Who are the biggest underachieving and overrated players in the NRL?

[Albert Rosenfeld]

Serious ratings, top 10:

Jack Bird
Aaron Woods
Corey Norman
Boyd Cordner
Josh Jackson
Jake Friend
Bryce Cartwright
Michael Lichaa (aka Michael Leesha)
Robbie Farah
Jarryd Hayne

 

[alexwilliams_66692007]

The entire 2018 Roosters team

 

[AlwaysGreen]

f**k up albert

 

[Dave_]

Josh Jackson and Boyd Cordner. They’ll walk in to the NSW starting side sadly.

2 absolute myths right there. What do they even do?

 

[Dave_]

Tom Turdbo - he's fast but... nothing else
Jack Bird - love ya work brother!
Boyd Cordner - boring vanilla piece of plod
Josh Jackson - see above
Sharon Woods - just an absolute skirt
Anthony Milfdud - fast but just garbage
James Roberts - see above
Andrew Fatfita - fat, lazy, grubby, slow PTB's
Jarrod Choker - just a dud
Thurston - getting shown up now...

Or it could just be that Kayln Ponga makes everyone else look sh*t

 

[The_Shield]

Underachieving - Cronk, Tedesco, the whole Parramatta team, Vunivalu

Overrated - Cartwright, Moses, Lodge (by media, not fans), Latrell Mitchell, Roberts, Jackson, Cordner.

I would put Hayne in there but he’s gone exactly like everyone bar Eels fans expected so yeah can’t really call him overrated or underachieving because he’s pretty much as expected.

 

[Exsilium]

Manly Sea Eagles top 30 for both categories.

 

[davi]

Next is Robbie Farah. He has been relegated to reserve grade since he played for Lebanon with Mtchell "Pimples" Moses.

Robbie Farah maybe a lot of things but a underachiever and overrated is not one of them. Farah is at the backend of his career and can't get a run because the starting hooker Damien Cook is having a superb year. Cook has also attributed Farah mentoring for the season he is having.

I think Farah made a mistake going to Souths. I think he should of gone to England and get some decent coin and experience some new surroundings before calling it quits.

 

[Albert Rosenfeld]

Robbie Farah maybe a lot of things but a underachiever and overrated is not one of them. Farah is at the backend of his career and can't get a run because the starting hooker Damien Cook is having a superb year. Cook has also attributed Farah mentoring for the season he is having.

I think Farah made a mistake going to Souths. I think he should of gone to England and get some decent coin and experience some new surroundings before calling it quits.

He should have gone to Catalans in France and learned French and enjoyed French food and wine.

 

[stormbati]

Bird looked good when he was playing with Ben Barba. But so did everyone at Cronulla.

Now that Barba is at St Helens Bird has been exposed as a lightweight. Cronulla is now wooden spoon material.

Bird is far from a lightweight.

 

[typicalfan]

Dylan Napa

 

[Cherry_poppins]

Underachieving - Cronk, Tedesco, the whole Parramatta team, Vunivalu

Overrated - Cartwright, Moses, Lodge (by media, not fans), Latrell Mitchell, Roberts, Jackson, Cordner.

I would put Hayne in there but he’s gone exactly like everyone bar Eels fans expected so yeah can’t really call him overrated or underachieving because he’s pretty much as expected.

Turned on him faster than the WCW crowd on Hogan being the 3rd man

 

[Crazyperpman]

He should have gone to Catalans in France and learned French and enjoyed French food and wine.

You forgot women with hairy armpits

 

[madunit]

He should have gone to Catalans in France and learned French and enjoyed French food and wine.

*whine

 

[Frank_Grimes]

Who currently rates Jack Bird?

 

[TheFrog]

You forgot women with hairy armpits

But a small price to pay.

 

[Travitoh]

Who currently rates Jack Bird?

Wayne Bennett

 

[Fangs]

Who currently rates Jack Bird?

Brad Fittler.

 

[mozza91]

Who currently rates Jack Bird?

The owner of his local Maccas holds him in high regard apparently.

 

[Bobby DIGital]

1. Mitchell Moses
2. Anthony Milford