What does your top 5 greatest NRL players of all time list look like?

[TheDalek079]

these two are the Wests '99 equivalent of forum posters. it's probably turk from the roosters forum

 

[BestHookerRein]

Guys... Stop being infatuated by us, and start talking about the topic on hand.

 

[Tarasoft11]

The other 92% bought or d/led the show.

yeah true

 

[Tarasoft11]

Mate, in England for the 2015 Season finale, 4.8mil watched it, in a population of 55mil.

That's roughly 8% watched this shitty show.... I am with the other 92%

same

 

[Tarasoft11]

Guys... Stop being infatuated by us, and start talking about the topic on hand.

besthookerrein

 

[Tarasoft11]

Too big an ask for a bloke watching the game for 50 years . . . all I can tell you is they wouldn't be immortal

yeah i only watched for 10 years and i found it hard to list
cant imagine how hard a 50 year fan would find it

 

[Puntoue]

My legitimate top five:

1. Andrew Johns
2. Darren Lockyer
3. Jonathan Thurston
4. Cooper Cronk
5. Jarryd Hayne

The top five everyone else is doing:

1. Jarred Anderson
2. Anthony Watts
3. Karl Filiga
4. Tim Moltzon
5. Shane "The Loveshack" Shackleton

 

[Tarasoft11]

besthalfbackpearce was a gentleman and a scholar

thats corrrect

 

[simmo05]

Johns, thurston, fittler, menzies, slater

 

[lafai]

Jarryd Hayne
Jonathan Thurston
Cameron Smith
Andrew Johns
Whoever the media want to dickride next

 

[Eelementary]

In all seriousness:

Manu Ma'u > all

 

[Shorty]

It's probably Besthalfbackpearce making a double comeback. The trolls are taking over.

Off season starting early this year.

 

[Eelementary]

Yeah people like -

Christopher Eccleston
Julian Glover
Michael Gough
John Cleese
Brian Blessed
Paul Darrow
Simon Pegg
Penelope Wilton
Brian Cox
Timothy Dalton
Anthony Head
Geoffrey Palmer
Michelle Ryan
John Simm
Sir Derek Jacobi
Catherine Tate
Sir Michael Gambon
Sir Ian McKellen
Dame Diana Rigg
Michael Sheen
Michelle Gomez
Peter Capaldi.

All of them are pretty dumb and cant act eh?

No love for David Tennant?

For shame...

 

[Tarasoft11]

Johns, thurston, fittler, menzies, slater

Thurston is a machine

 

[STORM.99/07]

CAM SMITH
BILLY SLATER
COOPER CRONK
Johnathan Thurston
I'll get back to you on the last one

 

[Tarasoft11]

CAM SMITH
BILLY SLATER
COOPER CRONK
Johnathan Thurston
I'll get back to you on the last one

why is it all capital letters except jonathan thurston. He is just as important!

 

[Tarasoft11]

In all seriousness:

Manu Ma'u > all

except thurston an johns

 

[MilkShark]

Cronk in the top 5? Just lol

 

[betcats]

Josh Mansour gets a run in mine.

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

John Cleese is awesome and deserves more love