sorry, I mean "The Brave Chooks".
 

The Rosco

Bench
Messages
2,909
Love seeing the difference between eels fans with some self respect and dignity, and the rest of you dumb merkins that are supporting him, and think he is entitled to renege on his contract as long as you pay the same $$.
If he wants to brush us ( and that don't make it guaranteed that he wants to stay with you guys ), I hope my club has the balls to stand their ground and make him play or sit out of the NRL for 3 years.
When this window closes, and you lot go back to being regular wooden spooners, I hope and pray that some good player that signs for you wants to back out. And then listen to your whining. Karma is a bitch in high heels.
 

Soto

Bench
Messages
4,221
To me the Nathan Brown "no contract beyond 2023" now makes sense.
Leave now and get yourself a longer contract and we use the portion we aren't paying for his full contract to up Papali'i's contract.
Yes it sucks for the Tigers but at the end of the day if we keep Papali'i who is about to hit his prime and lose a declining NRown it's a massive benefit for us..
Contracts are meant to be broken...especially if there was a clause in it about the coach.. I won't mention the paper part as I don't want to upset too many ppl. 🤣
 

Gazzamatta

Coach
Messages
15,646
Love seeing the difference between eels fans with some self respect and dignity, and the rest of you dumb merkins that are supporting him, and think he is entitled to renege on his contract as long as you pay the same $$.
If he wants to brush us ( and that don't make it guaranteed that he wants to stay with you guys ), I hope my club has the balls to stand their ground and make him play or sit out of the NRL for 3 years.
When this window closes, and you lot go back to being regular wooden spooners, I hope and pray that some good player that signs for you wants to back out. And then listen to your whining. Karma is a bitch in high heels.
The other Papalii had a wee little change of heart a few years ago if I recall.
Then there was Tedesco who reneged on Ricky to return to The Tigpies before jumping overboard a second time for the brave Chooks.
It happens dude. No one except the brave Chooks is immune.
 
Last edited:

Pazza

First Grade
Messages
9,790
Weren't we very very close to getting Ali Lauitiiti and his grandma talked him into staying at the warriors.
 

Noise

Coach
Messages
18,169
Love seeing the difference between eels fans with some self respect and dignity, and the rest of you dumb merkins that are supporting him, and think he is entitled to renege on his contract as long as you pay the same $$.
If he wants to brush us ( and that don't make it guaranteed that he wants to stay with you guys ), I hope my club has the balls to stand their ground and make him play or sit out of the NRL for 3 years.
When this window closes, and you lot go back to being regular wooden spooners, I hope and pray that some good player that signs for you wants to back out. And then listen to your whining. Karma is a bitch in high heels.
You are aware the Tedesco backflipped on the Raiders to stay with you guys? And that it has already happened to us when we signed Josh Papali'i and he reneged to stay in Canberra? If it happens with Ice then it's no different to all the other times it has happened.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,418
Love seeing the difference between eels fans with some self respect and dignity, and the rest of you dumb merkins that are supporting him, and think he is entitled to renege on his contract as long as you pay the same $$.
If he wants to brush us ( and that don't make it guaranteed that he wants to stay with you guys ), I hope my club has the balls to stand their ground and make him play or sit out of the NRL for 3 years.
When this window closes, and you lot go back to being regular wooden spooners, I hope and pray that some good player that signs for you wants to back out. And then listen to your whining. Karma is a bitch in high heels.

Well If your stupid club didn't sack yet another coach you wouldn't be in here looking like a jealous ex girlfriend..
 

I bleed blue & gold

First Grade
Messages
8,850
Love seeing the difference between eels fans with some self respect and dignity, and the rest of you dumb merkins that are supporting him, and think he is entitled to renege on his contract as long as you pay the same $$.
If he wants to brush us ( and that don't make it guaranteed that he wants to stay with you guys ), I hope my club has the balls to stand their ground and make him play or sit out of the NRL for 3 years.
When this window closes, and you lot go back to being regular wooden spooners, I hope and pray that some good player that signs for you wants to back out. And then listen to your whining. Karma is a bitch in high heels.
45A64F46-7B53-4AE5-A377-9D0ECD986F5C.jpeg
 

yy_cheng

Coach
Messages
18,734
I enjoy deriding anyone who thinks there’s a simple or obvious answer. I enjoy having Papali’i in the team but he’s not good enough that we should entertain paying overs. Moses probably is though, in the sense that he might be impossible to replace. But then that really depends on Dylan Brown and how much we have to pay to keep him. One thing for sure, if we lose Moses our kicking game will be significantly worse. But our defence will probably improve. It’s never simple.
Go after Burton if we lose Moses.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
Love seeing the difference between eels fans with some self respect and dignity, and the rest of you dumb merkins that are supporting him, and think he is entitled to renege on his contract as long as you pay the same $$.
If he wants to brush us ( and that don't make it guaranteed that he wants to stay with you guys ), I hope my club has the balls to stand their ground and make him play or sit out of the NRL for 3 years.
When this window closes, and you lot go back to being regular wooden spooners, I hope and pray that some good player that signs for you wants to back out. And then listen to your whining. Karma is a bitch in high heels.


If no clause then I'd want compensation. N. BROWN is not compensation as we don't really want him. I'd ask for a promising junior plus N.Brown for 200k . But I am with you. He signed and should stay loyal to that.
 

Latest posts

Top