What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Where Will Penrith Finish in 2020?

Where Will Penrith Finish in 2020?

  • 1-4

    Votes: 6 14.3%
  • 5-8

    Votes: 23 54.8%
  • 9-12

    Votes: 10 23.8%
  • 13-16

    Votes: 3 7.1%

  • Total voters
    42
  • Poll closed .

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
Well if you know my name use it properly, and if mxlegend99 meant that moylan eliminated us "in 2018" by himself without 12 other cronulla sharks on the field then yes i didn't get the drift, but i read it as moylan eliminated us, thus didn't play in the finals 2017 due to being his sooky self, and leaving us 5/8thless, which realistically what was written, no one mentioned which finals, or which team matty was contracted to regarding elimination,
View attachment 36338
and when we were at the SFS 2018 we destroyed ourselves and Townsend and Lewis turned us over and went for seconds.

I'm not the one you need to argue the point with. I was just helping clarify The point. As for your name I didn't even realise it was written wrong until you said something. I don't see why it's such a big issue but each to their own.
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
15,043
I'm not the one you need to argue the point with. I was just helping clarify The point. As for your name I didn't even realise it was written wrong until you said something. I don't see why it's such a big issue but each to their own.
No arguing nessesary, mxlegend99 never clarified, and you saw it one way, i saw the other,
But dude you always refer to me as muga, your the only guy who does that
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
No arguing nessesary, mxlegend99 never clarified, and you saw it one way, i saw the other,
But dude you always refer to me as muga, your the only guy who does that

I've done it once now not paying attention and showed you a funny video die to the similarity of your fake internet name I thought you'd see the funny side.
 

mxlegend99

Referee
Messages
23,327
Well if you know my name use it properly, and if mxlegend99 meant that moylan eliminated us "in 2018" by himself without 12 other cronulla sharks on the field then yes i didn't get the drift, but i read it as moylan eliminated us, thus didn't play in the finals 2017 due to being his sooky self, and leaving us 5/8thless, which realistically what was written, no one mentioned which finals, or which team matty was contracted to regarding elimination,
View attachment 36338
and when we were at the SFS 2018 we destroyed ourselves and Townsend and Lewis turned us over and went for seconds.

OldPanther was right by what I meant. I thought mentioning the Maloney / Moylan trade made it clear I was referring to 2018 as that was the year it happened.

Moylan tore us to shreds in that final... or more specifically he tore Maloney to shreds. That's why I meant by he eliminated us. I dont blame a player who isn't on the field for us losing in 2017.

We had chances that poor decisions from us cost us. As a fan of Wallace and not of Katoa... arguably the worstdecision made that night was putting Wallace back on the field after being cleared to return. The team improved when Katoa was out there and we lost the momentum when we took him off. Hook must not have been watching that game to make a call like that.
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
15,043
I've done it once now not paying attention and showed you a funny video die to the similarity of your fake internet name I thought you'd see the funny side.
Wheres the vid?, and it's my nickname, my real nickname.
Costanza/kantstanzya
 
Last edited:

MugaB

Coach
Messages
15,043
OldPanther was right by what I meant. I thought mentioning the Maloney / Moylan trade made it clear I was referring to 2018 as that was the year it happened.

Moylan tore us to shreds in that final... or more specifically he tore Maloney to shreds. That's why I meant by he eliminated us. I dont blame a player who isn't on the field for us losing in 2017.

We had chances that poor decisions from us cost us. As a fan of Wallace and not of Katoa... arguably the worstdecision made that night was putting Wallace back on the field after being cleared to return. The team improved when Katoa was out there and we lost the momentum when we took him off. Hook must not have been watching that game to make a call like that.
Yeah all good, we were still shit in 2017, with/out moyza, and just as shit with malonza 2018, even shittier last year, balls rolling south ya'll
 

Todd Hoffman

Juniors
Messages
489
Between 7-11th. Not fussed on Cleary's coaching success but every dog has their day.
Some good young ones coming through and I have a feeling about the Pennies this year.

Need to flick Luai out of the halves for Burton though. Not convinced on Luai and Burton is way more talented and a better foil for Cleary jnr.
I like Crichton and that nut Hetherington too. I would have them in the side for round 1. Both looked good in the trials.

Stay relatively injury free, get the selections right, improve the attack and you should be finals bound.
 

soc123_au

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
19,836
Between 7-11th. Not fussed on Cleary's coaching success but every dog has their day.
Some good young ones coming through and I have a feeling about the Pennies this year.

Need to flick Luai out of the halves for Burton though. Not convinced on Luai and Burton is way more talented and a better foil for Cleary jnr.
I like Crichton and that nut Hetherington too. I would have them in the side for round 1. Both looked good in the trials.

Stay relatively injury free, get the selections right, improve the attack and you should be finals bound.
Pretty much nailed it. The only thing I disagree with is Burton being a better foil for Nathan. I think Luai at has best is a better point of difference. That said I think Burton is the better player and would go with him anyway. Unfortunately Luai is a bit too scattered.
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
15,043
Had to be better after maloney left, he is great but our defence was automatically better without him, plus ivan always has had awesome 2nd year seasons, i thought top4, but didn't think top1
 

Latest posts

Top