What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Wests Tigers' landmark deal could become NRL boardroom blueprint

sensesmaybenumbed

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,930
Some good news for the lead up to a hopefully much improved 2014.

Wests Tigers' landmark deal could become NRL boardroom blueprint




Adrian Proszenko

Chief Rugby League Reporter






''It's a historic moment for the Wests Tigers'': NRL boss Dave Smith. Photo: James Brickwood

Wests Tigers have struck a historic agreement to overhaul their corporate structure in what the NRL describes as a potential blueprint for other clubs to follow.
Fairfax Media can reveal the Balmain and Western Suburbs factions, an uneasy alliance since they merged into Wests Tigers in 1999, have agreed to a new model of seven directors - two from the Balmain side, two from Western Suburbs, and three independent board members. The landmark agreement to ensure a more harmonious relationship between the merged entities was ratified by the NRL at an extraordinary meeting between the parties on Thursday. It came just two days after Balmain and Western Suburbs met to sign off on the arrangement.
Under the new arrangement, the ARLC has agreed to cover the financial shortfall of the cash-strapped Balmain side for the next two years. Balmain must square the ledger within that period or face losing their shares in the joint venture.
Until such time as security is provided against the money lent, the two Balmain board members - Nick Di Girolamo and Danny Stapleton, who have been nominated for those spots - won't have voting rights. Western Suburbs will be represented by Tony Andreacchio and Wests Ashfield boss Simon Cook.
Advertisement
The archaic system of alternating chairmen on an annual basis will be scrapped, and the role now will go to one of the three independent directors. Those board members will be selected by the two entities from a list sourced by the NRL.
After years of backroom squabbling between the factions, the long-awaited reforms are expected to provide the Tigers with the financial and off-field stability that has been missing for much of their short history in the NRL.
''It's a historic moment for the Wests Tigers,'' NRL boss Dave Smith said. ''The club, along with the two shareholders, has shown great courage in agreeing to the changes. It's a great moment for the club and a big moment for the governance of the game in beginning to set the standard to improve the overall quality of these boards.
''Fans and members can have some confidence the newly constituted board will have the independence and business plans to grow and be great again.''
The changes - which are sure to be welcomed by stakeholders, including fans, players and officials - were agreed upon after an independent audit outlined the extent of the financial struggles under the previous arrangement.
Wests Ashfield Leagues club had previously sought control of the board in exchange for a $1 million cash injection to prevent Wests Tigers from becoming insolvent last year. The failure of the leagues club development at Rozelle was one of the factors behind Balmain being burdened with a $9.5 million debt.
Western Suburbs and Balmain have agreed on little since their union 15 years ago. However, in recent months, the parties have made a concerted effort to work more cooperatively to ensure the long-term sustainability of Wests Tigers. With the majority of NRL clubs running at a loss, the agreement highlights the role of the ARLC in assisting clubs towards sustainability. Smith said the Tigers' structure could be a blueprint for how other NRL clubs could operate in the future.
''For sure, it sets the standard,'' Smith said. ''It's very much a blueprint and a benchmark for the standard of governance we want across the whole game.''
The league provided additional funding only after it was satisfied the corporate governance issues were resolved.
Wests Tigers can now move positively towards several long-term ambitions. They include finding a new training base to replace the ageing Concord Oval, the establishment of academies in both its heartland regions and a cohesive strategy for stadiums.
Source
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
Under the new arrangement, the ARLC has agreed to cover the financial shortfall of the cash-strapped Balmain side for the next two years. Balmain must square the ledger within that period or face losing their shares in the joint venture.
Until such time as security is provided against the money lent, the two Balmain board members - Nick Di Girolamo and Danny Stapleton, who have been nominated for those spots - won't have voting rights

So at present, Wests Magpies are running the show, and if Balmain can't repay the debt within 2 years, then the Magpies are set to cease full control of the side it would seem.

Serious question - will Balmain be able to repay the money in the two years, or is this decision purely delaying the inevitable?
 

magpie4ever

First Grade
Messages
9,992
Under the new arrangement, the ARLC has agreed to cover the financial shortfall of the cash-strapped Balmain side for the next two years. Balmain must square the ledger within that period or face losing their shares in the joint venture.
Until such time as security is provided against the money lent, the two Balmain board members - Nick Di Girolamo and Danny Stapleton, who have been nominated for those spots - won't have voting rights

So at present, Wests Magpies are running the show, and if Balmain can't repay the debt within 2 years, then the Magpies are set to cease full control of the side it would seem.

Serious question - will Balmain be able to repay the money in the two years, or is this decision purely delaying the inevitable?

That was my question. While, I believe this is a move in the right direction; does anyone have any ideas how Balmain will repay the monies owed and reduce the debt.

Is re-negotiating the sale of the old leagues club site a possibility?

That is the only way forward for Balmain that I can see; unless of course a billionaire benefactor is found to cover present and future debt.
 

BuffaloRules

Coach
Messages
14,272
You would have to assume that this deal has been done on the assumption that the Balmain Leagues club can be redeveloped eventually. Otherwise, how could the loan ever be repaid?

In the meantime, the independent directors are able to outvote the Wests directors 3-2.

Not sure that this scenario can work in the long term, so will be interesting to see where we are in 2 years time.
 

Bulldog Force

Referee
Messages
20,619
It sounds like a good idea and way for the club to move forward, but I don't see how something like this can apply to clubs that aren't merged entities. Just my 2 cents.
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
That was my question. While, I believe this is a move in the right direction; does anyone have any ideas how Balmain will repay the monies owed and reduce the debt.

Is re-negotiating the sale of the old leagues club site a possibility?

That is the only way forward for Balmain that I can see; unless of course a billionaire benefactor is found to cover present and future debt.

Well first & foremost, does Balmain have an assets? If not, then i'm not sure they can service any sizeable loan. The development needs to get approved realistically within the next 12 to 18 months.

Where's Benny?
 

Matchball

Bench
Messages
2,971
I think building approval is clincher.
Planning says no to height but developers say need that for profitability.
Developers won't proceed if height reduced due to weak profitability.

Thanks Benny for not doing due diligence on planning before proceeding.
 

Matchball

Bench
Messages
2,971
News on this will come to light later on as corruption commission probes more into Obeid.
I won't say more in fear of post deletion.
Nick Di Girolomo and Benny were lobbying the man himself.
 

magpie4ever

First Grade
Messages
9,992
As much as I want to see my club, Western Suburbs Magpies return to the top level of the rugby league competition; I don't wish to see another great foundation club, Balmain, go belly up.

I hope that makes sense to the Balmain side of the joint venture.
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
As much as I want to see my club, Western Suburbs Magpies return to the top level of the rugby league competition; I don't wish to see another great foundation club, Balmain, go belly up.

I hope that makes sense to the Balmain side of the joint venture.

Sadly, its the only way Wests will return & its looking likely.
 

macnaz

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
8,352
Well first & foremost, does Balmain have an assets? If not, then i'm not sure they can service any sizeable loan. The development needs to get approved realistically within the next 12 to 18 months.

Where's Benny?

f**k off Wheres Benny !! This story has been done to death MU . Fmd do your research .
 

Front-Rower

First Grade
Messages
5,297
As much as I want to see my club, Western Suburbs Magpies return to the top level of the rugby league competition; I don't wish to see another great foundation club, Balmain, go belly up.

I hope that makes sense to the Balmain side of the joint venture.

I heard bits and pieces of talking sport's interview with Grant Mayer today. I'm sure I heard him say that the wests tigers brand was the only brand for either wests or balmain the NRL would register in the premiership. If what I heard was correct that has just closed the door for a balmain or western suburbs magpies return.
 

macnaz

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
8,352
As much as I want to see my club, Western Suburbs Magpies return to the top level of the rugby league competition; I don't wish to see another great foundation club, Balmain, go belly up.

I hope that makes sense to the Balmain side of the joint venture.

Yes it makes sense. .. BUT lets us all consider this .
The ONLY leagues club that donates money is Wests Ashfield. .. which is awesome .... so WHERE DOES THE OTHER 5 + mil come from ? ????
All the stupid in house fighting aside , cut BALMAIN you cut at least half of that sponsorship , membership, gate takings, merchandise, juniors and branding that actually makes thats extra money!!
BYall means have control but if the Tiger dies the Magpie will also die :(
 
Last edited:

Flapper

First Grade
Messages
7,825
I heard bits and pieces of talking sport's interview with Grant Mayer today. I'm sure I heard him say that the wests tigers brand was the only brand for either wests or balmain the NRL would register in the premiership. If what I heard was correct that has just closed the door for a balmain or western suburbs magpies return.

Which is really the only way. Western Suburbs Magpies as a corporate entity would have low commercial appeal and a lack of glamour for attracting fans and crowds.
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
f**k off Wheres Benny !! This story has been done to death MU . Fmd do your research .

steady on.

This story hasn't been done to death because this story only came out in the last 24 hours.

The where's Benny thing was in jest, like saying "Where's Skasey?", that much I thought was evident.
 
Top