What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

lucablight

First Grade
Messages
6,880
Are you arguing that Lussick could be as good as Cameron Smith? If so I’d love to hear your argument. I’m certain I can counter any point you try to make. I’ll start with the obvious one: how many NRL players improved after the age of 30? You’d have more luck arguing that Ryley Smith could be as good as Harry Grant, which I also disagree with, but there is less evidence against it.
Well going by your logic if it’s an opinion it can’t be proven so the strength of the arguments is irrelevant no?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
95,575
Well going by your logic if it’s an opinion it can’t be proven so the strength of the arguments is irrelevant no?
Your second statement doesn’t follow from the first.

Regarding Lussick’s and Da Silva’s relative potential, let’s flip the comparisons and see if it illuminates the difference for you any better. I confidently predict Lussick will never be as good as Cameron Smith. Are you equally confident TDS will never be as good as Harry Grant?
 

85 Baby

Juniors
Messages
284
Your second statement doesn’t follow from the first.

Regarding Lussick’s and Da Silva’s relative potential, let’s flip the comparisons and see if it illuminates the difference for you any better. I confidently predict Lussick will never be as good as Cameron Smith. Are you equally confident TDS will never be as good as Harry Grant?
No because he thinks Lussick is already better than Smith?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
95,575

Talk about TDS

And Brandy almost had a stroke over the Knights signing Jake Arthur and questioning are the Knights just handing out contracts to coaches mates.
They do already have plenty of backup halves, though last week they had Fletcher Hunt playing 6 in reserve grade so they are getting thin on availability. They've also lost Ponga so Sharpe will have to play fullback, though he has his own health issues.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
17,831
They do already have plenty of backup halves, though last week they had Fletcher Hunt playing 6 in reserve grade so they are getting thin on availability. They've also lost Ponga so Sharpe will have to play fullback, though he has his own health issues.
Its exciting we play the Knights in the last round at Commbank on Sunday the September 7th.

Might be to avoid the spoon

Sharpe won't be back this year.
I doubt Ponga will be back either with a serious foot injury why risk him for the last few rounds.
Dylan's last game at Parramatta we can walk him into the Newcastle sheds at FT and give him a goodbye wave.

And by then Newcastle might be playing there 4th string halfback
 

Latest posts

Top