What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Sustaining&building upon current NRL boom

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,546
Honest question here but why is that?

are AFL tickets cheaper and packaged more family friendly?
Few reasons:
- they have a long tradition of membership culture. That has helped massively drive crowds. Nrl has only really started getting serious about memberships when smith took over in 2012,
- they have traditionally had bigger and better stadiums
- they haven’t sacrificed family friendly ko times for sake of tv, despite getting more money from tv
- They’ve based their teams in mostly big cities with Big populations
- they use a shared stadium Approach meaning better quality stadiums
- they have for years had very cheap kids tickets, adults are similar price to nrl
- Sydney people don’t like going out much lol
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
33,633
Few reasons:
- they have a long tradition of membership culture. That has helped massively drive crowds. Nrl has only really started getting serious about memberships when smith took over in 2012,
- they have traditionally had bigger and better stadiums
- they haven’t sacrificed family friendly ko times for sake of tv, despite getting more money from tv
- They’ve based their teams in mostly big cities with Big populations
- they use a shared stadium Approach meaning better quality stadiums
- they have for years had very cheap kids tickets, adults are similar price to nrl
- Sydney people don’t like going out much lol
Melbourne is a boring city with nothing to do and travelling is easy vs Sydney

lions and swans had super league
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,546
Melbourne is a boring city with nothing to do and travelling is easy vs Sydney

lions and swans had super league
How does that explain crowds in perth,adelaide, brisbane and Sydney for afl? The old city is boring nonsense is nearly as poor a reason as nrl is better on tv lol
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
33,633
How does that explain crowds in perth,adelaide, brisbane and Sydney for afl? The old city is boring nonsense is nearly as poor a reason as nrl is better on tv lol
Adelaide is even more boring than Melboring obviously

I responded above about the swans and lions super league

as the giants have shown

with no legs up they are lucky to get 5k paying fans in Sydney
 

taipan

Referee
Messages
22,500
Melbourne is a boring city with nothing to do and travelling is easy vs Sydney

lions and swans had super league
Spot on ,the impact of Superleague on the code's finances, fanbase was immeasurable and at the same time(even the Swans have admitted such ,the war was a boost in entrenching their team in Sydney.The non News media Herald /channel 2/7 promoted AFL like their lives depended on it.
I doubt on a weekend in Melbourne you'd see youth spending hours on autumn and winter weekends surfing as they do in Sydney.Nor have all the media in Sydney worship AFL like they do in Victoria.
That being said we are closing the gap ratings wise, expansion wise, crowdwise will always be a difficult task.
Transport is a no brainer .Melbourne was planned Sydney was haphazardly done.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
33,633
Spot on ,the impact of Superleague on the code's finances, fanbase was immeasurable and at the same time(even the Swans have admitted such ,the war was a boost in entrenching their team in Sydney.The non News media Herald /channel 2/7 promoted AFL like their lives depended on it.
I doubt on a weekend in Melbourne you'd see youth spending hours on autumn and winter weekends surfing as they do in Sydney.Nor have all the media in Sydney worship AFL like they do in Victoria.
That being said we are closing the gap ratings wise, expansion wise, crowdwise will always be a difficult task.
Transport is a no brainer .Melbourne was planned Sydney was haphazardly done.
A big obstacle for rugby league is the media

at best indifferent at worst hostile

in terms of genuinely good journalists there are maybe one or two

growing up with a guy like Peter frilingos he would turn in his grave if he saw the drivel his former employers put out these days

ratings wise we annhiliate them
 

greenBV4

Bench
Messages
2,510
I doubt on a weekend in Melbourne you'd see youth spending hours on autumn and winter weekends surfing as they do in Sydney
Melbourne Surfer here
I very much doubt you'd have many more people than inner Melbourne in Western Sydney being avid surfers lol - as far as winter goes they came up with this nifty thing down in torquay called a wetsuit

and as a New South Welshmen I can safely say Sydney is boring as batshit in comparison..
how do you explain night games? Sydney was notorious for killing off its nightlife

The real reason is mentioned above, Sydney, and thus the NRL by extension, has a shit attendance and membership culture (probably because its near impossible to get around), you can even see this without using the other code as a comparison by just comparing NRL crowds & membership in Brisbane to Sydney
 

footyfan4life

Juniors
Messages
119
Why would they be? They are set up already for the next decade. Revenue is massive and growing significantly, they have the capital city footprint they want, a full womens comp and they will soon own marvel stadium outright. They seem to be pretty well set.

nrl has so much potential, but always has had. If it will ever realise it is the big question.
How will the AFL own marvel stadium outright?
 

docbrown

Coach
Messages
11,842
I find the Melbourne vs Sydney rivalry funny. Two big fish in a small pond arguing that they are sharks.

That said Sydney is a global city and Melbourne is not. If I recall correctly, Sydney is about a quarter of Australia's entire GDP. About the same as Victoria altogether. Add in regional NSW and it's 33%. Major international companies are more likely to be based in Sydney than Melbourne. Also Sydney is high on international brand awareness rankings, usually in the top 20 cities in the world. Melbourne rarely rates. Sydney has a world famous harbour with iconic landmarks. Melbourne has a dirty swamp river.

If I had to choose between having a coffee in a crappy lane way or an extra $100 billion to my economy, I know what I'd choose.
 

greenBV4

Bench
Messages
2,510
I find the Melbourne vs Sydney rivalry funny. Two big fish in a small pond arguing that they are sharks.

That said Sydney is a global city and Melbourne is not. If I recall correctly, Sydney is about a quarter of Australia's entire GDP. About the same as Victoria altogether. Add in regional NSW and it's 33%. Major international companies are more likely to be based in Sydney than Melbourne. Also Sydney is high on international brand awareness rankings, usually in the top 20 cities in the world. Melbourne rarely rates. Sydney has a world famous harbour with iconic landmarks. Melbourne has a dirty swamp river.

If I had to choose between having a coffee in a crappy lane way or an extra $100 billion to my economy, I know what I'd choose.
doesn't help explain why Sydney folk don't know how to find their own front door when it comes to sport
 

docbrown

Coach
Messages
11,842
doesn't help explain why Sydney folk don't know how to find their own front door when it comes to sport
You do realise that the people who attend sports events of any kind are a small minority of the population? Even in Melbourne. You could literally add up every single person who goes to a fumbleball game, NRL, rugby union, cricket, soccer, netball, basketball et al match in the city and they won't even be the majority. Most people have no interest in sports attendance in general. You're literally complaining about tiny percentages of both populations.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
33,633
I find the Melbourne vs Sydney rivalry funny. Two big fish in a small pond arguing that they are sharks.

That said Sydney is a global city and Melbourne is not. If I recall correctly, Sydney is about a quarter of Australia's entire GDP. About the same as Victoria altogether. Add in regional NSW and it's 33%. Major international companies are more likely to be based in Sydney than Melbourne. Also Sydney is high on international brand awareness rankings, usually in the top 20 cities in the world. Melbourne rarely rates. Sydney has a world famous harbour with iconic landmarks. Melbourne has a dirty swamp river.

If I had to choose between having a coffee in a crappy lane way or an extra $100 billion to my economy, I know what I'd choose.
No tourist ever visited Australia to see st kilda beach or the Yarra river that’s for sure

Melbourne is just a bland cbd built on a mundane river with really crappy weather

the worst bit is it’s full of fumblers
 

greenBV4

Bench
Messages
2,510
You do realise that the people who attend sports events of any kind are a small minority of the population? Even in Melbourne. You could literally add up every single person who goes to a fumbleball game, NRL, rugby union, cricket, soccer, netball, basketball et al match in the city and they won't even be the majority. Most people have no interest in sports attendance in general. You're literally complaining about tiny percentages of both populations.
thanks for proving my point..
the point the NRL needs to try and make (and good luck to them) is why a state government with a voting population more concerned with other things should be spending on more than the 4-5 existing stadiums? especially when you start requesting council and privately owned grounds get funding..

Melbourne has 3 major centrally located stadiums all with multiple tenants across multiple codes - a much much easier sell to voters
 

greenBV4

Bench
Messages
2,510
No tourist ever visited Australia to see st kilda beach or the Yarra river that’s for sure

Melbourne is just a bland cbd built on a mundane river with really crappy weather

the worst bit is it’s full of fumblers
lol the classic weather gag

How'd youre swannies go this week?
 
Last edited:

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,546
No tourist ever visited Australia to see st kilda beach or the Yarra river that’s for sure

Melbourne is just a bland cbd built on a mundane river with really crappy weather

the worst bit is it’s full of fumblers
Dumbest argument ever, and that’s saying something from you lol. All the major cities in Australia have exactly the same amount of things to do.
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
33,633
thanks for proving my point..
the point the NRL needs to try and make (and good luck to them) is why a state government with a voting population more concerned with other things should be spending on more than the 4-5 existing stadiums? especially when you start requesting council and privately owned grounds get funding..

Melbourne has 3 major centrally located stadiums all with multiple tenants across multiple codes - a much much easier sell to voters
Did voters even get a say when the Victorian govt spent over hundred million improving a privately owned stadium ?
Dumbest argument ever, and that’s saying something from you lol. All the major cities in Australia have exactly the same amount of things to do.
internationals tourists visit Australia for Sydney then Gold Coast and qld in general

every else is irrelevant
 

Latest posts

Top