http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2002/12/11/1039379884734.html
Judiciary threatens walkout if NRL ends defamation funding
By Brad Walter and Roy Masters
December 12 2002
The National Rugby League's entire seven-man judiciary has threatened to resign en-masse over the NRL's decision to stop funding legal action by some panel members against NSW Origin coach Phil Gould.
Judiciary commissioner Jim Hall, chairman Greg Woods, QC, and the five-man panel of former players Royce Ayliffe, Ian Roberts, Darrell Williams, Mal Cochrane and Jeff Hardy made the threat in a letter sent to NRL chairman John Chalk last Friday.
They are furious with the NRL's decision not to fund their pursuit of damages in the wake of a Supreme Court ruling in September that Gould had defamed Hall, Ayliffe, Roberts and Williams.
The action was triggered by Gould's criticism of the tribunal's decision to impose a six-match suspension on Dragons captain Craig Smith last year made in comments on Macquarie radio's 2GB and in his column in
The Sun-Herald, published by John Fairfax, which also publishes the
Herald.
A new hearing would determine whether the judiciary representatives are entitled to damages but the NRL is not prepared to continue funding the action.
");document.write(" [SIZE=-1]
advertisement[/SIZE]</div>"); } } // -->
NRL chief executive David Gallop had hoped an apology from Gould to the judiciary members would end the matter. However, the judiciary members are adamant they want to seek financial compensation.
"We told the plaintiffs during grand final week, when the matter was in court, that once the defendant offered a full and unreserved apology it was then our view that the necessity for the league to fund the proceedings was removed," Gallop said.
"Having said that, we respect their private rights to continue the litigation, but we don't believe it is appropriate for the league to fund the proceedings beyond that point."
Gallop said he had not seen the letter, which contains all seven members' signatures, but was aware of its contents.
However, he said funding matters were the responsibility of the NRL's joint shareholders, News Ltd and the Australian Rugby League, not the board.
"In any event, the NRL partners have recently re-affirmed that the matter is now a private matter if they [the judiciary members] wish to pursue it for payment of damages," he said.
"The game will always act to protect the reputation and integrity of its tribunals and tribunal members but there must be a point when it becomes a private issue for them to determine the extent to which damages should be paid to them.
"Our decision in relation to funding the proceedings should not in any way be interpreted as giving credibility to the offending comments by Phil Gould.
"[But] if it had been an individual who was bound to the NRL rules, then we would have taken action against the individual or the club under the rules.
It didn't, so court action was necessary, but it couldn't be unlimited."
Asked if he believed the NRL needed to find a new judiciary for next season, Gallop said: "I'd be disappointed if they choose to adopt that course."
But Hall indicated yesterday that the seven tribunal members were prepared to carry through with their threat. "We've asked them to re-consider their position on funding to us and we'll re-consider our position in relation to them," Hall said. "He [Gallop] says we should take an apology. But they never told us that they would cease funding at that stage. We though that they were committed until the end."
Meanwhile, Gallop expressed surprise at Brisbane coach Wayne Bennett's criticism of plans to introduce a golden point rule next season in drawn matches.
Bennett was unable to attend the NRL's annual conference last month, but Gallop said that other Broncos officials had approved the introduction of up to 10 minutes of extra time.
"It got 100 per cent support at the annual conference but unfor- tunately Wayne wasn't there to participate in the debate," he said.
I have selected some quotes from Darrell Williams over the last week in interviews that he has done regarding taking legal action. I can't find any direct quotes or interviews from Royce Ayliffe or Darren Britt.
The threat to sue was it would appear started on 27th of September and made by Williams to Mascord.
Storm erupts over fine
By Steve Mascord September 28, 2008 12:00am
http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/nrl/comments/0,27064,24411983-11088,00.html
NRL judiciary members were last night considering legal action against Melbourne Storm after the grand finalists were hit with an unprecedented $50,000 fine for bringing the game into disrepute.
The damage is done Bellamy, says Gallop
Posted Mon Sep 29, 2008 2:24pm AEST
Updated Mon Sep 29, 2008 2:43pm AEST
ABC NEWS
www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/09/29/2377031.htm - 21k
David Gallop says Craig Bellamy's comments are hard to take back. (Getty Images: Matt King)
NRL chief executive David Gallop says Craig Bellamy's apology to the judiciary does not make up for his outlandish comments on the suspension of Storm captain Cam Smith.
Bellamy said he knew that Smith had no chance of beating a grapple tackle charge last week after he saw the betting markets.
He later apologised for suggesting the decision to ban Smith for two matches was made before last Wednesday night's judiciary hearing.
But Mr Gallop says the judiciary panel members are right to be upset about Bellamy's comments.
NRL judiciary panelist recommends taking legal action against Storm
By Steve Mascord | October 01, 2008 12:00am Herald Sun
www.news.com.au/dailytelegraph/story/0,22049,24428333-5001023,00.html
JUDICIARY members have lost patience with Melbourne and panelist Darrell Williams will today recommend they launch immediate legal action against the grand finalists.
Williams put off a meeting with fellow tribunal members Royce Ayliffe and Darren Britt yesterday because he was told the Storm had scheduled an announcement.
"I'll be seeking to resolve this through the courts and will instigate that immediately," Williams told the Daily Telegraph last night.
Williams said he was also unimpressed Storm's captain Cooper Cronk had since said players were "right behind" Bellamy.
"That's an attitude through the whole club that I don't like," he said. "Things will happen from now.
Too little, too late for Melbourne Storm over apology
Brent Read and Stuart Honeysett |
October 03, 2008
http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,24437819-2722,00.html
"While they may be trying to shield their players from it, it's still hanging around," Williams said.
Williams rejects call to delay legal action
BY STEVE JANCETIC
3/10/2008 12:00:00 AM
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/new...jects-call-to-delay-legal-action/1324411.aspx
But Williams dismissed the proposition.
''I am not in the mood to sit down and wait for them to get over their grand final campaign,'' Williams told SBS.
Initially judiciary member Williams claimed he wanted an apology from the Storm before Sunday's grand final, but on Wednesday said he had run out of patience and yesterday officially lodged the claim.