The weekly Paul Carige award

[CliffyIsGod]

Billy Slater for attempting the chip and chase, but having an air swing with his foot.

 

[God-King Dean]

LOL, I don't think he should get near the top 3 though, it's not like it's a mistake that ruined Storms chances

LOL, dare I add SBWs to the list?

 

[Balmain_Boy]

Why? He was one of the Dog's best today? #-o

 

[God-King Dean]

2 mistakes lead to tries as well

 

[Munky]

Reece Simmonds attempt to catch the ball going out on the full was tops.

Obviously though Campbell was kicking for touch from a penalty.

 

[God-King Dean]

though

Do you mean 'thought' or 'though'?

 

[Dr Crane]

Tony Archer and the sideline imbeciles.

 

[Sea_Eagles_Rock]

Morrison has to get the nod this week.

 

[aids]

morrison.

 

[El Diablo]

Matt Gafa

 

[God-King Dean]

Luke MacDougall

 

[Bazal]

Yeah, Morro kicked the ball a little hard...but no way in any of the seven levels of hell did he knock on. Mander/Hampstead get my vote, closely followed by Mick Stone.

 

[Jake the snake]

Brian Fletcher from the Kick restart when he stopped the ball from going the 10m.

 

[The Colonel]

Gary Freeman - LUKE MacDougall plays in jumper number two, ADAM MacDougall plays in jumper number 1. 25 minutes of you calling Adam as Luke was enough...... someone could have told him. :roll:

 

[legend]

His hatred for the Raiders is pathetic and shows him up to be a rank amatuer IMO.

As silly as Morrison was, he certainly didn't knock the ball on and for Hampstead to make the call when he was standing no more than a metre away means he should be this weeks winner.

 

[Kiwi]

His hatred for the Raiders is pathetic and shows him up to be a rank amatuer IMO.

As silly as Morrison was, he certainly didn't knock the ball on and for Hampstead to make the call when he was standing no more than a metre away means he should be this weeks winner.

How about the ref from the Tigers v Bulldogs game, who whilst standing right there within a metre, let Anasta get up after diving on the ball, with Hodgson on him and carry Hodgson over the line to score. Last time I checked if you dive on a ball, and the opposition player is on top of you, thats tackled.

 

[The Colonel]

His hatred for the Raiders is pathetic and shows him up to be a rank amatuer IMO.

Listen to him call a Parramatta game....... ;-)

 

[Darth Bobo]

How about the ref from the Tigers v Bulldogs game, who whilst standing right there within a metre, let Anasta get up after diving on the ball, with Hodgson on him and carry Hodgson over the line to score. Last time I checked if you dive on a ball, and the opposition player is on top of you, thats tackled.

It wasnt the only dodgy decision he came out with, I'm glad that we won the game because if that decision and the one where Paul Whatiura's try was disallowed for a double movement were allowed to impact on the outcome of the game I would have snapped. We had enough of that shi*t last year.

Morrison should get the award this week, there is no excuse for losing the ball like that for a professional footballer, would love to see what Smith has him doing at training this week.

 

[legend]

But the replays showed he didn't knock the ball on. He was stupid for acting like an idiot whilst behind on the scoreboard and he got his just desserts it would seem.

 

[Dr Crane]

Do "Aggreived Souths Fan" and "Man in New Zealand Warriors jersey" get special mentions for throwing crap at referees?