What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

State of origin 2025

Girds89

Bench
Messages
3,404
I didn't change anything I said he's been bad for it this year but there is no confidence in this team contesting kicks. Your Edwards love is clouding your judgement.

Haha. Well you were talking about contesting kicks and next minute your talking about general field errors like play the balls..... two completely differeng things..

Nothing to do with my love of edwards..just a fact mate.. yes hes forms been down but to try make out our team has issues with catching kicks and or makes a lot of errors from them is just not true..
 

Girds89

Bench
Messages
3,404
Pissweak middles are the real issue. A bunch of blokes watching their captain kill himself and thinking "nah I can't be f**ked"

Martin does need to lift no doubt.. i have no issues with him making no meters if he defends like he did last night every week..

Ive said for 2 years we need to change up the way we play and yeo goes back to be a running forward and nath goes back to 1st receiver and both sides..

It was cluncky last night but yeo was epic solely as a running forward.. nathan looked better as a first receiever and had more time..

Ivan needs to take a lot out of that game plan.
 

snickers007

Juniors
Messages
1,716
The problem with Edwards this season is that everytime he makes a mistake, we leak points off the back of it.

Probably not an Edwards problem per se, but when his errors are more damaging than the past it makes it seem like he's playing worse.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
16,496
Haha. Well you were talking about contesting kicks and next minute your talking about general field errors like play the balls..... two completely differeng things..

Nothing to do with my love of edwards..just a fact mate.. yes hes forms been down but to try make out our team has issues with catching kicks and or makes a lot of errors from them is just not true..

Would you concede he is lacking confidence?

When I watch him go at the high ball under pressure he almost looks hesitant to me. You are right its not an easy situation at all and I don't have a stat to say he is better, worse or the same. Just doesn't look like the Dylan Edwards we know.
 

Oldpanther86

Juniors
Messages
366
Haha. Well you were talking about contesting kicks and next minute your talking about general field errors like play the balls..... two completely differeng things..

Nothing to do with my love of edwards..just a fact mate.. yes hes forms been down but to try make out our team has issues with catching kicks and or makes a lot of errors from them is just not true..

On the beers? Took an offhand comment and turned it into a whole thing.

Would you concede he is lacking confidence?

When I watch him go at the high ball under pressure he almost looks hesitant to me. You are right its not an easy situation at all and I don't have a stat to say he is better, worse or the same. Just doesn't look like the Dylan Edwards we know.

Exactly. Instead of 11/10 brick wall dependable he's at 8/10 and seems a little uncomfortable or tired.
 

Chins

Juniors
Messages
1,552
The problem with Edwards this season is that everytime he makes a mistake, we leak points off the back of it.

Probably not an Edwards problem per se, but when his errors are more damaging than the past it makes it seem like he's playing worse.
Trying to be a focal point of our attack and be some great ballyplayer is an issue but that's more Ivan
 

Girds89

Bench
Messages
3,404
Would you concede he is lacking confidence?

When I watch him go at the high ball under pressure he almost looks hesitant to me. You are right its not an easy situation at all and I don't have a stat to say he is better, worse or the same. Just doesn't look like the Dylan Edwards we know.

Look across the whole game. The games changed and the way the nrl has come down on blockers is effecting every fb in the comp...

I dont think hes lacking confidence at all under the high ball. When does he ever drop a torpedo uncontested bomb?? Basically never..

Hes been the safest fb in the comp the last 5 years..this year at least according to z5ero tackle hes made 7 errors in 7 games.. id think at least 3 or 4 of those weren't from kicks. And we're poor mistakes in the play the ball etc...

3 dropped bombs in 7 games in the current game and the way it's reffed is very good..

If dyl is more hestitant than in the past id suggest its based on the fact he knows blockers are basically dead in the game know and hes on his own at the back.. no protection


I thought he was very very good on Wednesday.. didmt overplay his hand..finished off tries. Was everywhere in defence and did the tough stuff hes renowned for..

Is he struggling under the high ball... categorically no..has the game changed and is there allowed to be a heap more pressure on catchers... yes.. any sign of blocking now and players out smart the ref nd take a dive and we all know it gets blown as a penalty..

Its harder then ever for the back 3 atm.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
16,496
TV vision of Tom Jenkins in Origin Camp?

Best winger in the comp mate gotta have him there.

In all seriousness he is showing what he is capable of. He can play football. I was curious to see some more of him at centre but McClean looks like he is making that position his home. McClean had a knock on his ability to set up his winger but that is starting to come along too.

If Alamoti ups his form then we will actually have some competition for spots in the backline again. Not just depth.
 
Top