Team list vs Panthers thread - Rnd 11

[hineyrulz]

Penrith by 30.

 

[T-Boon]

So was Tep dropped or have to sit out because of another head knock

My guess is dropped.
Edit: I looked it up concussion protocol.
How many times now has he been concussed?

 

[Noise]

George Jennings played f**king horrible and keeps his spot. Taka actually played ok and gets benched???

 

[Bazal]

My guess is dropped.
Edit: I looked it up concussion protocol.
How many times now has he been concussed?

f**ken heaps.

It's clearly affecting his game too. And it's getting to the stage where he will need to look at where his career goes pretty soon

 

[Bazal]

George Jennings played f**king horrible and keeps his spot. Taka actually played ok and gets benched???

Well we could always put French on the wing...

Taka has been horrible all year.

 

[I'm a loser baby...]

Has French snuck up the order there?

 

[Bazal]

Has French snuck up the order there?

Well he's not a pinch hitter.

Maybe the skipper is looking for someone who's quick between the wickets? Or a left /right hand combination

 

[T-Boon]

f**ken heaps.

It's clearly affecting his game too. And it's getting to the stage where he will need to look at where his career goes pretty soon

The club should offer him a job off the field.

 

[I'm a loser baby...]

Well he's not a pinch hitter.

Maybe the skipper is looking for someone who's quick between the wickets? Or a left /right hand combination

I think it might be a message to Smith - No dumb shit, merkin!

 

[Noise]

Well we could always put French on the wing...

Taka has been horrible all year.

I'm no fan of Taka but if it's a choice between George Jennings in the team and Taka, I pick Taka every time. Also moving Fergo to the centres weakens ones position to take a punt on another.

Salmon and Taka centres, Hoffman and Fergo wings.

 

[Bazal]

I'm no fan of Taka but if it's a choice between George Jennings in the team and Taka, I pick Taka every time. Also moving Fergo to the centres weakens ones position to take a punt on another.

Salmon and Taka centres, Hoffman and Fergo wings.

Seems that while Dylan Brown is in limbo Salmon is being given some time at six, which is where we'll need him most.

I'm not so keen on Ferguson at centre but without Mennings I don't think we can name a three quarter line thats objectively better than that. Gennings has fewer brain explosions than Taka if anything

 

[IFR33K]

I'm no fan of Taka but if it's a choice between George Jennings in the team and Taka, I pick Taka every time. Also moving Fergo to the centres weakens ones position to take a punt on another.

Salmon and Taka centres, Hoffman and Fergo wings.

Everyone keeps raving on about salmon as a centre but he continues to get overlooked. I don’t like the look of that side!

 

[T-Boon]

I would prefer Gutherson to centre for French at fullback rather than what BA has done.
So:
1. French
2. Sik
3. Guth
4. Tak (final warning)
5. Ferg
6. Salmon
7. Moses

In the back 3, Fergo is a lot more important than Guth who does not contribute to getting sets off to a good start.

 

[Kornstar]

With Sivo back and Fergo in the team and the ineffectiveness of the last 2 players in the 6 jersey should we slot French in at fullback and Gutho to 6 until Brown comes back?

French can only work when we don’t need him to ruck it out and with those 2 big bodies there maybe it is worth a try and we can use his speed!

Maybe if the team doesn’t work this week it may happen next week.....

 

[Noise]

Was kaufusi that bad on Saturday? He barely played any minutes.

 

[Soto]

Was kaufusi that bad on Saturday? He barely played any minutes.

More shit bench rotation by BA.
Keeping Jnr on too long, bringing blokes on when game is done in previous matches etc.
Does anyone think DWZ is on the outer? States he has been omitted...

 

[hindy111]

Well we could always put French on the wing...

Taka has been horrible all year.

He hasnt been good. His strong point is agrression and thats gone at moment.

So missing is Tepai and Kafusi is dropped. Sivo and Gower in.
Unsure why Kafusi was cut. Its some odd changes. But I will roll with it. I wouldnt mind Salmon getting shot at centre but Hoffman goes ok there. G.Jennings may of been terrible last mweek but he has barely played this season in any grade. He is a decent player and deserves a chance based on last years form rather then 1 poor game.

 

[Soto]

Was kaufusi that bad on Saturday? He barely played any minutes.

More shit bench rotation by BA.
Keeping Jnr on too long, bringing blokes on when game is done in previous matches etc.
Does anyone think DWZ is on the outer? States he has been omitted...

 

[Bazal]

Kaufusi is young. No reason to burn him out. Plus with Tepai missing, Gower fills his role in terms of being able to play edge or middle

Omitted doesn't always mean dropped

 

[hindy111]

MY guess DWZ is injured. Not in NSW cup either.