macavity
Referee
- Messages
- 20,610
Mullo isn't fit
not too sure Newto is either.
I think Quinny should be back.
Carmont is needed in PL - he has reverted back to his turnstyle ways and is carrying some sort of injury - well I hope that is the excuse for his form anyways.
whatever team is named, if we dont improve a million % we are going to get lapped again.
we need a real fullback for one - and if Hinton is what we have, then he is our man. We also need a 5/8 who is not a forward - a slow limited passing game player does not belong in the backline. ever. some sort of kicking game would help too.
Lowrie has been decent this year, but a 5/8 he certainly isn't. If we insist on playing Kurt at FB (worst idea in a long time, but hey...) then Tighe has to be in 6. He is quick, can pass, and can kick. If Tighe isn't in the 6 he should be in the centres. but hey, we know its not going to happen.
for mine,
1. Nathan Hinton
2. Brian Carney
3. Matt Gidley
4. Brad Tighe
5. Anthony Quinn
6. Kurt Gidley
7. Andrew Johns
8. Josh Perry
9. Danny Buderus
10. Craig Smith
11. Steve Simpson
12. Todd Lowrie
13. Kirk Reynoldson
14. Adam Woolnough
15. Daniel Tolar
16. Riley Brown
17. Luke Davico
assuming Quinn is fit and Newton / Mullen aren't. If they are they take the spots of Lowrie (to bench for Brown) and Kidley (to centre for Tighe) but it isn't going to happen. Mullo/Lowrie will be on the bench for Tolar, and Tanner will start at lock, lets not kid ourselves.
our team looks alot better with Simmo there. Newton would help too. but im bloody worried about this game, we look shocking atm.
not too sure Newto is either.
I think Quinny should be back.
Carmont is needed in PL - he has reverted back to his turnstyle ways and is carrying some sort of injury - well I hope that is the excuse for his form anyways.
whatever team is named, if we dont improve a million % we are going to get lapped again.
we need a real fullback for one - and if Hinton is what we have, then he is our man. We also need a 5/8 who is not a forward - a slow limited passing game player does not belong in the backline. ever. some sort of kicking game would help too.
Lowrie has been decent this year, but a 5/8 he certainly isn't. If we insist on playing Kurt at FB (worst idea in a long time, but hey...) then Tighe has to be in 6. He is quick, can pass, and can kick. If Tighe isn't in the 6 he should be in the centres. but hey, we know its not going to happen.
for mine,
1. Nathan Hinton
2. Brian Carney
3. Matt Gidley
4. Brad Tighe
5. Anthony Quinn
6. Kurt Gidley
7. Andrew Johns
8. Josh Perry
9. Danny Buderus
10. Craig Smith
11. Steve Simpson
12. Todd Lowrie
13. Kirk Reynoldson
14. Adam Woolnough
15. Daniel Tolar
16. Riley Brown
17. Luke Davico
assuming Quinn is fit and Newton / Mullen aren't. If they are they take the spots of Lowrie (to bench for Brown) and Kidley (to centre for Tighe) but it isn't going to happen. Mullo/Lowrie will be on the bench for Tolar, and Tanner will start at lock, lets not kid ourselves.
our team looks alot better with Simmo there. Newton would help too. but im bloody worried about this game, we look shocking atm.