Team V Tigers 16/8/09

[Mr Angry]

Cronulla have lost fullback Bronx Goodwin for the season with a broken shoulder. He will be replaced against Wests Tigers on Sunday by Nathan Stapleton. Interchange hooker Terence Seu Seu has also been ruled out with a hamstring injury, with Lancen Joudo set to debut off the bench. There is some possibility, though, that Anthony Tupou will return from a hamstring injury.
Wests Tigers centre Chris Lawrence remains in doubt with a hamstring problem. Lawrence did not run with the team yesterday, with Dean Collis ready to replace him if needed.

http://www.leaguehq.com.au/news/lhq...n-for-nq-battle/2009/08/13/1249756399218.html

 

[Drakken]

The seasons over for the sharks so I would personally go with the guys who are going to be there next year. Not sure if all of these have been re-signed but I would go with something like this-
1. Goodwin (Is he staying??? If not then put Wright here and Covell back to the wing)
2. Ferguson
3. Pomeroy
4. Brown (Staying???)
5. Wright
6. Stapleton
7. Porter
8. Douglas
9. I would've said Green but now that he's going I guess Hughes will have to go here even though he's retiring.
10. Snowden
11. Afamasaga (Think he's re-signed hasn't he?)
12. Millington
13. Gallen
14. Unfortunately Seu Seu as I dont think there's another hooker.
15. Norrie (What's the story with this guy?)
16. Donnelly (And this one?)
17. Tupou (If fully fit only, don't risk him otherwise)

1. Wright
5. And would have to put Covell in now I guess
What a shame Cronulla dont have another fast try scoring winger like.. oh lets say Bryson Goodwin

 

[Tucky]

1. Wright
5. And would have to put Covell in now I guess
What a shame Cronulla dont have another fast try scoring winger like.. oh lets say Bryson Goodwin

Also Brown has signed with the Tigers for 2010.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

1. Wright
5. And would have to put Covell in now I guess
What a shame Cronulla dont have another fast try scoring winger like.. oh lets say Bryson Goodwin

Bryson Goodwin is average at best. Good players are judged by how well they play in a team coming last. Ferguson or Goodwin? FMD Fergo will pick him up with one hand by the skull & chuck him into the grandstand.

 

[Drakken]

Bryson Goodwin is average at best. Good players are judged by how well they play in a team coming last. Ferguson or Goodwin? FMD Fergo will pick him up with one hand by the skull & chuck him into the grandstand.

I thought he played well for Cronulla last year didn't you? Also the bloke can kick. I'm sure everyone thinks Inglis is such a good player because he stands out in a poor performing team.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

I thought he played well for Cronulla last year didn't you? Also the bloke can kick. I'm sure everyone thinks Inglis is such a good player because he stands out in a poor performing team.

Having watched Inglis proceed through the juniors in norhter NSW, QLD cup & then NRL from around the age of 14, his talent is undeniable. What is your point? That Goodwin is on parr with Inglis? FMD!!

 

[Drakken]

Having watched Inglis proceed through the juniors in norhter NSW, QLD cup & then NRL from around the age of 14, his talent is undeniable. What is your point? That Goodwin is on parr with Inglis? FMD!!

Bryson Goodwin is average at best. Good players are judged by how well they play in a team coming last. Ferguson or Goodwin? FMD Fergo will pick him up with one hand by the skull & chuck him into the grandstand.


See above for explanation ^^

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Bryson Goodwin is average at best. Good players are judged by how well they play in a team coming last. Ferguson or Goodwin? FMD Fergo will pick him up with one hand by the skull & chuck him into the grandstand.


See above for explanation ^^

If your point is about inglis only playing in good teams, that is not the case. The teams win because he is so good. When he was coming through the ranks, his teams were average at best even when he was scoring 5 length of the field trys each game, to keep them in the hunt.
he was outstanding as a junior in any team. He was outstanding QLD cup & only ended up playing a handful before being plucked into first grade where again, he is outstanding.
How can you seriously mention a hack like goodwin in the same breath.
FMD inglis can cover any backfline position & would probably be the best in the comp at that position.
Goodwin?> Career winger, average at best, with medium pace.

 

[Drakken]

If your point is about inglis only playing in good teams, that is not the case. The teams win because he is so good. When he was coming through the ranks, his teams were average at best even when he was scoring 5 length of the field trys each game, to keep them in the hunt.
he was outstanding as a junior in any team. He was outstanding QLD cup & only ended up playing a handful before being plucked into first grade where again, he is outstanding.
How can you seriously mention a hack like goodwin in the same breath.
FMD inglis can cover any backfline position & would probably be the best in the comp at that position.
Goodwin?> Career winger, average at best, with medium pace.

No Goodwin has nothing on Inglis, I was just pointing a glaring error in your opinion. The storm still won with out Inglis and on more than one occassion too. Good players don't have to be judged in a poor team.

 

[The Popper]

Tonight will be the first time I've barracked for Manly in a game since 1971.

 

[sando88]

daily telegraph says 23yrold weyman (michaels brother) has earnt a callup from nsw cup

 

[RUBIKS]

While we are bringing up all these randoms, why not bring up Orcher instead of Misi?

What happened to our second teir cap? Have we blown it so bad that Ricky though well we're going to get caught anyway, may as well blood everyone...

 

[S.R.]

So now it's:

1. Stapleton
2. Talaupapa
3. Pommeroy
4. Brown
5. Capt Afterburners
6. Wright
7. Porter
8. Snowden
9. Hughes
10. Douglas
11. Afamasaga
12. Millington
13. Gallen

14. Weyman
15. Norrie
16. Joudo
17. Tupou


You'd assume Donnelly out for Weyman?
Tupou still going to play?

 

[runatme]

i think norrie is injured

 

[Inferno]

If Weyman is replacing Norrie, then I'd suspect either Donelly or Weyman will start with Dougie pushing into the backrow.

 

[Mr Angry]

Can't see Cov moving left Angry.
I get the impression that right wing is the only place left for him in the squad.
Blake is a far better option at left wing. I know he's having a rest, but I think that's the way it's going down

I note Don that Blake is playing right centre in NYC.

 

[DJDL]

Just noticed that myself Angry one.
He debuted in firsts at right centre too.

God knows what's going on there.

 

[Inferno]

I note Don that Blake is playing right centre in NYC.

I thought he was very poor Angry, seemed a bit disinterested. Makes me wonder if his demotion was attitude related.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

look up the meaning of the phrase "kick ins". There is picture of Bryson Goodwin.
Whilst I feel sorry for the guy, this year is not the year to celebrate bonuses.
Correct?

 

[Mr Angry]

I thought he was very poor Angry, seemed a bit disinterested. Makes me wonder if his demotion was attitude related.

Seemed to me to have much expectation. That said, coach is in charge of attitude.