Which big name recruit will be the biggest flop in 2013

[SpaceMonkey]

Have memories of him, fit bloke who was just up and back all day. It was his defence though which I remember him for, had everything covered....

Terrible judiciary record though, just couldn't help himself with the head shots.

 

[TheDalek079]

lol at everyone who thought SBW would be a flop :lol:

 

[roostersrule2]

lol at everyone who thought SBW would be a flop :lol:

And Maloney hahaha

 

[Hutty1986]

lol at everyone who thought SBW would be a flop :lol:

Aren't you the bloke that actually rates Mitchell Pearce?

 

[The Elephant In The room]

lol at everyone who thought SBW would be a flop :lol:

He was far from a flop, but he was also far from the stand out success you would expect from the dollars and hype that was thrown at him.

 

[betcats]

I still disagree with the way we rolled out the red carpet for that clown.

 

[Canard]

He was far from a flop, but he was also far from the stand out success you would expect from the dollars and hype that was thrown at him.

Remember when LU posters would claim that he was basically the best player to ever play Rugby League, and his return would prove that to be the case.

The guy was like the Bruce Lee of Rugby League.

 

[lockyno1]

And Maloney hahaha

Maloney has hardly been brilliant. Without SBW you don't win your premiership...without Maloney you probably still do.

 

[roostersrule2]

Maloney has hardly been brilliant. Without SBW you don't win your premiership...without Maloney you probably still do.

That's a lie.

SBW was better, but Maloney was huge. With bwaiff still in the halves we wouldn't have gone close, Maloney was brilliant in 2013.

 

[bottle]

Both $BW and Maloney were instrumental in the NFL passes that saw the Rorters win, so I think it's fair to say they both played their part.

 

[lockyno1]

That's a lie.

SBW was better, but Maloney was huge. With bwaiff still in the halves we wouldn't have gone close, Maloney was brilliant in 2013.

It was SBW's 2nd half in the GF that won the premiership, not Maloney. I stand by what I said, there is a good reason your halves look even more terrible this year...SBW isn't there to cover their ineptness. Maloney has been solid don't get me wrong, did you overpay, yes, however not by much. He isn't a bad buy, isn't a great buy, somewhere in between. Nothing wrong with that.

 

[TheDalek079]

Aren't you the bloke that actually rates Mitchell Pearce?

yeah. that kid goes alright

He was far from a flop, but he was also far from the stand out success you would expect from the dollars and hype that was thrown at him.

Voted best player in the world (RLIF international player of the year) for 2013

 

[roostersrule2]

It was SBW's 2nd half in the GF that won the premiership, not Maloney. I stand by what I said, there is a good reason your halves look even more terrible this year...SBW isn't there to cover their ineptness. Maloney has been solid don't get me wrong, did you overpay, yes, however not by much. He isn't a bad buy, isn't a great buy, somewhere in between. Nothing wrong with that.

Maloney was quite comfortably the best player in the GF, then Moa, then DCE and then SBW.

Maloney was amazing in 2013, which is what were talking about. He's been inconsistent in 2014/15 but still been decent. In 2013 he was worth every penny and than some.