What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Shoaib gone for 2 years, Asif for 1

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.cricketzone.com/news/interviews/20061207-1.html

Miandad slams doping flip-flop
07th Dec 2006 23.50 IST
By Agencies

Batting great, Javed Miandad, today joined a list of former players who have slammed the decision of the Pakistani authorities to exonerate fast bowlers, Shoaib Akhtar and Mohammad Asif , of doping charges.

Miandad, a veteran of 128 Tests and the country's leading Test run scorer, said the decision of the Pakistan Cricket Board appointed appellate tribunal was a big "eyewash".

"I really don't know all the details, but certainly, to me it looks odd that two tribunals headed by two former governors and eminent legal experts should have such differing views on what is a clear cut case of doping, intentionally or unintentionally," he said in Karachi.

Miandad said he did not see Pakistan cricket gaining any credibility after this doping episode.

"First of all, I really don't understand that when the PCB anti-doping regulations are still not in line with those of the World Anti-Doping Agency and the International Cricket Council why the hurry to have the out of competition tests.

"The board should have first got its anti-doping regulations in place in line with WADA rules and than started its anti-doping drive. It has only gone and embarrassed Pakistan cricket internationally," he said.

He said the entire episode appeared to be an "eyewash". "It seems as if somewhere discipline and regulations have been sacrificed. I have always said there should never be compromise on discipline no matter how big a player is. Cricket Australia also did ban Shane Warne for one year despite his stature," Miandad said.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,20867,20890243-5001505,00.html

Uniform code is needed: Healy
Malcolm Conn
December 08, 2006
IAN HEALY wants the embarrassing drug-taking fiasco in Pakistan to prompt a greater effort by all Test-playing countries to adopt a uniform drugs code.

As reaction in Pakistan and around the world continued to boil two days after fast bowlers Shoaib Akhtar and Asif Mohammad had a steroids ban overturned, Healy was also hopeful that the International Cricket Council and the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) may be able to take some action.

Choosing his words carefully, the record-breaking former Australia wicketkeeper and Australian Cricketers' Association president attempted to find something positive from the game's latest debacle.

"It would be nice for all countries, in a sport that is so heavily international, to be consistent," Healy said.

"I'm sure this will be a step forward to gaining something."

So far it has been a disaster for cricket, with WADA immediately signalling it would step in and investigate the situation after a Pakistan Cricket Board appeals panel dismissed a two-year suspension against Shoaib and one-year ban against Asif.

Because Pakistan is not a signatory to WADA and the doping Tests were done by the PCB, not the ICC, it is doubtful whether either WADA or the ICC will be able to act against Pakistan or the two players.

"It will be really interesting to see if WADA puts any pressure on the ICC and that gets anywhere," Healy said.

He was loath to criticise the decision without more information but was incredulous that players could be found with steroids in their system from supplements and not know about it.

"You just don't know the standard of their medical advice over there," Healy said.

"It's hard to imagine it happening but in Pakistan I don't

know what their set-up is like.

"If any supplement is really good it's got to have something in it."

The latest Pakistan judgment continued a terrible month or so for the ICC, which has disgraced itself by sacking umpire Darrell Hair and agreeing to re-admit corrupt and incompetent Zimbabwe back into Test cricket next year.

ICC president Percy Sonn certainly appears unwilling or unable to take Pakistan on over allowing the banned bowlers to return to the game without punishment.

Instead he issued a weak plea overnight, as if politely requesting that something be done.

"The judgment highlights inconsistencies in the Pakistan Cricket Board's (PCB) anti-doping processes and regulations," Sonn said.

"Cricket has taken significant strides forward in addressing the important issue of drug use in our sport. However, this judgment emphasises that much more work needs to be done to educate players and to synchronise our members' efforts to attain a totally drug-free sport."

In other words, can everyone co-operate please?

Pakistan has already made its answer perfectly clear.

Newspapers across Pakistan slammed the decision to lift the bans on the bowlers, with one newspaper citing a "fig leaf of exceptional circumstances".

"Regardless of a split decision among the three-member review panel that heard their appeals, both Shoaib and Asif have in fact been proved to have taken a banned substance. No review panel in the world can change that fact," an editorial in The Post said.

"A nation's pride is much more valuable than the pride of any individual. If by some miracle, Pakistan can win the World Cup utilising two druggies, will it add to the pride of our nation?" it wondered.
 

bayrep

Juniors
Messages
2,112
It shows you where the money is in the game and they have the clout to do what they like and get away with it. Can you imagine a NZ trying the same thing and getting away with.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
152,899
waltzing Meninga said:
All countries should boycott tours of Pakistan if these 2 are playing

I agree, something needs to be done and this would be a good start
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.tsn.ca/olympics/news_story/?ID=187641&hubname=olympics

Pound calls decision 'aberrational'

The Canadian Press

12/8/2006 12:30:34 PM

"It is certainly aberrational to have a national federation telling the international federation what rules it is going to apply in something like doping," Montreal-based WADA chairman Dick Pound said in an interview Friday with The Associated Press.

"This is typical of the reason why you need WADA. You have different rules applied in different cases."

A three-member appeals panel in Pakistan on Tuesday overturned doping bans on fast bowlers Shoaib Akhtar and Mohammed Asif.

A PCB tribunal on Nov. 1 had banned Akhtar for two years, and Asif for one, after they tested positive for the banned steroid nandrolone.

Pakistan Cricket Board chairman Nasim Ashraf claimed that WADA and the Dubai-based International Cricket Council cannot overturn the panel's decision.



Pound said it was too early to say whether WADA would take the case to the Switzerland-based Court of Arbitration for Sport and that it was discussing the matter with the ICC.

The appeals panel set aside the punishments because it said Akhtar and Asif had not been warned about dietary supplements blamed for their positive tests.

Pound has said that international athletes must be aware of the risks involved and a lack of knowledge was no excuse.

ICC president Percy Sonn said Wednesday that the panel's decision highlighted "inconsistencies" in Pakistan cricket's anti-doping processes.

Sonn said all ICC member countries should align their anti-doping policies with WADA and ICC codes.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
it gets worse

http://www.dailyindia.com/show/91234.php/Proof-that-PCB-doctored-Akhtar-Asif-dope-judgement-surfaces

Proof that PCB doctored Akhtar, Asif dope judgement surfaces

Lahore, Dec 9 (ANI): PCB Chairman Dr Nasim Ashraf tried his best to influence both judgements, that of the Anti-Doping Commission and the PCB's Appeals Committee, in the doping case involving fast bowlers Shoaib Akhtar and Mohammad Asif.




While he was unsuccessful in the first case, he reportedly succeeded in the latter, and got the duo freed of the doping charge.

This has been revealed in a letter signed by none other than Ashraf and addressed to the PCB's Anti-Doping Commission, headed by Barrister Shahid Hamid, with Intikhab Alam and Dr Waqar Ahmed as members. The Commission had held the two fast bowlers guilty, but the Appeals Committee lifted the bans imposed on them.

According to The Nation, Shahid Hamid confirmed that he had received the letter. It was also revealed that the PCB chairman had been directly involved in trying to subvert the due process and in swaying the judgement of first the Anti-Doping Commission without success, but finally getting his way with the Appeals Committee, added the paper.

This intervention from the highest level at the PCB allowed the spearheads of Pakistan's pace attack Akhtar and Asif to walk after the original judgement of two and one year bans was overturned, and the duo was exonerated on appeal in a split judgement - probably on 'patriotic' grounds on December 5, the paper said further.

Shahid Hamid maintains that the pressure brought to bear on him was resisted with great determination, and his Commission had arrived at its verdict in a manner most forthright. "I am positive that we made a correct appreciation of the fact and correct application of the law", the paper quoted him as saying.

Shahid Hamid admitted that he was so incensed at receiving the missive from the PCB chairman that he called Moeen Afzal, a retired federal secretary of some standing and a member of the PCB's Advisory Council, and let rip. Recounting his exact words, Shahid Hamid said that he told Afzal that the contents of the letter were "insulting, out of order and tantamount to influencing the judgement of the Commission".

Through Moeen Afzal, Shahid Hamid reportedly passed on the message to the PCB chairman "not to send any further communication till after the Commission had reached its verdict".

Shahid Hamid also told Moeen Afzal that in the circumstances he would not be talking to the PCB's imported counsel Mr Mark Gay, as Dr Nasim Ashraf wanted him to, because "we did not need his input about reaching our verdict". (ANI)
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
152,899
the Paki administration should be held accountable for this, and perhaps they should be dismissed

something very rotten in Pakistan
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
153,316
got to agree with you Twiz, this is absolute bullsh*t and it looks like they will get away with. grow some spine ICC.
 

Angry_eel

First Grade
Messages
8,644
ICC can't be bothered making a controversy before the world cup. they are scared of loss of revenue and sponsors.

i agree something needs to be done but the question is who will do it. No individual country has said anything yet, no cricket board had called for an action as far as im aware.
 

Latest posts

Top