Wake Up Raper

[black_dot]

For every " ex shark player" and every "ex international" that you both cite as very loose, very flimsy sources guys, that say " peachey is rubbish and used up" or that say" simmons is rubbish and has got nothing", I can just as flimsily say that I know plenty of "ex-sharks players" and "ex internationals" ....infact, fug it, add "Current sharks and international players" to that mix, that have offered up their opinion that Peachey is what is holding the sharks together into some semblance of a football team this year, and that Simmons is one of the most talented young athletes and outside backs in the game.

I just think that the entire debate has done more rotations than a peach kick return, and reading it again is about as exciting as a Simmons kick return.

it's old ground and the same old argument, claims, counter claims, but it's nothing more than your own opinions which is fine, no amount of " ask people at the ground" " ask the ex kangaroo coach, ask etc etc what they think is going to add any weight to either arguement or sway the other from their very staunch opinion.

I just hope that both sides of the debate are sharks fans enough and not too proud to actually hope they are both wrong deep down, and that peachey and Simmons find some great form over the next few weeks and turn things around to give us a fighting chance in the semis.

 

[blacktip-reefy]

no i accept none of your assessments

that is because Bongo thinks hacks are good footballers & he refuses to concede when proven wrong.

here is a list of debutant wingers in the NRL this year.
naiquama
Bott
Scott
Inglis
Bowen

Thes guys are constantly going back a grade to work on aspects of their game & when they do come back, they play better again.
How come these 5-15 game veterans are som uch better already than a player have put so much time, effort & money into. Seriously, Naiquama vs simmons
f*ck me f*cken fatal!!!!!

 

[blacktip-reefy]

yillen gordon vs simmons f*ck me f*cken fatal!!!!!

 

[blacktip-reefy]

John Sutton vs simmons, f*ck me f*cken fatal!!!!!

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Reddy v Simmons. f*ck me f*cken fatal!!!!!

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Brad Tighe v simmons f*ck me f*cken fatal!!!!!

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Trent Salked vs simmons f*ck me f*cken fatal!!!!!

 

[BeenThere]

simmons vs simmons f*ck me f*cken fatal!!!!!

 

[Thomo.]

the old bag at the roosters game that abused me on the way out v simmons f*ck me f*cken fatal!!!!!

 

[BeenThere]

the grass at the stadium vs simmons f*ck me f*cken fatal!!!!!

 

[Thomo.]

BT - :lol: :lol:

 

[White Poiner]

over it!!

 

[pogo]

of course i hope all players excel black dot, unlike some in particular who death ride a few consistently.

i wont argue this point again, you are obviously either too close or blindly loyal to see what is so apparrent.
dont expect peacheys teammates to bag him.

his form has become a laughing stock , so much so one high profile commentator is having a field day with him.

cronullas malaise , expecting the likes of peachey, nutley and co to get us a title.

if it wasnt so sad it would be funny.

the end!

 

[King of the Hill]

of course i hope all players excel black dot, unlike some in particular who death ride a few consistently.

righto bobo...nice sentiments

oh wait that didnt last long

his form has become a laughing stock , so much so one high profile commentator is having a field day with him.

cronullas malaise , expecting the likes of peachey, nutley and co to get us a title.

if it wasnt so sad it would be funny.

the end!

 

[blacktip-reefy]

cronullas malaise.
Expecting skill-less hacks like Simmons & Bird to bring us a title & therefore wasting years of preferential first grade selections & experience on 2 players that are fring first graders at best at any other NRL club.
As for a high profile commentator having a field day with him, what a f*cken joke.
who would that be Bongo?
Bruce Macaveney? Oh thats right he is AFL, your prefferred sport.

 

[pogo]

ask the loop or the tit!

 

[blacktip-reefy]

Bruce macaveney "So Dave Simmons again you have had another great game out there today, 4 tackles, only missed 3. 12 hitups for 18 metres. And that spectacular ball carry of yours, brings everybody to their feet. Surely now you have to consider yourself in top 32 wingers in the NRL? When do you hope to take that old hack peacheys job over? & do you think you can break into the top 16 fullbacks in the NRL?"

Simmons "have you read the bible?"

 

[pogo]

interesting to see how highly david peachey rates simmons isnt it backflip.

and no as usual your a mile of the pace, its not macavaney.

ask the other blind man, and thats the one without the labrador, lol

 

[DJDL]

Bruce macaveney "So Dave Simmons again you have had another great game out there today, 4 tackles, only missed 3. 12 hitups for 18 metres. And that spectacular ball carry of yours, brings everybody to their feet. Surely now you have to consider yourself in top 32 wingers in the NRL? When do you hope to take that old hack peacheys job over? & do you think you can break into the top 16 fullbacks in the NRL?"

Simmons "have you read the bible?"

:lol:

Some of your best work, Reefy

 

[blacktip-reefy]

34 games ago Peach rated , Simmons.
he has seen nothing but a decline in effort & zero growth in skills & ability.
When will it happen pogo?
Tell us all. When will Bird & Simmons deliver their so called potential?
When will simmons do more than just fall over the line after peach or Dykes has set him up? When will he produce skills like the 30 game veteran on the other wing?