Except Roosters signed a 25 year agreement to play at the new Allianz stadium. You best make peace with that.
They could play 3 heritages games
Except Roosters signed a 25 year agreement to play at the new Allianz stadium. You best make peace with that.
So Adelaide Broncos it is.Except Roosters signed a 25 year agreement to play at the new Allianz stadium. You best make peace with that.
Which 2?Rams, Pirates, Bris 2 and NZ 2…
Makes sense.
2 Sydney teams to go.
Any two but mine.Which 2?
Any two but mine.
Does West Tigers count as 2 clubs?
Or St George Illawarra?
(There's no restrictions on house parties here at the moment...)
Paul Kent made a good point when he said you wouldn't have the Dragons and Sharks where they are if you were putting the league together today.
I genuinely fear for the future of the Dragons and Sharks because they're fighting over such a small catchment. If a club was to fall on hard times and find life easier in Adelaide, surely it has to be one of these clubs.
made sense when it was a suburban one city comp. Makes no sense as a would be national comp. But no one has the balls or vision to do anything about it so we will be stuck with what we've got for a very long time. Short of LC's going out of fashion there wont be any financial imperative for anyone to be dropped or relocated.Paul Kent made a good point when he said you wouldn't have the Dragons and Sharks where they are if you were putting the league together today.
I genuinely fear for the future of the Dragons and Sharks because they're fighting over such a small catchment. If a club was to fall on hard times and find life easier in Adelaide, surely it has to be one of these clubs.
Just spitballing and mostly messing around here but what about a 3 team merger between the dragons, sharks and steelers?Paul Kent made a good point when he said you wouldn't have the Dragons and Sharks where they are if you were putting the league together today.
I genuinely fear for the future of the Dragons and Sharks because they're fighting over such a small catchment. If a club was to fall on hard times and find life easier in Adelaide, surely it has to be one of these clubs.
If you could wave a magic wand you'd have a Southern Sharks playing out of a new stadium somewhere accessible to the St George/Cronulla regions with maybe 3 games in Wollongong. But will never happen. If sharks hadn't had land to flog off good chance they'd be bust by now and Dragons could have taken over their junior catchment. But again wont happen now so we are stuck with what we have, arguably to the detriment to the long term future of the game.Just spitballing and mostly messing around here but what about a 3 team merger between the dragons, sharks and steelers?
The St George Illawarra sharks permanently based in Wollongong?
Why not base the southern sharks/st George illawarra sharks out of Wollongong permanently?If you could wave a magic wand you'd have a Southern Sharks playing out of a new stadium somewhere accessible to the St George/Cronulla regions with maybe 3 games in Wollongong. But will never happen. If sharks hadn't had land to flog off good chance they'd be bust by now and Dragons could have taken over their junior catchment. But again wont happen now so we are stuck with what we have, arguably to the detriment to the long term future of the game.
Good question - and I wonder if the Steelers actually *had* to merge with St George. Being a regional club, I assume they wouldn't have been subject to the dreaded criteria that Sydney clubs faced.Is the consensus regarding Illawarra on here that the Wollongong/illawarra region is too small to permanently base an NRL franchise?
Had the rationalization of Sydney clubs been better handled then there’s absolutely no reason and no justification for not having NRL clubs in both illawarra and the central coast.Good question - and I wonder if the Steelers actually *had* to merge with St George. Being a regional club, I assume they wouldn't have been subject to the dreaded criteria that Sydney clubs faced.
It strikes me as a similar scenario, similar conundrum to having a stand-alone Central Coast team.
Can the NRL afford more mid-size regional stand-alone teams while big fish like Perth, Adelaide & Brisbane 2 haven't been added?
Good question - and I wonder if the Steelers actually *had* to merge with St George. Being a regional club, I assume they wouldn't have been subject to the dreaded criteria that Sydney clubs faced.
It strikes me as a similar scenario, similar conundrum to having a stand-alone Central Coast team.
Can the NRL afford more mid-size regional stand-alone teams while big fish like Perth, Adelaide & Brisbane 2 haven't been added?
I think the ARLC has to address the viability of the game as it currently stands, as all signs point to it being unsustainable. The player base is getting thinner and it's going to get worse. Globalisation has made American and European sporting competitions from soccer, basketball and gridiron a competitor. We might only have enough talent and supporters to sustain a 12 team competition by 2050. I hope it doesn't go down that path, but we have to accept it's possible if current trends continue and aren't addressed.Indeed, nor would you have a pocket of the eastern suburbs for the Roosters wedged in above the remainder claimed by souths.
Nor have Leichhardt n Rozelle combined with Campbelltown.
But that’s how it’s evolved!
Yes. Too small and too much near by big city competition. There’s only one nsw club managing to survive without a big LC, that’s how crowded the nsw market is.Is the consensus regarding Illawarra on here that the Wollongong/illawarra region is too small to permanently base an NRL franchise?
I am of the belief that leaving Sydney oversaturated while Bris/NZ are under-represented and Adelaide and Perth unrepresented is causing more damage than can occur by rationalising Sydney.made sense when it was a suburban one city comp. Makes no sense as a would be national comp. But no one has the balls or vision to do anything about it so we will be stuck with what we've got for a very long time. Short of LC's going out of fashion there wont be any financial imperative for anyone to be dropped or relocated.
Good question - and I wonder if the Steelers actually *had* to merge with St George. Being a regional club, I assume they wouldn't have been subject to the dreaded criteria that Sydney clubs faced.
It strikes me as a similar scenario, similar conundrum to having a stand-alone Central Coast team.
Can the NRL afford more mid-size regional stand-alone teams while big fish like Perth, Adelaide & Brisbane 2 haven't been added?