What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Sydney relocations

juro

Bench
Messages
3,827
Manly moan so much about losing home ground advantage in the finals.

There is no "home ground" advantage. It is "home city" advantage.

So if they want the advantage, all they have to do is move to another city!
 

alien

Referee
Messages
20,279
god its not like they have to travel that far to get to the sfs. f**k moanly and their shithole of a ground. its almost as shit as leichhardt oval
 

Sparky 74

Juniors
Messages
415
all the mergers were done incorrectly or with not much love in it.

The NRL should fold like the soccer did 10 years ago & start fresh.

A 16 team true national comp

QLD x 4

Brisbane
Central QLD
North QLD
Gold Coast

SYDNEY x 3

Sydney City
Western Sydney
inner West metro Sydney

NSW regional x 3

Central Coast
South Coast/ illawarra
Newcastle

Others - 6

ACT - Canberra
Vic - Melbourne
Perth
Adelaide
New Zealand
PNG



All sydney tribal teams to play out of the NSW cup

Norths
Souths
Easts
Wests
Parra
Penrith
Cronulla
St. George
Canterbury
Newtown
Balmain
Manly
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
Keep Canberra.
Dump Bulldogs, Parra, Penrith, Souths, St George (but retain Illawarra)
Create Gosford, PNG and Adelaide.

You haven't given this very much thought, have you?
 
Last edited:

mongoose

Coach
Messages
11,856
all the mergers were done incorrectly or with not much love in it.

The NRL should fold like the soccer did 10 years ago & start fresh.

A 16 team true national comp

QLD x 4

Brisbane
Central QLD
North QLD
Gold Coast

SYDNEY x 3

Sydney City
Western Sydney
inner West metro Sydney

NSW regional x 3

Central Coast
South Coast/ illawarra
Newcastle

Others - 6

ACT - Canberra
Vic - Melbourne
Perth
Adelaide
New Zealand
PNG



All sydney tribal teams to play out of the NSW cup

Norths
Souths
Easts
Wests
Parra
Penrith
Cronulla
St. George
Canterbury
Newtown
Balmain
Manly

what a dumb idea, seriously. Do you think anyone would care about these new franchises? Do you think the legions of Souths, Dragons, Broncos fans will just jump on board the new team?
 

alien

Referee
Messages
20,279
people have already gone through enough bullshit. piss them off anymore and they'll just tell the game to go f**k themselves, if they havent already
 

goodplayer

Juniors
Messages
2,078
all the mergers were done incorrectly or with not much love in it.

The NRL should fold like the soccer did 10 years ago & start fresh.

A 16 team true national comp

QLD x 4

Brisbane
Central QLD
North QLD
Gold Coast

need 2 or 3 brisbane teams please . wake up :sarcasm:
 

alien

Referee
Messages
20,279
2 brisbane teams is enough, plus maybe a sunshine coast club eventually. sunshine coast has a population of 270,000 already
 

docbrown

Coach
Messages
11,842
20 Team Comp
No relocations
1 merger

North Queensland Cowboys (with some matches in Cairns)
South Queensland Brothers (with some matches in Rockhampton)
Brisbane Broncos
Gold Coast Titans (with some matches in PNG)
Newcastle Knights
Central Coast Bears
New Zealand Warriors (with some away matches across North Island)
New Zealand 2 (with matches in Wellington & Christchurch)
West Coast Pirates
Adelaide Rams
Melbourne Storm (with some away matches in Tasmania)
Canberra Raiders
St George Illawarra Dragons (primarily in Wollongong)
South Sydney Rabbitohs (with some matches in NZ)
North Sydney Sea Eagles
Eastern Sydney Sharks (merge Roosters & Sharks)
Western Sydney Tigers (with some matches elsewhere)
Parramatta Eels (with some matches in Darwin)
Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs (with some matches elsewhere)
Penrith Panthers

Which could lead to 4 or 5 divisions like Western Sydney, Eastern Sydney, Interstate, Queensland etc
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
71,258
18 team comp, drop the deadweight to NSW cup

Perth (1 game a year South Africa)
Adelaide (1 game a year PNG)
Wellington (1 game a year Dunedin)
Auckland (1 game year Christchurch)
Storm (1 game a year Tassie)

Broncos
Brisbane2 (1 game a year CQ)
Titans
Cowboys

Souths
Bulldogs
Tigers (2 games a year Adelaide)
Eels (2 games a year NT)
Roosters (if they can get crowds back up to last years)
St's (50-50 split games Gong and Sydney)
Northern Sea Eagles (50-50 split games CC and Manly/Sydney)

Knights
Raiders

Tough love but necesary to grow game.
 

pHyR3

Juniors
Messages
955
18 team comp, drop the deadweight to NSW cup

Perth (1 game a year South Africa)
Adelaide (1 game a year PNG)
Wellington (1 game a year Dunedin)
Auckland (1 game year Christchurch)
Storm (1 game a year Tassie)

Broncos
Brisbane2 (1 game a year CQ)
Titans
Cowboys

Souths
Bulldogs
Tigers (2 games a year Adelaide)
Eels (2 games a year NT)
Roosters (if they can get crowds back up to last years)
St's (50-50 split games Gong and Sydney)
Northern Sea Eagles (50-50 split games CC and Manly/Sydney)

Knights
Raiders

Tough love but necesary to grow game.

why are the tigers playing 2 games in adelaide when adelaide has a team in your proposal?

cutting teams isnt the answer. 9 teams is what the AFL has in melbourne with a smaller population, so it is sustainable. If manly can expand to north shore and central coast then sydney isn't looking too bad.
 

Diesel

Referee
Messages
23,970
20 Team Comp


Eastern Sydney Sharks (merge Roosters & Sharks)

The Bondi Sharks return! Wasn't there a story going on 2-3 years ago about this being a possibility? Surely must've been before the development got the nod.

Roosters IMO are a wasted spot in any future footprint, they're a successful club on/off the field, have bucketloads of tradition, have a sugar daddy millionaire, just won a premiership but struggle to get crowds
 

rooster25

Juniors
Messages
120
The Bondi Sharks return! Wasn't there a story going on 2-3 years ago about this being a possibility? Surely must've been before the development got the nod.

Roosters IMO are a wasted spot in any future footprint, they're a successful club on/off the field, have bucketloads of tradition, have a sugar daddy millionaire, just won a premiership but struggle to get crowds

Here we go again.. Easts averaged 20 000 last year, a figure most sydney clubs could only dream of. Yes this year they went down however with only 1 day home game fans were sick of going to night games in the pouring rain with the terrible weather sydney had this winter. Not the clubs fault they don't have a small stadium like parra,Sharks and Manly and penrith which make crowds look better on TV.

Like it or not the Roosters are a strong foundation club that are very important to the game, esp being up against other codes more than any other club, and are here too stay.
 

Diesel

Referee
Messages
23,970
Couldn't your clubs good mate Gyngall give them more Sunday games or does he think Thursday night does Sydney Roosters the best?
 
Last edited:

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
71,258
why are the tigers playing 2 games in adelaide when adelaide has a team in your proposal?

cutting teams isnt the answer. 9 teams is what the AFL has in melbourne with a smaller population, so it is sustainable. If manly can expand to north shore and central coast then sydney isn't looking too bad.

Despite afl being moreopular in melbourne 9 afl teams in melbourne is not sustainable, they are artificially kep alive by taxing the other clubs.
 

docbrown

Coach
Messages
11,842
The Bondi Sharks return! Wasn't there a story going on 2-3 years ago about this being a possibility? Surely must've been before the development got the nod.

Roosters IMO are a wasted spot in any future footprint, they're a successful club on/off the field, have bucketloads of tradition, have a sugar daddy millionaire, just won a premiership but struggle to get crowds

They need to expand their fanbase and market reach else risk being cut off in their little enclave.

They're not the worst supported club in Sydney (they're arguably more supported than the Sea Eagles, Sharks & Panthers) but they risk being left behind by the Big 5.

Here we go again.. Easts averaged 20 000 last year, a figure most sydney clubs could only dream of. Yes this year they went down however with only 1 day home game fans were sick of going to night games in the pouring rain with the terrible weather sydney had this winter. Not the clubs fault they don't have a small stadium like parra,Sharks and Manly and penrith which make crowds look better on TV.

Like it or not the Roosters are a strong foundation club that are very important to the game, esp being up against other codes more than any other club, and are here too stay.

And yet the year before that they averaged only 12,482.

But again you look at long term trends their average since the NRL began is 14,270 which is 6th out of the 9 Sydney clubs which is exactly where I've said they'd be ranked in terms of support. That overall though equates to the bottom third of the league.

Nobody's arguing the foundation club stuff but for a century old club that's always been in the competition they should be doing a lot better than that. I'd hate to see them axed or relocated, that would be death knell for their fan base (if they're not interested now, they won't be interested if they're playing out of Adelaide...).

It may be prudent then that if an option needed to be taken that a merger is better than the other alternatives.

At least the club would still be based in Sydney with games at the SFS. If they kept even half the fanbase they would obviously still be ranked 6th in Sydney. But as the Tigers & Dragons show (ranked 2nd & 4th) they'll keep more than that and probably end up ranked in the Top 4.

Ideally though the Tigers would shift out of South-West over time and the Roosters would start to spread out into the Inner-West. At the same time Manly --> North Sydney & Panthers --> North West.
 
Top