Week 2 Trial Vs Tigers

[Black Panther]

Lead with shoulder and it ended up hitting the opposition's head even tho first contact was shoulder to shoulder. A week would have been fair. Im glad he got off as it would have ruined a blockbuster.

So he learnt how to tackle properly, lead with your shoulder. Was a total farce and justice has been served. People can say what they want, but everyone knows it was a good shot.

 

[Black Diamond]

Lead with shoulder and it ended up hitting the opposition's head even tho first contact was shoulder to shoulder. A week would of been fair. Im glad he got off as it would of ruined a blockbuster.

There was no HIA. Therefore no contact with head.

 

[Oldpanther86]

There was no HIA. Therefore no contact with head.

Not how it works!!!

 

[Black Diamond]

Not how it works!!!

Well Ivan proved it was

 

[Oldpanther86]

Well Ivan proved it was

These were the points that cleared him. Someone can be hit in the head and not be concussed:

 

[Black Panther]

I get you can be hit in the head and not be concussed, but who plays god out on the field. Would still assume you go for a HIA to be deemed fit to play otherwise we are going to have players never going off. Not sure many players would volunteer to go off. I do however believe the Tigers case was more whiplash effect.

 

[Oldpanther86]

I get you can be hit in the head and not be concussed, but who plays god out on the field. Would still assume you go for a HIA to be deemed fit to play otherwise we are going to have players never going off. Not sure many players would volunteer to go off. I do however believe the Tigers case was more whiplash effect.

They look for specific symptoms. They arent guessing. At least not to the degree you are implying.

 

[Black Diamond]

These were the points that cleared him. Someone can be hit in the head and not be concussed:

View attachment 109998

Where in that summary does it say he was hit in the head? It says "shoulder to shoulder" If he hit him in the head, he would have been suspended.

 

[Oldpanther86]

Where in that summary does it say he was hit in the head? It says "shoulder to shoulder" If he hit him in the head, he would have been suspended.

Did you misunderstand the conversation? People were saying Cleary got off because there was no HIA meaning no head contact. The hia or lack of didn't factor and I posted the reason to prove it.

 

[Stinkfinger]

Lead with shoulder and it ended up hitting the opposition's head even tho first contact was shoulder to shoulder. A week would of been fair. Im glad he got off as it would of ruined a blockbuster.

One week wasn't an option. It was either 0 or 3, or 2 if he took the early guilty. I think they got it right in the end.

 

[Bred not Bought]

It was never a grade 2. Silly from the outset.

 

[Black Panther]

They look for specific symptoms. They arent guessing. At least not to the degree you are implying.

Similar to the Bunker then? They have all the evidence required and still f**k it up.

 

[hindy111]

One week wasn't an option. It was either 0 or 3, or 2 if he took the early guilty. I think they got it right in the end.

I agree. If it was 1 week id say fair enough but it wasnt worth 3

 

[Stinkfinger]

Similar to the Bunker then? They have all the evidence required and still f**k it up.

They have a few seconds to decide. The MRC had as long as they needed though.

 

[Black Panther]

They have a few seconds to decide. The MRC had as long as they needed though.

I was referring to the HIA decision on game day.