What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Snaring JT would add fire to Eels

FUIFUI_MOIMOI

Juniors
Messages
2,448
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...add-fire-to-eels/story-e6frexnr-1225783069498

Snaring JT would add fire to Eels

* By Michael Hagan
* From: The Daily Telegraph
* Tue Oct 06 00:00:00 EST 2009 Tue Oct 06 00:00:00 EST 2009

PARRAMATTA should have in their sights the world's greatest halfback, Johnathan Thurston, if they are to complete their transformation and become the NRL's dominant club.

Thurston will be on the market at the end of the 2010 season. If the Eels can sign the Cowboys, Queensland Origin and Kangaroos superstar they will have found the last piece in the puzzle on their way to being a premiership powerhouse.

They have the nucleus of a very good team, a Dally M winner in Jarryd Hayne, a tireless workhorse in Nathan Hindmarsh and a powerful front-rower in Fuifui Moimoi.

The emergence of Daniel Mortimer in the halves with Jeff Robson has been one of the talking points of the season. Robson, who has done a great job, may not be retained at the club because of salary cap pressure, which would place an expectation on Mortimer to play No. 7 at this famous club next season.

He has shown the necessary skills, toughness and temperament this year to suggest he could be the player the Eels can use to build their team around and is an Origin player of the future as they strive for a premiership.

But how long will it take for him to develop into a player capable of leading a team to victory on Grand Final day? The other problem: He may be best suited at No. 6.

Assuming he needs to play at least 100 games to learn his craft, do the Eels need to recruit a big-name player to ensure they have the quality in the key positions (like Melbourne) to win a title? They may have little room to move under the cap next year but if I were Daniel Anderson I'd go all-out to sign Thurston, who has expressed an interest in testing his value on the open market for 2011. I'm a big fan of Matt Keating and Kris Keating, who will both develop into long-time first- grade players at the Eels but the addition of a player like Thurston would give them the experience and direction to make it all count. You need a great halfback to win a title.

It can take a long time to recover from the pain of losing a Grand Final but the Storm have shown what can be achieved after one of the game's biggest defeats by Manly last season.

They have also given other teams a blueprint for success. In the era of salary-cap pressures, Melbourne invested in the key positions of fullback, halfback, hooker and five-eighth. Then there was the great mid-season recruitment of Brett Finch at bargain-basement level.

They have also invested heavily in coaching, performance and injury management - so their best players can cope better with the demands NRL and rep football place upon you.

The Eels appear to have recruited well with the arrival of former Eel and Wallaby Timana Tahu, Roosters back-rower Shane Shackleton and Dragons front-rower Justin Poore.

Their strength and conditioning program is second to none and their defensive capability improved dramatically in the last 10 weeks of the season. But the formula for winning a premiership says you must be in the top four. Starting slowly hurt them and they need to get out of the blocks more quickly to be a chance of getting there again next year.

the formula to winning the competition says you must be in the top four and the Eels have featured in the bottom half of the top eight in three of the last four seasons.

Their tradition of starting the year slowly has hurt them and they need to adopt a different strategy to get out of the blocks quickly to give themselves a genuine chance of being there again next season.

are no guarantees in this great game of ours and there will be 15 other teams, including Melbourne, who will be desperate to be there on Grand Final day next season.
 

distortedchaos

Juniors
Messages
73
Obviously can't see this happening - but I can't see him going back to the dogs either, one way or another though he won't be at the cowboys past next year. Would hate to see him go to super league.
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
68,623
hope thurston goes back to the dogs in 2010 when kimmorley retires

Kris Keating, Robson, Mortimer and Mateo are our halves for the next 10 years. fullstop
 

distortedchaos

Juniors
Messages
73
Personally I'm hoping ben barba is ready for a full first grade season by the time noddy retires. He could be absolutely amazing if he lives up to his potential.
 

scottyeel

Bench
Messages
4,297
Supercoach said:
Assuming he needs to play at least 100 games to learn his craft, do the Eels need to recruit a big-name player to ensure they have the quality in the key positions (like Melbourne) to win a title? They may have little room to move under the cap next year but if I were Daniel Anderson I'd go all-out to sign Thurston, who has expressed an interest in testing his value on the open market for 2011. I'm a big fan of Matt Keating and Kris Keating, who will both develop into long-time first- grade players at the Eels but the addition of a player like Thurston would give them the experience and direction to make it all count. You need a great halfback to win a title.
So you need a great halfback to win a title, yet this knob left our hopes with Finch and Robson who had only played 6 games.
 

Pazza

First Grade
Messages
9,797
thurston hasnt won a comp at halfback and he wants 700k, a waste of our cap tbh!
 

scottyeel

Bench
Messages
4,297
Since he came to 1st grade 5 of the last 6 premiers have done it without him in the team. He is not needed here to win one. No thanks.
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,228
To play devil's advocate: consider what he would have brought to the table on our last tackle options on Sunday...Perhaps he would have set up a repeat set or a try and the result may have been different...

Food for thought.

I can see why you'd like him to stay away (off-field issues, mainly). But I can definitely see the merit, on the field, of having him here.
 

charlie

Juniors
Messages
146
Personally I'm hoping ben barba is ready for a full first grade season by the time noddy retires. He could be absolutely amazing if he lives up to his potential.
Barba loves to run the ball hates to tackle. Only player I've ever seen side step while defending.
 

Eels Dude

Coach
Messages
19,065
While we're at it why don't we sign Watmough, O'Donnell, Farah, and Civo. We'd win a comp for sure.
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
78,987
i think our kicking game was a big part of where we went wrong on sunday .... our kicking has gone ok in the back end of the season, but when we got put under the pump by a good team (melbourne) it was found wanting

its something we really need to address - hopefully mortimer can progress alot in that department .... sure thurston would do wonders there, but he'd decimate our team with his massive asking price and he ain't getting any younger - that and the fact he's a total prick
 
Messages
3,609
I know there is a lot of sentiment surrounding Sunday, however, I dont have a problem with letting Robson go.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,502
i think our kicking game was a big part of where we went wrong on sunday .... our kicking has gone ok in the back end of the season, but when we got put under the pump by a good team (melbourne) it was found wanting

its something we really need to address - hopefully mortimer can progress alot in that department .... sure thurston would do wonders there, but he'd decimate our team with his massive asking price and he ain't getting any younger - that and the fact he's a total prick

I agree our kicking was found out and its exactly why I dont rate Robson, his kicking game seems to regularly find the fullback where as Morts normally finds the turf. Morts kicking game was off on Sunday but I wouldn't be too harsh on him because his kicking game has been very good over the last 2 months

I'm not disputing the fact that Robbo is at the top of his game atm, but we will never win a grand final with Robson at 7 imo

KK has so much more to offer in attack than Robson,
 

Latest posts

Top