What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

State Of Origin

Surely

Post Whore
Messages
103,320
Played ordinary with a half that can't lead, crap defence from ado and Mitchell and only lose by 4 at Suncorp

It's not all doom and gloom
 

bluefox68

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
4,559
Isn’t he the reason we picked Cleary!!

Told Fitter last year if he is to pick him, he must stick.
That’s Gould all over - that’s a major low blow to Freddy, if he’s done what the media says he’s done...
 

azzah72

Bench
Messages
4,204
The simple reason why this game was lost.

The NSW Halves went missing and QLD had Ponga who is a ball playing fullback.

Otherwise, it's basically Even. Teddy and Cook worked their asses off but the halves let them down.
 

Weaponhead

Coach
Messages
11,037
The simple reason why this game was lost.

The NSW Halves went missing and QLD had Ponga who is a ball playing fullback.

Otherwise, it's basically Even. Teddy and Cook worked their asses off but the halves let them down.
Fair assessment.

Walker is an opportunist. His job was to have quality touches that create tryscoring opportunities. He laid on the try for Jake T but needed to do more when NSW were on the front foot.

Cleary has to run the side. He sat on the right edge and did not impose himself at all. Maloney ran the team last year while Cleary has the L plates on. Cleary didn't step up at all. He did what he always does and it's not enough. He isn't ready to run that team. Everything good comes off Cook and Teddy.

Mitchell had a shocker. Showed no trust in Walker. Showed no urgency in cover. Looks a million bucks when the game runs his way. Looks terrible when not switched on. Lacks mental toughness.

Fittler has some choices to make. I reckon he sacrifices Walker to protect Cleary. Cleary is being looked after by Dad and Freddy. This may not end well.
 
Messages
15,326
The halves.
With Keary out it should have been Reynolds and Walker, or Cleary and Maloney.
Hear me out on this one. I'm not talking of team combos, even though that does help.
If Freddy was serious about form players, it's automatically Reynolds/Walker. If he was showing loyalty to Cleary, why not Maloney as well? Yes they have not been good but they did help the side win last year.
The mixture of these two combos, Walker and Cleary was wrong, main reason being, neither of them have won a Premiership. Both Maloney and Reynolds have, also both the Queensland halves, Munster and DCE, have won Premierships.
Maloney and/or Reynolds needed to be there.
Luke Keary was the real missing ingredient. Awesome player with two Premierships to his name.
 

fizman

Bench
Messages
3,507
Queensland - Champion Team
New South Wales - Team of Champions.

What we saw last night in no way, shape or form represented State of Origin. They need to change the name to "State of First Football" because that was nothing more than a fast paced NRL game at best.

State of Origin was built on genuine hatred and has been turned into this family friendly light entertainment TV product.
 
Messages
2,966
Played ordinary with a half that can't lead, crap defence from ado and Mitchell and only lose by 4 at Suncorp

It's not all doom and gloom
I think the problem defensively was walker, personally. I'd say Keary takes a lot of the thinking out of d for Mitchell and Walker is a bit on the quiet side.
 

Windy70

Juniors
Messages
2,276
first time in a long time I didn't watch it. Big day, and big hours at work was in Bed watchin telly at 7.00. Nodded off and my wife woke me up and said Origins on. I said, I'll watch it tomorrow, tired.
 

SadShark

Bench
Messages
4,049
So, you Derty little Shark rooters, does Wado come back into consideraysh for SOO too or fwee?
 

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,816
So, you Derty little Shark rooters, does Wado come back into consideraysh for SOO too or fwee?
Doubt it, Cordner has his spot, they ain't dropping him.

Hopefully Josh M can retire again with Turbo back, head held high.
 
Top