The weekly Paul Carige award

[Jason Maher]

Please, comparing what Hindmarsh has offered Parra and Burt is like comparing Rolls Royce to a Datsun 180b.

What in the blue hell does Dale Shearer have to do with this?

 

[bottle]

Bit harsh on Burt I feel. Always gave his all and delivered some quality at times. Not every player's an immortal.

 

[Y2Eel]

Burt's f**k ups led to 3 Dragons tries.

An appropriate way to end his career. Terrible player, I'll never understand what any Eels fans see in hm.

Alot like Hornby Soward Nightingale Stanley and Rein Dont see what the hell people think is so good about him...

 

[bottle]

There GKD see what you've done, you've gone and upset him. Now be nice and aplogise or no dessert.

 

[Y2Eel]

There GKD see what you've done, you've gone and upset him. Now be nice and aplogise or no dessert.

Oh let him have his desert

 

[CliffyIsGod]

Dave Taylor

 

[Charlie124]

Lolrightthef**k@50(c)uff$

 

[Big Pete]

Josh Hoffman
Jack Reed
Corey Norman

Beale's opening mistake was pretty bad too.

 

[THE CHAMP]

Josh Hoffman
Jack Reed
Corey Norman

Beale's opening mistake was pretty bad too.

Not 100% sure Beale knocked that one on but he was still pretty bad.
Hoffman was f**king shithouse. We need to look elsewhere for a fullback.
Tate made him look like he was running in concrete.
Norman was his usual self. Shit. Could finish bottom 4 next year looking at that performance.

 

[Captain BF]

Brent Tate. Should have passed the ball to Graham. Line wide open. Would have been back into the game. Everything changes.

 

[bottle]

The refs.

 

[Charlie124]

Bill harrigans parents

 

[Jason Maher]

Brent Tate. Should have passed the ball to Graham. Line wide open. Would have been back into the game. Everything changes.

Dead set, is every centre in the NRL locked in a death match to find who is the biggest hog?

I second the nomination of the refs, the idiots in the box in particular.

 

[Matt23]

Steve Clark

 

[STORM.99/07]

paul simpkins.should be banned from any NRL game.Most inept ref NRL has ever had.

 

[Jason Maher]

The entire Manly team except for Lyon.

 

[El Diablo]

Manly

 

[Son of Minto]

"The weekly Jorge Taufua award"

 

[adamkungl]

+1 for Taufua... he'd have it pretty well sealed for 2012 imo

 

[dogslife]

Prelim finals bring out the Carige in some blokes