Team list Tuesday vs Tits - Magic Round - Sunday 6:25pm

[yy_cheng]

To be honest, I was a Dunster fan in the juniors and was thrilled to see him show his potential in late 2021.

I was also happy to see him return this year - but when your centre turns to look for you on a line break and you are not within a bulls roar and are instead appearing to lope but obviously trying (twice), then we had to have hoped he'd been taken out (which he hadn't).

I suggest you watch the replay, because it was a pretty obvious and basic failure. Sometimes a stat line doesn't tell the true picture.

You do realise that some decisions are wrong? You don't have to blindly defend absolutely everything.

Yeah. when dunster first came into NRL, i didnt like what i saw. I called him duster. he was getting so dominated.

Then one year, i think just before the run to the finals, he ran hard and started being safe under the ball and I was impressed.

But today, he is not ready to be back in NRL. He needs to work on his acceleration and speed again. He is not tommy t who can play at 65%.

Those 2 times when Peni was looking for him were tries. Against a better team, these are what would cost us the game possibly

 

[IFR33K]

Let’s hope dropping Carty to the bench doesn’t affect his game. He’s been excellent imo this year, I hope he doesn’t come on and think he needs a trick play or an offload and mistakes creep into his game.

 

[TheCrowe]

Not yet. Look at this article from last year.

NRL clubs can now select players outside of the Top 30. Here’s who is on your team’s radar

NRL clubs can now select players outside of Top 30. Here’s who is on EVERY team’s radar

www.foxsports.com.au

Crap Journo. 2mins research could have told him that Rodwell is already top 30. 2 mins more and he could have figured out he is way down the pecking order.

 

[Gronk]

You don't have to blindly defend absolutely everything.

No mate, Im not blindly defending. My opinion is that Russell's errors at centre were unacceptable and we cannot afford a repeat. If I have a different opinion than you, don't take offence to it, don't be shocked and humiliated. How about hardening the f**k up ? Two blokes talking about who should play wing or centre and you're getting all frothy about it. Are you 12 ?

 

[Incorrect]

Unless Dunster has somehow overcome whatever niggle he had last week that was causing him to walk and jog in the backfield like he'd had Josh Hodgson's knees transplanted to his legs, then I have grave concerns about his ability marking Khan-Pereira this week.

That was another failure by the Knights last week. It was obvious Dunster was inconvenienced but they sent very limited traffic his way. Admittedly what did come his way he handled quite well defensively. But Khan-Pereira is about 3 light years quicker than Marzhew

 

[hineyrulz]

No mate, Im not blindly defending. My opinion is that Russell's errors at centre were unacceptable and we cannot afford a repeat. If I have a different opinion than you, don't take offence to it, don't be shocked and humiliated. How about hardening the f**k up ? Two blokes talking about who should play wing or centre and you're getting all frothy about it. Are you 12 ?

lol the only one getting frothy about it is you by the looks.

 

[Incorrect]

lol the only one getting frothy about it is you by the looks.

Just remember mate, whatever happens, Parramatta did the right thing...

 

[hineyrulz]

Just remember mate, whatever happens, Parramatta did the right thing...

Always, The club that hasn’t won anything in 37 years has never made a mistake ever.

 

[Legal Eel]

No mate, Im not blindly defending. My opinion is that Russell's errors at centre were unacceptable and we cannot afford a repeat. If I have a different opinion than you, don't take offence to it, don't be shocked and humiliated. How about hardening the f**k up ? Two blokes talking about who should play wing or centre and you're getting all frothy about it. Are you 12 ?

frothy? I pointed out the consistently defensive stance you take.

I would say that your response was the childish one.

 

[Gronk]

frothy? I pointed out the consistently defensive stance you take.

I would say that your response was the childish one.

It's pointless being condescending with me. Argue your point and you have my attention. Deride me and you're not worth my time. You need to get better at this, playing the ad hominem card because you have nothing left makes you look the fool. Learn to control your emotions, Counselor.

 

[Gronk]

lol the only one getting frothy about it is you by the looks.

Nah he said I was blindly defending. I had a graph FFS.

 

[Legal Eel]

It's pointless being condescending with me. Argue your point and you have my attention. Deride me and you're not worth my time. You need to get better at this, playing the ad hominem card because you have nothing left makes you look the fool. Learn to control your emotions, Counselor.

You are right

I let myself down - I told myself long ago not to engage you as you know nothing about football - but I ignored my own advice to my detriment

 

[IFR33K]

Can I play?

your chances of playing will improve dramatically if you change your surname to Arthur. And bonus points if you can’t run!

 

[IFR33K]

It's pointless being condescending with me. Argue your point and you have my attention. Deride me and you're not worth my time. You need to get better at this, playing the ad hominem card because you have nothing left makes you look the fool. Learn to control your emotions, Counselor.

fmd, I friggen hate it when they waste your time. Ffs

 

[84 Baby]

@Twizzle As you can see Davey is top 30

Whilst I agree, is Hands as well?

 

[Soren Lorenson]

Whilst I agree, is Hands as well?

That's a big mystery that is.

 

[84 Baby]

I would say that your response was the childish one.

No, you f**ken are!

 

[hindy111]

No mate, Im not blindly defending. My opinion is that Russell's errors at centre were unacceptable and we cannot afford a repeat. If I have a different opinion than you, don't take offence to it, don't be shocked and humiliated. How about hardening the f**k up ? Two blokes talking about who should play wing or centre and you're getting all frothy about it. Are you 12 ?

Maybe he need some big man's pants.

Dunsters been shit house. Russels been average. I'd go with Waqa but he isnt fit. Waqa is twice the player of both at this point.

 

[hindy111]

lol the only one getting frothy about it is you by the looks.

f**k. He might of reached orgasm while typing

 

[hineyrulz]

Nah he said I was blindly defending. I had a graph FFS.

Pie charts FTW!!