What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Squad succession

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,961
Starts with B ends with D
The same bloke who gave Moretti his debut, along with dozens of other NRL players. Arthur also wasn't the one who debuted Murchie or Momoisea. They had already been picked in the NRL by other coaches. Merkins acting like we're the only club that gave opportunities to nuffies. Eels legends Luke Kelly and Isaac Lumelume both got their debuts under Bellamy.
 

Pazza

First Grade
Messages
9,884
To assume mismanagement with the parramattas eels is hardly moronic, it's completely rational.

You love stats and figures, the parramatta eels haven't won a comp since 1986.....

To assume they aren't mismanaged just doesn't line up with the facts.
 
Last edited:

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,961
To assume mismanagement with the parramattas eels is hardly moronic, it's completely rational.

You love stats and figures, the parramatta eels haven't won a comp since 1986.....

To assume they aren't mismanaged just doesn't line up with the facts.
The current management have only been there since 2019. Only three clubs have won the comp since then. But more importantly, how many clubs have gone broke? None of them.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,128
He runs pretty quick.

Whilst I'm a fan of Ethyn, I think he came back to league too late and he's very injury prone. If he sticks to it there's no reason why he can't make it but he'll have to decide whether it's worth it to work a job whilst also chasing that first grade dream

I hope he does. He would be an excitement machine.
Unfortunately his defense and catching high ball needs a lot of work. Fixes that and stays injury free and he will play NRL.
 

Lemon Squash

First Grade
Messages
8,256
I hate to shitcan Ethyn Martin, but he is well behind his peers for the level of his development. As an example, he is the same age as Sean Russell. Hopefully he turns out to be a late bloomer. But it’s quite rare for outside backs to debut this late and still become first graders. Rich Penisini’s trajectory is what a future first grader looks like, even with the knee injury.

Take his age out of it…EM didn’t have a traditional path to the NRL or Rugby League in general.

He floated between the two games his whole life between three countries and was impacted heavily during Covid period.

I like Richie as well and yes he is younger but the one half year playing Flegg together EM had him covered.

You just have to believe what you see with EM, he is still raw but the kid moves and finishes better than anyone we have in the club.

If he didn’t do his hammy I think he would have debuted last year anyways. He was going better than Mulitalo.

Samrani is 23 I believe already and will play first grade this season.

Facts and figures will tell you that he probably is up against it to make it but just don’t right him off.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,961
Take his age out of it…EM didn’t have a traditional path to the NRL or Rugby League in general.

He floated between the two games his whole life between three countries and was impacted heavily during Covid period.

I like Richie as well and yes he is younger but the one half year playing Flegg together EM had him covered.

You just have to believe what you see with EM, he is still raw but the kid moves and finishes better than anyone we have in the club.

If he didn’t do his hammy I think he would have debuted last year anyways. He was going better than Mulitalo.

Samrani is 23 I believe already and will play first grade this season.

Facts and figures will tell you that he probably is up against it to make it but just don’t right him off.
The reason their age matters is because the majority of their physical development occurs early in their career. Dudes need to be in a high performance system by their mid teens to maximise their strength and power. If they wait until they are 19 or 20, they will never catch up to where they could've been. That's why their age matters. These are generalisations, and the example cutoffs I've used are to illustrate a point. The earlier they start training like pros, the more likely they will be to reach professional performance levels. Yes genetics are also a major factor, and often the thing that prevents slower developers from getting picked in NRL pathways systems in the first place.

I wouldn't be surprised if Martin played a few NRL games in his career, but I will be surprised if he gets to 100.
 

Latest posts

Top