I will never get this Robo hate. He won a comp back to back. Has Bellamy? Bellamy would win one and not make it the next if you count the ones he won fairly not the ones taken off him. Beallamy had 3 immortals at one stage play with him in Cronk, Smith and Slater. Robbo's strike rate at GF's is 100% where as Bellamy's is 3 out of 8 I think. I would take Robo over Bellamy in a heartbeat. Robo's only struggles are due to injury. He has stumbled into finals and lost class players like Manu, JWH, Radley, Teddy or Walker during those games. They beat the Sharks without Teddy, Manu and Suallii and were down a man a couple of years ago.
Robbo's current form against Penrith and Storm is bad but his injury toll / suspensions has been shocking the last few years.
Robbo has the best roster EVERY SEASON. Politis makes certain of this. Even going into 2025 he still has an awesome squad, even with the departure of Manu, JWH etc. The perceived bad luck with injuries they have had have been no worse than any other club. It is just that the media write and promote their pre-made excuses. Poor poor Chooks. I remember games where we've had just as many as them out, but because their outs are marquee, they get the sympathies from the press. The game when we beat the Panthers last season, we had a similar number out, but because theirs was Cleary, T'oo, etc, that became an excuse for the Panthers loss. Robbo is not that good a coach. At the beginning of 2024, he couldn't fit Angus Chrichton, Daniel Tupou, Connor Watson, Sia Wong into his top 17. They had a few injuries and then Chrichton, Tupou and Watson became regular top 17. What a great luxury to have superstars unable to make your squad.
Robbo is a myth and the back to backs were because of Cooper Cronk. His squads should be in every grand final. They start favourites every season.If Flanno has his squad, he'd RARELY lose.