What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Synthetic turf

1 Eyed TEZZA

Coach
Messages
12,420
IF it's good enough for the NFL arena, it's good enough the NRL.

In a revolutionary move, Brookvale Oval could become the first top flight rugby league ground in the world to be laid with synthetic turf.

Warringah Council Mayor, Michael Regan, told The Daily Telegraph yesterday that he wanted to fast-track a $1 million artificial playing surface at Manly's home ground.

Regan has already held preliminary talks with NRL chairman John Grant, Manly Sea Eagles chairman Scott Penn and NSWRL development officials about the historic move.

"It makes sense," Mayor Regan said.

The council pay $150,000 a year to maintain Brookvale's playing surface - for just 15 hours a week of use.

Anymore, he says, would trash the playing surface.

A synthetic surface would cost just $20,000 annually to maintain and allow up to 60 hours a week of use.

"At the moment Brookvale can only be used 15 hours a week to keep it to NRL standards - that's crazy," Regan said. "I think the people in charge need to embrace the change - if the technology is there, let's use it.

"With the state government looking at the Melbourne Stadia strategy, grounds like Brookvale are under threat.

"If synthetic means we can have the best possible surface available for 60 hours a week, Brookie becomes a sustainable financial model for the local council. You could play junior and senior games there, as well as school matches."

About fifty percent of NFL arenas have artificial surfaces with Regan dismissing fears the playing surface would injure or graze players.

"It would be the latest technology so that would be eliminated," he said. "In fact, some might argue that playing on grass would be worse.

"It would be purely psychological for the players.

"It would be unbelievable and we have got the money to do it at Brookvale.



"It also would give us a reason to continue to invest into Brookvale Oval. Over time it would pay itself off and be used commercially and for the community."

NRL director of football operations, Nathan McGuirk, said the game's governing body would have to be convinced about introducing an artificial surface.

"Synthetic ovals have benefits for junior sport but at elite level with the elite players, we would have some reservations at this stage about approving any change," he said.

Brookvale was again boggy last Sunday with fullback Brett Stewart straining a hamstring in the heavy conditions.

Former Australian captain Laurie Daley said: "It is certainly an interesting concept. It hasn't happened in rugby league before. Player welfare is the most important issue. I'd have to look into it more."

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...plans-to-the-nrl/story-e6frexri-1226422910889
 

1 Eyed TEZZA

Coach
Messages
12,420
Im not against the idea. Id like to see the difference the surface would make to the ball. Would it bounce more? less? etc.
 

miguel de cervantes

First Grade
Messages
7,473
It's just not football without mud and dirt on the ball and jerseys. I gather it is some sort of drainage or sunlight problem that is causing problems, fix that instead.
 

1 Eyed TEZZA

Coach
Messages
12,420
Issues I can see arising is pools of water forming because of the lack of dirt, the surface impact on players and the balls bounce too it.

A quick google search shows that the IRB has approved a certain type of the turf.
 

Deacon

First Grade
Messages
6,879
Becoming a real issue this, many junior sports are being constantly cancelled because of the poor condition and overuse of fields. This will definitely happen to the majority of sporting fields down the track at a professional and amateur level, providing the money is available
 
Messages
2,399
Widnes are the only club who have it, it's been an advantage to them certainly.

I was hoping it would be good, but I don't like it, Jarrod Sammutt blamed it for his injury this year, there is evidence apparently that it puts extra pressure on the joints.

IMO stick to grass, and build more fields, so they get used less. It's ok for Gridiron with all that padding!!!!!!!! Obviously!!!! For crying out loud!!!! And light players don't move around and step as much in the NFL as they do in the NRL and SL.
 
Last edited:
Messages
2,364
I've only seen one Widnes game this year, early in the season, I remember a lot of nasty looking scrapes to knees and elbows, and some commotion about it after the game.

I'm assuming players have gotten over that?
 

mikdalton

Juniors
Messages
90
I've only seen one Widnes game this year, early in the season, I remember a lot of nasty looking scrapes to knees and elbows, and some commotion about it after the game.

I'm assuming players have gotten over that?

There are still some complaints but that game has proven to be a one-off.

Basically, the game was played at -8 or something and the little rubber balls froze meaning that it caused more scrapes than usual. However, games played the day after showed that there were worse injuries on frozen grass pitches!
 

Quidgybo

Bench
Messages
3,054
Surely if we were to go down the synthetic turf path, the prime candidates would be the high traffic multi use stadiums with a history of surface issues. SFS, ANZ Stadium, Suncorp and Etihad. All these grounds have suffered chronic issues maintaining their surface and despite the fixes it still seems to raise its head at least once or twice a year at each of them. The suburban grounds should be the last places that need to move away from grass.

Leigh.
 
Last edited:

IowaRL

Juniors
Messages
419
Well, according to Wiki, the biggest issues are extra scrapes. Not saying it is the be all and end all, but it is an interesting idea.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthetic_turf

If the council are worried about linemarking (which can't be done on Synthetic Turf), perhaps going down the path of fibre optics, with the lines being able to be activated with the flick of a switch
 

DC_fan

Coach
Messages
11,980
Grass is a much better surface to be tackled on then synthetic turf.

If they go the way of synthetic turf then we could see players wearing long playing pants and long sleeved jumpers.
 

Latest posts

Top