Previous dozen iterations? Are you talking about the Rugby Super League? Because that was never professional. That's the only nationwide league I'm aware of. The are regional leagues like the Pacific Rugby Premiership, Atlantic Rugby Premiership, Red River Rugby Conference and the Mid-West D1. But they are all amateur leagues. Though I do know the PRP are looking to establish themselves as firmly semi-pro in the next few years.
This is the 2nd attempt that actually pays players. The 1st failed because of the model (owned by one bloke)and the clash of ego's. This one is a different structure and anyone wanting to enter the league has to provide verified finances capable of sustaining operations at a minimal level for a period of 5 years. This includes playing an annual bond to the league in order to cover operational costs such as player salaries, travel and accommodation etc.
The 9 that will play in the 2nd season stating in late January and the three others that will join them in 2020 have all met those criteria.
So, perhaps it will fail. Though the games averaged 250k last season on TV at a 50:1 viewership ratio which is well above the average for most start up leagues in the States over the past 25 years including the MLS so things are looking good so far. But, if it fails (and you'll say something you think is smart that it will) it likely wouldn't be for a few years yet. And at least Rugby is at a point in North America where it can begin to actually try this kind of thing. League is still struggling to maintain a handful of active teams nationwide. So, from a Rugby perspective. If MLR doesn't make the jump then all we can hope for is the next iteration learns from the experience and moves forward once again.
And please don't mention the Wolfpack. While I do applaud their marketing efforts we all know that being actually based in England they are more a Fly In/Fly Out team with Toronto branding and not actually a representation of League in Nth America.
It will end up in the bin as the previous dozen iterations have. Enjoy Australian union circling the drain hole.
