Great
Eels (Simple, iconic and screams RL)
Knights (Modern and keeps true to original)
Rabbitohs (Simple and iconic)
Warriors (Simple and iconic, good line-work)
Good
Bulldogs (Don't like the "BULLDOGS" at the top)
Dragons (Could be great with an update to the shield, Dragon/Knight is great)
Raiders (Good render, football on helmet looks a bit silly though)
Sea-Eagles (Well rendered Eagle on old-style circle, stays true to older logos)
Storm (A good representation given the awkward name)
Titans (Good rendering, "GOLD COST" in impact and rounded rectangle looks weird)
Ordinary
Roosters (too cartoonish for a historical side, needs to go back to Easts logo)
Panthers (Bad colours, wordmark)
Sharks (Bad wordmark, already dated)
Broncos (Trying too hard to be like Denver aesthetically, chess piece, needs to go back to updated original Bronco)
Bad
Cowboys (horrendous star, fixing that upgrades it to "good")
Tigers (Florida panthers ripoff, not fitting for two foundation clubs)