What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Very old anti-Nutley thread by me bumped

pogo

Juniors
Messages
2,263
reefy, you obviously compare him to other prop forwards.

stevens
clinton
ryles
sims
webcke
civoniceva
omeley
price
ohara
davico
kearns
perry
woolnough
rauhihi
bailey
stringer
morley
cayless
tupou
villasanti

there is a list of TWENTY who quite clearly shit all over nutley.

now i rate his work rate , his defence is sound but in attack unless he dives at the ground and gets a quickplay the ball he is dead set ineffective.

when the big games are on and the forward battles are being won they arent won with pygmies!
 

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
one thing about this thread

not just nutley but the entire team (maybe except bailey) has made a dramatic change in their discipline

the coach has acted

nutley has improved his discipline out of sight

do you deny this pogo?
 

pogo

Juniors
Messages
2,263
dont change the point millernose!!

u want to wrap him for doing what he is expexcted to do!!!

get back on track....the above post shows he is in the bottom 1/3 of prop forwards.
 

pogo

Juniors
Messages
2,263
deny his discipline has improved , absolutely not .

i guess after he was one of the most heavily penalised in the nrl early on he could only improve couldnt he???

back to the real issue after your clever nark like diversion.....
 

blacktip-reefy

Immortal
Messages
34,079
thats a very good list Pogo
well done.
Except for tha fact that list is a meaningless piece of shyte like most of your irrelevant posts.
You don't even know what Nuttleys role is in the team.
you haven't backed your opinion up with 1 piece of factual evidence.
The fact of the matter is, Nutters has a role in the team & that role does not include any of the things you say.
Raper says he is the first one picked, so the club, staff & team all seem to disagree with you. His name has been brought up in origin talks.
On close inspection to the stats I could tear your list apart with real stats. But that is obvious , I I can't be bothered.
we have all just learnt one thing.
pogo = mindless git & knows as much about league as Mao Tsi Tung.
Looking forward to subsequent posts of yours & perhaps a step up in quality because at this rate, it's just too easy.
 

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
well at least i had you concede you took a thread out of context

frankly i agree with you

nutley for me is a second rower with a good work ethic

he makes stacks of tackles and misses plenty also

he has strengths and weaknesses as have all players

his major weakness when you compare him to your list is .....size
 

pogo

Juniors
Messages
2,263
aww geez reefy dont hide tear em apart champ.

i get it his role is to play 80mins and tackle but not bust the line ...i got it hit the deck and bounce up quick.

your kidding mate, the list says it all.

as for facts mate what position did kevin play in the grand final????
and the original axe was bunny reilly mate.

dont let the facts bugger YOUR argument.
 

Jimbo

Immortal
Messages
40,107
Every one of those players listed is a hack compared with Nutley, bar about three.

You rightly left Parsons off though, since he is now scared sh*tless of a man a foot and a half shorter...
 

Jimbo

Immortal
Messages
40,107
Just telling it like it is.

Nutley > Parsons

A great man. A proud captain. A machine...

Clone the bastard!!

:D
 
Messages
15,203
keep him or punt him nark??? come on champ? u change your mind more than i change my incontinence pads

Nice one you freak
I said in the other thread that I advocated dropping him for his discipline earlier in the year
He was also making too many errors
I also said in the other thread that this has changed and so now I'm a fan

Now that the discipline is greatly improved I want Nutley in the team
Are you that thick that you cant understand that? As millers said, get some perspective. I based my opinion at the time on form and performance. The form and performance of Nutley (and along with Stevens and Bailey also) have changed. Thus I changed my opinion and was pleased to be able to do so.

Your posts both confuse and worry me. I dont care how old you are, you obviously have no idea. This is the most pointless bump I've ever seen.

The fact that no one except your only mate on here McSharkie agrees with you, ever, just goes to show how lowly you are. Get a clue you git
 

pogo

Juniors
Messages
2,263
The fact that no one except your only mate on here McSharkie agrees with you, ever, just goes to show how lowly you are. Get a clue you git[/quote]

touchy touchy nark!!

the gist of the argument einstein is that nutley doesnt have the size to make an impact in attack!!

debate it all you like!
 

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
his role isnt to break the line pogo

it isnt to goal kick

it isnt kicks in general play

it isnt selective passing

its defense - lot of it

and its getting 10 meters and a quick play the ball

he performs this role very well

is stevens a lesser player than him because he doesnt make as many tackles

in fact i dont think any on your list come close to the volume of tackles performed by nutley
 
Messages
15,203
Prior to last weekend (in the most recent big league mag)

Danny Nutley is 4th in hit ups/runs behind skandalis, minichiello and schifcofski
stevens comes next then lang. corey parker and steve price are well down the list.

He is second top tackler in the comp with 436, behind only nathan hindmarsh

As far as tackle breaks go, the only forward on the list is Gorden Tallis and he obviously plays a different role to Nutley

Backs make line breaks, forwards do the hard stuff
Your confusion is astounding and is providing some amusement to the rest of us
The fact that not even McSharkie is agreeing with you here should provide some clue that you are completely incorrect
 

pogo

Juniors
Messages
2,263
yeah millersnose its defence like that against ian hindmarsh that will bring the fans back.

porky pig could hit it up better than nutley.......and probably be a better chance off a decent offload.

stevens and nutley is phar lap and radish by the way!
 

millersnose

Post Whore
Messages
65,223
unfortunately pogo without seeing porky pig play it is doubtful your claim can be put to the test

radishes would also struggle to top the clubin tackles
 

pogo

Juniors
Messages
2,263
ohh yes nark of course he is because he plays 80mins most weeks mate.

this is about quality mate, he CANT dent the line.........thats fine though your mind is like concrete very hard and completely set.

compare him to those on the list with an honest open mind and work it out from there because those are the players he is competing with.

im glad you now dont want to"f**k him off" for whatever the reason.
 

blacktip-reefy

Immortal
Messages
34,079
So now you are going to tell me about Stumpy.
Thats beautiful.
Just keep adding to your irrelevance & lack of knowledge.
One would suggest to ignore you but in reality you are too much fun.
Not one fact in any post you have ever made.
did you ever put a boot on or are you a female?

Please don't leave us, as it hacks like you that get us to debate points about our players.
Just a question, when will your first entry of fact occurr?
i.e. what position did stump play?
 
Top