What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Sbw 1 - nrl 0

Micistm

Bench
Messages
4,470
Money Bill coming back is absolutely predictable. I have been saying it for months. Regardless of his on field abilities, his absolutely mercenary approach to life just destroys his street cred.

I am an employer. If I got this blokes CV, he might have all the skills, I wouldn't hire him. I'd have to pay him too much and he would upset the rest of my team. I couldn't rely on his loyalty and the fact that he would put the company's best interests at heart and as soon as he sensed a better offer was on the table he'd be off, then my efforts to develop him would be lost.

If I were a professional rugby league manager, I wouldn't hire him for the same reasons.

He will bring publicity. Sure. But will it be good? Doesn't this bloke just cheapen the image of professional sportsman and make the whole thing a joke?

I'd be happy for him to disappear off to France to play rugby....or soccer...or be a male model.


Could not agree more.:)
 

hitman82

Bench
Messages
4,937
http://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/6292468/He-can-t-box-SBWs-an-amateur-Sir-Bob

Veteran boxing historian and promoter Sir Bob Jones reckons Sonny Bill Williams "can't box" and should be fighting as an amateur.

But Williams' manager, Khoder Nasser, fired back, saying he's never heard of Sir Bob and wants to see his boxing "credentials".

Williams is scheduled to fight Clarence Tillman III for the title at Claudelands Arena in Hamilton on February 8.

Since launching his boxing career in 2009, the star All Black has fought, and beaten, four much lesser opponents, including 43-year-old gospel-singing sickness beneficiary Alipate Liava'a in June last year.

Sir Bob said yesterday Williams was not a credible boxer and should not be fighting as a professional, let alone for the heavyweight title.

"I'm afraid as a boxing historian I cannot take SBW seriously," he said.

"He can't box; he's what we call an arm-puncher, but that's hardly surprising given his novice status. If he enjoys boxing then that of course is his business and he should go for it – but as an amateur."


Sir Bob, a former boxing manager, promoter and commentator, said Williams strikes him as a person "desperate to get his name in the papers and prepared to do anything".

He also took a swing at Sky TV for promoting and broadcasting the fight "just because mugs pay".


Mr Nasser said he should not even have to answer the comments.

"Why am I even talking, or even rebutting, someone who doesn't even register on the map?" he said.

Williams was surrounded and trained by credible boxing people, including former world champion Anthony Mundine.

Waikato Boxing Association president Rik Ellis said Williams was a credible contender for the title and was taking a step up in fighting Tillman.

"Sonny Bill Williams is probably going to be presented with a little bit more of a task than he had with Tutaki. [Tillman's] a bigger man, he's effectively a very good boxer, so straight answer – more credibility."

He said despite Williams only having four fights under his belt, he had proven himself a capable boxer.

"At the end of the day it's about who's good enough on that day, and I really do think that experience doesn't have much to do with it in this case."

Mr Ellis said Williams, who has been training at his Ringside Gym in Hamilton, was an "absolute athlete". His "star power" wouldn't count for much in the ring but he had fantastic co-ordination.
:lol:
 

Fast Eddie

First Grade
Messages
8,085
Credible boxer? He is talking about if the guy can box, and I've seen two of his fights and it's not pretty viewing. The guy looks terrible in the ring, because like Jones said is an amateur who doesn't know what he is doing.
 

ozbash

Referee
Messages
26,922
Sir Bob said yesterday Williams was not a credible boxer and should not be fighting as a professional, let alone for the heavyweight title.




well bobby, what are you going to say when SBW wins ?

My oldest boy is good mates with one of the guys on the undercard, Dave someone,Tongan guy and also a member of Khoders camp. Says SBW is the consumate pro, trains harder, lives with discipline and steers well clear of the bullshit (and theres plenty of it) from the Mundine camp.

SBW's last fight, he moved hotels to get his own space and avoid the rest.

Still, if Sir Bob says...
 

Penrose Warrior

First Grade
Messages
9,467
If he stayed clear of the bullshit, he'd a) not be involved with the Mundine camp at all b) be giving his energies to the code that pays his wages.
 

Rich102

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,762
Note to $BW.
Have a think about taking on Kim Dotcom.
Meets all your requirements:
Will bring lots of publicity.
Hugely overweight.
Can't box.
 

ozbash

Referee
Messages
26,922
Long before the letters S, B and W came to mean something other than a theme for Sesame Street, there was Kevin Skinner.
A fearsome prop from the old school, the 20-test All Black is still revered in rugby circles after coming out of retirement for two tests in 1956 and dealing to Springbok props Chris Koch and Jaap Bekker.
In the days when men were men and the All Black jersey hung a little looser, they didn't come much tougher than Skinner, who, in 1947, was crowned the heavyweight boxing champ of New Zealand while juggling his playing commitments for Otago.
Fast forward 65 years and another All Black – he of those now-famous initials – is hoping to follow in Skinner's giant footsteps when he steps into the ring on February 8 to take on giant American Clarence Tillman III for the New Zealand heavyweight title.
If Sonny Bill Williams wins, he will be the first All Black since Skinner to claim the belt.
That's no easy feat and so on Wednesday morning, Williams, who was told of the legendary Skinner by former Wallabies captain Sir Nicholas Shehadie, decided to call in on the man himself at his home in West Auckland for some advice.
"When I told him [Sir Nicholas] I was going to fight for the [NZ title] belt, he started telling me some stories about Kevin Skinner," Williams told the Sunday Star-Times.
"He was telling me how he [dealt to] a couple of Springboks players and ... how he was feared without being a dirty player.
"I grew up on rugby league so I didn't really know too much about Kevin Skinner. But from what people have been telling me, he was a well-respected man within the game.
"When I heard that he was a boxer as well, I was desperate to meet him."
The visit was supposed to be a fleeting one but Williams was so captivated by Skinner and his wife Laurie that he ended up staying all morning.
"It was choice, man, unreal," Williams said. "He's a lovely bloke and so was his wife; she was a character.
"We had a really good yarn, a laugh and we ended up staying for a couple of hours.
"We talked about life, boxing, rugby, everything. He told me at the start when I played for the All Blacks he was a bit iffy about my style of play. But he told me he quickly came around, and that was so cool to hear him say that." Although at 84 Skinner might be past his prime, Williams said the All Black legend was still a tough character.
"You could tell he's been around, man," Williams said.
"It would be such an honour to follow in his footsteps, especially after meeting the bloke. I feel like now I've got even more drive inside to do this."
Whatever it was that Skinner told Williams on Wednesday, it appears to have had the desired effect of firing-up the All Black midfielder.
His sparring session on Friday evening in Auckland with Commonwealth Games superheavyweight boxer Joseph Parker was interrupted in the second round for Parker to have a profusely bleeding nose tended to.
"The training's been tough," Williams said. "Clarence Tillman, he's a big man. [The bout's] for the belt and it's daunting but also exciting. But I wouldn't have it any other way."

http://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/other-sports/6295070/Sonny-Bill-Williams-meets-his-match-in-Skinner
 
Messages
857
well bobby, what are you going to say when SBW wins ?

My oldest boy is good mates with one of the guys on the undercard, Dave someone,Tongan guy and also a member of Khoders camp. Says SBW is the consumate pro, trains harder, lives with discipline and steers well clear of the bullshit (and theres plenty of it) from the Mundine camp.

SBW's last fight, he moved hotels to get his own space and avoid the rest.

Still, if Sir Bob says...

Doesn't mean he's not a shit boxer.
 

Micistm

Bench
Messages
4,470
If he stayed clear of the bullshit, he'd a) not be involved with the Mundine camp at all b) be giving his energies to the code that pays his wages.

I've heard two fans of different codes, Phil Gifford for Union and the Mad Butch for league, say EXACTLY the same thing about $BW: If you get the guy on his own, you won't find a nicer, more humble young bloke. Once the Mundine Management entourage are around, he's a jumped up strutty, arrogant little ****.
Unfortunately while he'll be rich in the end his sporting career will be defined as a joke.
Sir Bob always speaks his mind, very opinionated and sometimes annoying, but often speaks the truth. And certainly knows his boxing.
 

Micistm

Bench
Messages
4,470
Worth noting Shane Cameron offered to fight...camp Mundine didn't accept for some odd reason... ;-)
 

Rich102

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,762
Probably the same as the rest of us- The only thing it will prove is what a joke Boxing has become, bordering on WWF stuff:lol:

I was thinking the same thing. Shame boxing has gone so far downhill. I used to go to most of the fights when I was in Ak. (From the time I saw Monty Betham Sen and Tony Mundine fight at Carlaw, to seeing Lance Revill win the NZ Heavyweight crown).
The $BW fight does not justify top billing on a pro card and certainly $BW should not get a NZ title by fighting a loser of his choosing.
Also I think SKY TV are making a farce of the bout by charging so much for watching rights.
I guess money rules.

Still, I would pay to see $BW fight Shane Cameron :lol:
 

Latest posts

Top